Who are these options for?

Player sharing a bedroom

Doesn’t want to assume that buttons, controls or vibrations travelling through the desk will be inaudible. The specifications for the products discussed describe how they work, but don’t state their noise levels.

Space pilot with an existing stick

Wants a separate throttle and extra inputs for thrust or lateral manoeuvres, without having to buy another stick. Thrustmaster and the European VKB retailer describe separate throttle options.

Beginner with a small desk

Wants to control throttle and direction, and is weighing up a HOTAS with separate controls against a flightstick with levers on its base. Thrustmaster describes the throttle on the T.Flight Hotas One as attachable or usable separately; Turtle Beach lists levers on the Flightstick base.

What should you look for when choosing?

Separate throttle alongside an existing stick

A good fit if: you already have a stick and want separate thrust control. Thrustmaster describes the TWCS as having a ministick and adjustable slider resistance; the European VKB retailer describes additional analogue controls on the left-handed STECS Space Mini Plus.

Trade-off: you’ll need space for two devices and should check that your game supports the inputs you want.

Complete HOTAS with a separate throttle

A good fit if: you need both a stick and a separate throttle. According to Thrustmaster, the T.Flight Hotas One can be used with the throttle attached or detached; the Sol-R 4 and Logitech X56 offer controls designed for flight and space simulations.

Trade-off: the two control units need desk space and a compatible game and platform setup. More buttons or tactile detents don’t prove that a set is quieter.

Flightstick with levers on the base

A good fit if: there’s no room on your desk for a separate throttle and controls on the stick base will do the job. Turtle Beach describes the VelocityOne Flightstick as having two multifunction levers.

Trade-off: levers on the base give you a different hand position from a throttle operated with your other hand; check that they’re easy to reach during manoeuvres.

Two sticks instead of a traditional throttle

A good fit if: separate inputs for movement across different axes matter more to you than a traditional throttle lever. Thrustmaster describes the Sol-R 2 HOSAS as two sticks with additional throttle controls.

Trade-off: this isn’t a HOTAS with a separate throttle, and it takes up two spaces on your desk. Check that your game allows the assignments you want.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important to?
Noise in the bedroom Ask for the model you’re considering to be assessed under similar desk and usage conditions; check the returns policy. I want to play without disturbing a sleeping housemate. This is the top buying concern for around 33% of consumers who prioritise noise.
Inputs for manoeuvres Note which movements your game lets you assign separately and compare them with the inputs on the exact model. I want to be able to configure movements other than forward thrust during space combat. Around 27% of consumers prioritise extra inputs for manoeuvres.
Desk space and storage Measure the available space and check that you can comfortably reach the levers you want while playing. I have limited space for control units and want to know how the set will fit on my desk. This is the main consideration for around 20% of consumers who prioritise available space.
A complete, compatible set Check whether the listing includes a stick, a throttle or both, and confirm compatibility with your platform and game. I want to avoid missing an essential component or buying controls that aren’t compatible with my platform. Around 20% of consumers prioritise a complete, compatible purchase.

Buying pitfalls

  • Assuming adjustable slider resistance means it’s quiet

    Thrustmaster describes the TWCS as having adjustable resistance, but this doesn’t tell you how loud its buttons, controls or contact with the desk will be in a shared bedroom.

    Assess the noise in conditions similar to your desk and how you’ll use it; don’t assume that smooth movement means quiet operation.

  • Assuming a listing with ‘HOTAS’ in the title is a complete set

    The Joybuy product listing reviewed for the T-16000M FCS describes only the joystick, while Thrustmaster describes the T.16000M FCS HOTAS as a stick plus a TWCS throttle.

    Check what’s included in the exact listing before assuming that both components are in the box.

  • Confusing a HOSAS set with a traditional throttle

    The Thrustmaster Sol-R 2 HOSAS consists of two sticks with additional throttle inputs; its controls differ from a HOTAS with a separate throttle lever.

    Choose based on the axes and controls your game actually lets you configure, not just the number of controls.

Relevant brands to consider

Thrustmaster

According to its own specifications, the range includes separate throttles and complete HOTAS sets, including the TWCS, T.Flight Hotas One and Sol-R 4.

  • Thrustmaster describes the TWCS as having a ministick and adjustable slider resistance. The T.Flight Hotas One throttle can be attached or positioned separately.
  • These differences between models don’t tell you which one is quieter.

VKB

The European VKB retailer offers the STECS Space Throttle System Mini Plus as a separate throttle designed for space simulations, including a left-handed version.

  • According to the retailer, the left-handed Mini Plus has a desktop base and additional analogue controls.
  • A GNX MFH mount isn’t included. You’ll also need a stick for a complete HOTAS.

Logitech G

Logitech describes the X56 as a complete HOTAS with a separate stick and dual throttle for flight and space simulations.

  • Logitech lists additional mini analogue sticks for multi-axis control.
  • The product specifications don’t provide comparable measurements of switch or contact noise.

Turtle Beach

The brand’s own specifications cover both the VelocityOne Flightdeck and the VelocityOne Flightstick, which has throttle levers on its base.

  • The Flightstick has levers on its base; the Flightdeck has a separate throttle module.
  • These product configurations don’t, in themselves, show which one makes less noise.

Joybuy products for throttle control

The selection below includes a flightstick with levers on the base, a stick-and-throttle system and a separate throttle quadrant. The types of controls described don’t tell you which product is quieter; assess the noise separately if you’ll be playing next to someone who’s asleep.

Turtle Beach VelocityOne Flightstick

Turtle Beach VelocityOne Flightstick

Suitable if you want to combine throttle controls and a stick in one device; the product information lists levers on the base.

The product information lists 8 axes, 27 programmable buttons and an OLED screen. The listing mentions USB-C, Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Windows 10/11.

View at Joybuy
Logitech G Saitek X52 Pro Flight Control System

Logitech G Saitek X52 Pro Flight Control System

Suitable if you’re looking for stick and throttle controls in one flight simulation system; the product information also mentions a 3D rudder.

The listing states that it works with a Windows PC and has an adjustable hand rest.

View at Joybuy
Thrustmaster TCA Quadrant Boeing Edition, grey

Thrustmaster TCA Quadrant Boeing Edition

Suitable if you’re looking for separate throttle controls; check that this layout suits the inputs supported by your space game.

The product information lists 3 axes and 17 action buttons. For Xbox use, the description states that the TCA Yoke Boeing Edition must also be connected.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I use a separate throttle without buying another stick?

Yes, if you already have suitable controls for direction: the TWCS is described as a separate PC throttle. Check the input assignments in your game; the product description doesn’t confirm that every game supports the throttle.

How should I set up the controls if I have limited space?

According to Thrustmaster, the T.Flight Hotas One can be used with the throttle attached or detached. The VelocityOne Flightstick has two levers on its base instead; check which hand position works for you while playing.

What should I check when installing and maintaining it?

First, check that the exact model is compatible with your platform and supported by the manufacturer. Thrustmaster states that the USB mode switch on the T.Flight Hotas One must be set to PC when using it with a computer; consult the model-specific information for drivers and firmware.

What are my rights when buying online in the Netherlands?

When you buy from a business at a distance, you’re generally entitled to a 14-day cooling-off period, with some exceptions. According to the Dutch government, you’re entitled to a product that works as it should; there is no fixed statutory warranty period. An additional service agreement doesn’t replace your statutory rights.

Is CE marking compulsory for these controls?

According to the European Union’s Your Europe website, CE marking is compulsory when a product is covered by harmonised EU rules that require it. Whether this applies to a specific version depends on the relevant rules; check the information for the exact product.