Joybuy Insights

Choosing Dog and Cat Treats: What to Look For Before You Buy

Picking up a bag of dog or cat treats might seem simple. However, products can vary widely in their composition, moisture content, texture and purpose. A treat for training needs to be different from a long-lasting chew for in-between meals. Similarly, a cat that doesn't drink much might benefit more from a moist treat than from dry kibble.

As a Joybuy Product Recommendation Officer, I filter product information to highlight the practical details. This helps you quickly see which dog and cat treats are right for your pet and avoid a purchase that ends up gathering dust in the cupboard.

Three common pitfalls when buying dog and cat treats

1. An appealing flavour doesn't tell you much about the ingredients

Packaging often features large pictures of chicken, tuna or beef. That's why it's important to check the ingredients list. For example, Felix Crispies Cat Snack Beef & Chicken states that the product contains a minimum of 1% beef and 1% chicken. The base is made up of cereals, meat and animal derivatives, vegetable protein extracts, oils and fats.

This doesn't automatically make the treat unsuitable, but it's important to understand the difference between a product made “with chicken” and a treat where chicken is the main ingredient. With MeatyWay Chicken Tenders, chicken is listed as the only ingredient. The choice, therefore, depends on whether you prefer a simple or a composite recipe.

2. “Hydrating” doesn’t mean water is no longer needed

Some cat treats have a high moisture content. For instance, INABA Churu Cat Chicken lists 90.5% moisture, and INABA Fun Bites Cat Chicken Wraps Chicken with Pumpkin lists 93% moisture. This can be a practical way to add extra fluid to a reward or food topper.

However, fresh drinking water is still essential. These products are complementary foods and do not replace a complete meal or your pet's water supply. Also, be aware of the difference between a moist treat for cats and a soft treat for dogs: their composition and recommended portion sizes are not interchangeable.

3. A soft or chewy texture isn't right for every occasion

Soft dog treats are useful during training because you can give them quickly and sometimes break them into smaller pieces. A hard chew stick, on the other hand, takes longer to eat. This doesn't mean that every chew is suitable for every dog.

For a product with a hard exterior, like the Pedigree Jumbone Mini, a specific target group is mentioned: adult small dogs up to 15 kg. The packaging also specifies a limited feeding frequency. So, don't choose based on size or flavour alone; always check the age, weight, and instructions on the label.

What specifications should you check?

1. Complementary or complete food?

Most of the dog and cat treats in this range are complementary foods. They are intended as a reward, a snack, or a food topper, not as a replacement for a daily meal. An exception noted in the product information is complete dog food, such as Orijen Original Prey Dog Food.

As a practical guideline, treats should not make up more than about 10% of your pet's daily calorie intake. If necessary, reduce their main meal accordingly. For products with a stated energy content, also check the portion size: a single large treat can contain more calories than several small training treats for dogs.

2. Moisture content and nutritional values

The moisture percentage helps you distinguish a dry treat from a liquid or semi-moist one.

  • High moisture content: INABA Churu Cat Chicken lists 90.5% moisture; the INABA Fun Bites cat treats list 93%.
  • Soft dog treats: INABA Fun Bites Dog Chicken Wraps Chicken with Sweet Potato lists 82% moisture.
  • Dried treats: MeatyWay Chicken Tenders lists a maximum of 18% moisture and a minimum of 70% crude protein.

Also look at the crude protein, fat, crude fibre and ash. A grain-free dog treat isn't automatically low in calories. MeatyWay products state they have a grain-free recipe with chicken, but they still contain 5% fat. This means the total amount and daily portion size remain relevant.

3. Age, size and supervision

A product might be suitable for all life stages, only for adult animals, or specifically for kittens. For example, Felix Double as Nice Junior is intended for kittens from 6 to 52 weeks old. Pedigree Jumbone Mini is aimed at adult small dogs.

Also, pay attention to feeding guidelines:

  • Only give chews when you can supervise your pet.
  • Break larger soft dog treats into smaller portions if the packaging says this is possible.
  • Store opened moist treats in the fridge and use them within the specified time.
  • Take into account any allergies or prescribed diets, and discuss any concerns with your vet.

Our recommendations for different needs

Best for: Budget-conscious beginners
MeatyWay Chicken and Apple 100g

MeatyWay Chicken and Apple 100g

Why it's a good match: A 100 g bag with chicken and apple is straightforward for anyone comparing dog treats for the first time and looking for a simple format for daily rewards.

How this product avoids the pitfalls

The product information lists chicken and apple as ingredients and states it's a grain-free recipe with no artificial additives, fillers or preservatives.

Key benefit & plus points

100 g contents; 20% crude protein; soft, chewy texture according to the product description.

Best for: Shoppers seeking top quality
INABA CHURU CAT Chicken

INABA CHURU CAT Chicken

Why it's a good match: This soft cat treat is ideal for cat owners who want a high moisture content and a clearly defined portion per tube.

How this product avoids the pitfalls

The 90.5% moisture content is clearly stated in the product details. The treat is labelled as a complementary food, so you won't confuse it with a complete meal.

Key benefit & plus points

6 calories per treat according to the product information; 90.5% moisture; can be used as a treat, topper or reward.

Best for: Specific uses & frequent treaters
INABA Churu Dog Multipack 2 Chicken Seafood Varieties 20 pcs.

INABA Churu Dog Multipack 2 Chicken Seafood Varieties 20 pcs.

Why it's a good match: This multipack contains 20 x 12 g tubes and is practical for frequent training sessions, adding variety, or using as a food topper.

How this product avoids the pitfalls

The dosage per tube is clearer than with loose, large treats. Once opened, the tube should be refrigerated and used within 24 hours.

Key benefit & plus points

240 g total weight; minimum 90% moisture; two chicken and seafood varieties; can be used as a reward or topper.

Best for: Simple recipes
MeatyWay Chicken Tenders 100g

MeatyWay Chicken Tenders 100g

Why it's a good match: For dog owners who want the shortest possible ingredients list, this treat lists chicken as its only ingredient.

How this product avoids the pitfalls

The product information mentions no grains, fillers or artificial additives. The moisture and fat content are listed separately, making comparison easier.

Key benefit & plus points

100% chicken according to the ingredients list; minimum 70% crude protein; can be broken into pieces for portion control.

Looking for more options?

We've put together a complete, up-to-date list of products that fully meet these strict selection criteria and comply with current European safety regulations.

Frequently Asked Questions about Dog and Cat Treats

How many treats can my dog or cat have per day?

Use the recommended amount on the packaging as a starting point and adjust their main meal accordingly. As a general guideline, treats should not make up more than about 10% of their daily calorie intake. Weight, age, activity level and body condition all make a difference.

Are soft dog treats suitable for training?

Often, yes, because soft pieces can be eaten quickly and are usually easy to portion. Check if the manufacturer lists the product as a reward or training treat. Give small portions and always supervise your pet.

Are hydrating cat treats a substitute for water?

No. A product with 90% or more moisture can provide extra fluid through the treat, but fresh drinking water must always be available. Use hydrating cat treats as a complementary treat or topper, not as a replacement for complete food.