Who is this choice relevant to?

Storing a growing film archive

You keep lots of home videos on a small desk and don’t watch older recordings every day. Capacity and a separate backup matter more to you than maximum transfer speed. The Consumentenbond lists extra storage for photo and video collections as one use case.

Editing videos regularly

You often transfer large files or work directly from the external drive. In that case, both the drive and the computer port matter. ID.nl discusses an SSD as a suitable choice for working directly from an external drive.

Using the drive with several devices

For example, you watch films on both a Windows PC and a Mac. Check not only that the connection fits, but also that both devices can work with the file system. Toshiba says reformatting is required for the macOS versions listed on the Canvio Basics product page.

What should you consider when choosing?

Portable HDD

Best for: an archive you mainly store and only access occasionally.

Trade-off: an HDD is slower than an SSD, so it’s less suitable if you often move large files or edit them directly. ID.nl discusses this use case for SSDs.

External SSD

Best for: regularly transferring large videos or working directly from the drive.

Trade-off: achievable speed also depends on the port and cable. Check these before treating the advertised top speed as a given.

First work out how much space your archive needs and how often you’ll use it. Then check that the drive you choose will fit your workspace, both physically and technically.

What to consider What to look for Who this matters to
Archive space Add up your existing files, allow for expected growth and check the capacity of the exact model. The available space shown may be lower than the stated capacity; Seagate explains that formatting and units of measurement both play a part. If my film collection keeps growing, I want enough room without misjudging the usable space. Around 33% of consumers say having enough archive space is their top priority.
Desk space Compare the dimensions of the model you’re considering and check whether the drive is powered via USB. Toshiba lists dimensions of 78 × 109 × 19.5 mm and USB power for the 4 TB Canvio Basics; Crucial lists a 65 × 50 mm design for the X9. If space is limited, I want to know whether the drive and cables will fit on my desk. Around 27% of consumers put physical space and cabling first.
Transferring and editing Check the USB specification of both the drive and the computer, and make sure the cable is suitable. Samsung lists maximum read speeds of 1,050 MB/s and write speeds of 1,000 MB/s for the T7. These maximums aren’t guaranteed for every computer or use case. When I regularly copy large videos or work from the drive, I want to make sure the connection doesn’t unnecessarily slow down transfers. Around 20% of consumers prioritise speed when transferring or editing.
Backup Decide whether you’ll copy or move your films. Keep a separate copy and check that you can open a file from it; VeiligInternetten describes a backup as a copy of your files. If my films are irreplaceable, I want to be able to recover them if a drive fails or goes missing. Around 20% of consumers prioritise having a recoverable backup.

Pitfalls to avoid

  • Moving your only copy to the new drive

    If the files are only on that external drive, you won’t have a second copy to fall back on if the drive or files are lost.

    Copy your films rather than simply moving them, and regularly check that you can open a file from your backup.

  • Assuming an SSD’s maximum speed is its constant speed

    Actual transfer speeds also depend on the connection and cable you use. So an advertised maximum doesn’t automatically tell you how fast the drive will work with your computer.

    Check your computer’s port and cable before choosing a model based on speed.

  • Looking only at the TB capacity or USB plug

    Usable space may be lower than the stated capacity. Also, not every format works with every device. Toshiba says the Canvio Basics comes formatted as NTFS for Windows, and that reformatting is required for the macOS versions listed on its product page.

    Check the usable space, formatting and devices you want to watch your films on. Back up any existing files before formatting.

Brands to compare

Toshiba

Canvio Basics is a portable HDD range for storing a film archive.

  • Toshiba lists USB power and models with capacities of up to 4 TB. For the 4 TB model, the manufacturer gives dimensions of 78 × 109 × 19.5 mm.
  • The drive comes formatted as NTFS for Windows. Reformatting is required for the macOS versions listed on Toshiba’s EMEA product page.

Seagate

Expansion Portable is a portable HDD range with a choice of capacities for archive storage.

  • Seagate lists models with capacities including 1, 2, 4 and 5 TB, powered via the USB cable supplied.
  • The dimensions of 115.3 × 80.0 × 20.9 mm apply to the 5 TB model. Seagate says reformatting is required for use with Time Machine.

Samsung

The Portable SSD T7 is an external SSD option for anyone who regularly transfers files or works from the drive.

  • For the T7, Samsung lists maximum sequential read and write speeds of 1,050 and 1,000 MB/s, as well as USB-C to USB-C and USB-C to USB-A cables.
  • These are manufacturer specifications. Achievable speed depends on the connection and usage conditions.

Crucial

The X9 is an external SSD range with a compact casing and USB-C connection.

  • For the X9, Crucial lists a 65 × 50 mm design and a maximum read speed of 1,050 MB/s under the conditions specified by the manufacturer.
  • Crucial notes that compatibility depends on the formatting and host device.

Joybuy products

This selection includes portable HDDs for storing a film archive and external SSDs for anyone who regularly transfers or edits files.

SanDisk Portable SSD 1TB

SanDisk Portable SSD 1TB

A portable SSD for home videos and a compact workspace.

1 TB; the product description lists read speeds of up to 800 MB/s and drop protection from heights of up to 2 metres.

View at Joybuy
SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1TB, 2000 MB/s

SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1TB, 2000 MB/s

A portable SSD for anyone who regularly transfers large video files.

1 TB; the product description lists USB-C and read speeds of up to 2,000 MB/s with a compatible device. Dimensions: approximately 8.5 × 5.1 × 1.0 cm; weight: 46.9 g.

View at Joybuy
My Passport 2TB Blue portable hard drive

My Passport 2TB Blue

A portable HDD for a film collection if storage is your main priority.

2 TB; the product description lists USB 3.0 and 256-bit AES hardware encryption.

View at Joybuy
My Passport 4TB Black portable hard drive

My Passport 4TB Black

A portable HDD for anyone looking to store a growing film collection.

4 TB; the product description lists USB 3.0 and 256-bit AES hardware encryption. Dimensions: 75 × 107.2 × 19.15 mm; USB-powered.

View at Joybuy
Western Digital My Passport USB-C 4TB Black

Western Digital My Passport USB-C 4TB Black

A portable HDD for a film collection on a desk with little room for a separate power supply.

4 TB; the product description lists exFAT, compatibility with Windows and macOS, dimensions of 75 × 108 × 19.1 mm and USB bus power.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is an external drive with all my home videos also a backup?

Only if you also have a copy stored somewhere else. A backup is a copy you can use if files or a device are lost. If you move your only copies to the external drive, you won’t have a backup.

Can I use a Toshiba Canvio Basics with my Mac straight away?

Don’t assume so without checking. Toshiba says the Canvio Basics comes formatted as NTFS for Windows, and that reformatting is required for the macOS versions listed on its EMEA product page. Save any existing files elsewhere before formatting.

Do I need a separate power adapter for a portable HDD?

Not for the Toshiba Canvio Basics and Seagate Expansion Portable models reviewed: both manufacturers describe them as USB-powered. Check the exact model you choose, as connections and power requirements can vary between models.

What if my external drive fails after the manufacturer’s warranty has expired?

In the Netherlands, there is no fixed statutory period for the legal guarantee. According to the Rijksoverheid, what matters is what you could reasonably expect from the product. If a product is faulty, contact the seller. A warranty scheme is no substitute for keeping a separate backup of your films.