An ice cube tray might seem like a simple kitchen accessory, but you’ll quickly notice the difference between a handy one and a bad buy. A tray that’s difficult to get out of the freezer, makes too few ice cubes, or doesn’t sit steadily is soon forgotten at the back of a kitchen cupboard.
For British households, these three pitfalls are particularly important:
A silicone ice cube tray is flexible. This usually makes it easier to pop the ice cubes out without having to prise each compartment loose individually. However, do bear in mind that a soft tray can be less stable when you’re filling it. A firm surface or a matching tray underneath makes it more practical to use.
Polypropylene is a plastic that tends to keep a firmer shape. That can be handy for stacking and transporting in the freezer. Always check the product information for the exact material, cleaning instructions, and whether it’s dishwasher safe.
An ice cube tray with 4 compartments is suitable for a whisky glass or a small number of drinks. A model with 12 or 32 compartments is better for everyday use, a barbecue, or when you have guests. A tray with 100 cells is particularly useful if you want to make lots of small ice cubes in one go.
Alongside the number of compartments, also look at the dimensions. A compact tray fits more easily into a full freezer, while a wider one takes up more space. Also check whether you can stack the tray safely without the compartments getting squashed.
For fizzy drinks and squash, ordinary small cubes are usually the most practical. For ice cubes for cocktails or whisky, a larger cube can be interesting because its surface area is smaller relative to its volume. Some tray product descriptions therefore mention uses like cocktails, whisky and soft drinks. That’s a usage recommendation from the seller, not a guarantee of a specific melting speed.
An ice cube tray with a lid helps prevent spills and limits exposure to freezer odours. If the model doesn’t have a lid, fill it on a stable surface and make sure there’s enough room for the water to expand as it freezes.
Why this fits the profile: This compact tray makes 12 ice cubes, making it suitable for everyday use without taking up much freezer space. The model measures 19 x 14 x 4 cm and, according to the product information, is dishwasher safe.
The flexible silicone design is intended to make it easier to release the ice cubes. The limited capacity means you don’t have to fill a large, awkward tray.
12 compartments, compact size, silicone material and dishwasher-safe according to the product information.
Why this fits the profile: With four larger compartments, this model is aimed at a limited number of drinks, cocktails and whisky. The product description mentions larger, slow-melting ice cubes as a use case.
The four compartments make the purpose clear: not a large quantity of small cubes, but a solution for specific drinks. That means you’re not paying for capacity you won’t use.
Silicone material, four larger ice cubes and dimensions of 20.5 x 15 x 6 cm.
Why this fits the profile: The capacity of 32 ice cubes suits parties, barbecues and households where several glasses are regularly filled at once. The description mentions a flexible tray and a separate base plate for filling and moving.
The base plate supports filling and transporting. This reduces the risk of a full tray tipping over while you’re moving it in the freezer.
32 compartments, polypropylene, flexible design and stackable according to the product description.
If you don’t want to set aside space for a tray, you can choose ice cube bags. These are suitable when you need a lot of ice for a party in one go. For disposable bags, check the contents, closure and usage instructions.
Reusable ice cubes are another option. A set of 10 plastic ice cubes can be washed by hand and refrozen. They won’t dilute a drink with melted water, but they cool differently to water ice. According to the product information, they are not suitable for the dishwasher.
For larger occasions, you can also buy ready-made ice cubes. A pack such as 528 Ice Cubes weighing 1 kg contains drinking water ice that is delivered frozen. Follow the instructions not to refreeze the product after it has thawed.
We’ve put together a full, up-to-date list of products that fully meet these strict selection criteria and comply with current European safety regulations.
Fill each compartment evenly and leave some space at the top, because water expands as it freezes. Place the tray flat in the freezer and let the ice freeze completely before you release the cubes. A lid or base plate helps to prevent spills and shifting.
The lifespan depends on use, cleaning and storage. Check the tray regularly for cracks, warping or lingering odours. Follow the manufacturer’s care instructions and only use the dishwasher if the product information explicitly says it’s safe.
They can be suitable if you want cooling without extra melted water. Check the material, dimensions and cleaning instructions beforehand. For cocktails where dilution is part of the recipe, ordinary ice cubes may be more practical.