Groups with fragile maps
If you want to digitise maps with tears, loose pigment or fragile bindings, you’ll need to take the condition of the original into account. Choose a method that avoids unnecessary pressure and contact with the surface.
Measure the maps and first assess whether they can safely lie flat or need to be captured carefully from above. An overhead book scanner is an obvious choice for bound or fragile maps; a flatbed scanner may suit maps that can safely lie on the glass and fit within the scanning area. Larger originals need a solution with a suitable capture size, and a test scan can help you assess detail and visible artefacts.
If you want to digitise maps with tears, loose pigment or fragile bindings, you’ll need to take the condition of the original into account. Choose a method that avoids unnecessary pressure and contact with the surface.
Measure any maps that might not fit in a single A3 or A2+ capture. Then compare their dimensions with the scanner’s effective scanning area.
For small place names, fine lines and colours, test scans and visual checks of the files are important parts of choosing a scanner.
Measure representative maps and assess their condition before choosing a scanner type. Then check that the capture size, handling of the originals and desired file quality suit your group’s work.
| What to consider | What to look for when buying | Who is this most important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Map size | Measure both sides, including the edges, and compare them with the effective scanning area. Check whether the entire map fits in a single capture. | If the maps vary in size, I want to avoid edges being cut off or having to stitch captures together. Around 31% of consumers prioritise a suitable scanning size. |
| Condition of the original | Assess any tears, binding and fragile surfaces. Check whether contact with glass, pressure or feeding through the scanner can be avoided. | For fragile or bound maps, I want a method that puts as little strain as possible on the original. Around 25% of consumers prioritise preserving the original. |
| Detail and colour | Make test scans of small lettering, lines and blocks of colour. Also check the result visually for artefacts. | If volunteers need to study place names and fine map lines later, I want to check those details in a test scan. Around 25% of consumers give image quality the highest priority. |
| Workflow for volunteers | Check software compatibility and export options. Ask for a demonstration using a representative map. | When several volunteers are capturing and checking maps, I want a workflow everyone can follow. Around 19% of consumers prioritise a practical workflow for volunteers. |
The effective scanning area determines whether the entire map fits in a single capture. If a map is too large, you may need to make extra captures and stitch them together manually.
Measure a representative large map and compare both dimensions with the capture area of the model you’re considering.
Allow extra time for stitching if a map won’t fit in a single capture.
A wide scanning area doesn’t tell you whether a fragile, loose original can be fed through the scanner.
Assess the condition of the map first. If the material is fragile, choose an overhead capture method where necessary.
A stated resolution or automatic correction alone doesn’t show whether the lighting, lines, colours and edges have been captured well in the final file.
Make a test scan and check small lettering, map edges, straight lines and colours. Metamorfoze describes visual assessment of artefacts as well as technical checks.
Allow time for test scans, visual checks and, if necessary, recapturing the map.
The ET series offers an overhead option for bound materials up to the A3 size specified by the manufacturer.
The BookTEK 5 V2 is an overhead option for maps or open books that fit within A2+.
The OS A1 is a configurable overhead setup for larger or varied originals.
The OpticBook A300 Plus is a flatbed book scanner for originals that can safely lie on glass.
The HD Ultra X series includes large-format sheet-feed scanners for loose maps, where feeding the original through the scanner is suitable.
This Joybuy selection is intended for flat historical maps up to A3 in size.
No image available
Could suit flat maps up to A3 in size; measure your maps and check that they can safely lie flat before choosing this model.
The product title states that it supports flat sheets up to A3. Larger maps exceed that specified size.
No, not simply because the maps are historical. Metamorfoze describes quality levels for its own preservation programme. Choose a workflow that suits your intended quality level and any project requirements.
Assess the condition of each original and avoid pressure, contact with the surface or feeding it through the scanner if the material can’t withstand it. Metamorfoze advises avoiding contact with the surface of drawings; use an appropriate, careful method for fragile maps.
Not automatically: check each map to see whether copyright or other applicable terms of use still apply. The Dutch government explains that permission may be needed to make protected works available to the public; a map’s age alone doesn’t establish its copyright status.
Check that the software works with your group’s computers and that the scanner can export the files you need. For professional systems, also ask about the configuration, installation and support required for your intended workflow.