Who is this guide for?

Listener on a noisy train

You want to follow soft piano passages without constantly turning up the volume. So pay attention to fit and noise reduction. The World Health Organization recommends well-fitting noise-cancelling headphones in noisy situations.

Discerning piano listener

You want to hear how a recording you know sounds and compare the effect of different sound settings. The Consumers’ Association includes classical music in its listening tests.

Traveller who wants to hear announcements

You want to be able to switch between music and outside noise during your journey. Check whether the model you choose has an ambient mode and whether it’s easy to use.

What should you look for?

Over-ear with ANC

A good fit if: you want to listen on longer, noisier journeys and find ear cups comfortable.

The trade-off: over-ear models can be comfortable for long listening sessions, but take up room in your bag. ANC won’t automatically make announcements audible.

In-ear with ANC

A good fit if: portability matters and you can find in-ear earbuds that stay comfortable and seal well.

The trade-off: the seal and comfort depend on how well they fit your ears.

Letting in more outside noise

A good fit if: being able to hear announcements matters more to you than blocking out as much train noise as possible.

The trade-off: more outside noise can drown out soft piano passages; don’t automatically turn up the volume to compensate.

The table sets out four possible priorities to start with when making your choice. Compare the fit and sound settings using a recording you know well at a moderate volume.

What to consider What should you check? Who might find this especially important?
Reducing train noise Compare fit and ANC; also check how to use the ambient mode. If I want to keep hearing soft passages on a noisy train without turning up the volume, I’ll start by checking the fit and noise reduction. Around 36% of consumers say reducing train noise is their top buying priority.
Piano sound Listen to soft and powerful passages from the same recording; check which EQ settings are available. If I mainly want to judge how a recital recording sounds, I’ll compare it with a recording I know well. Around 29% of consumers give piano sound top priority.
Comfort and portability If possible, try them on for a longer period and see how the model fits in your bag. For a whole journey, I want headphones that stay comfortable and are practical to carry. Comfort and portability are the top buying priorities for around 21% of consumers.
Outside noise and controls Check whether the exact model has an ambient mode and how easily you can switch it on. If I want to hear announcements, I’d rather have easy access to outside noise than maximum isolation. Around 14% of consumers put awareness of their surroundings first.

Things to watch out for when buying

  • ANC is no reason to turn up the volume

    Listening at high volumes for long periods can damage your hearing. Noise cancellation can help reduce the need for extra volume in noisy surroundings, but it doesn’t replace the need to pay attention to volume and listening time.

    First check the fit and noise reduction, keep the volume moderate and take breaks during long listening sessions. The World Health Organization recommends well-fitting noise-cancelling headphones in noisy situations.

  • Maximum battery life figures aren’t automatically comparable

    Manufacturers sometimes give different maximum figures for use with and without ANC. A maximum figure on its own doesn’t tell you how long the battery will last on your train journey with noise cancellation switched on.

    Only compare battery life under the same conditions, and treat manufacturers’ figures as stated claims rather than independent test results.

  • Check the full version and bundle

    A revised version may have different components from the original. A bundle may also include accessories that aren’t supplied with the standalone version.

    Check the full model name and what’s included in the box before comparing versions. Fairphone describes updated drivers for the revised Fairbuds XL; JBL lists a transmitter included with the Tour One M3 Smart Tx.

Brands to compare

Sony

The WH-1000XM6 is an over-ear model worth comparing if you want ANC, an ambient mode and the option to listen wirelessly or with a cable.

  • Sony Netherlands states a maximum of 30 hours of music playback with noise cancellation on and up to 40 hours with it off.
  • The two battery figures are based on different usage conditions and don’t tell you how a piano recital will sound to you.

Sennheiser

The MOMENTUM 4 Wireless is worth comparing if you’re looking for adaptive ANC, an ambient mode and adjustable sound.

  • Sonova Consumer Hearing gives the MOMENTUM 4 Wireless a maximum playback time of 60 hours.
  • Only compare battery figures when the usage conditions are known and the same. The MOMENTUM 5 Wireless is a separate version.

JBL

The Tour One M3 is an over-ear ANC model worth comparing if you want a USB-C or 3.5mm audio connection as well as Bluetooth.

  • JBL Netherlands states that the Tour One M3 offers up to 70 hours of music playback.
  • This maximum isn’t directly comparable with other models’ battery figures when ANC is on. The Tour One M3 Smart Tx is a different bundle that includes a transmitter.

Fairphone

The revised Fairbuds XL is worth comparing if you’re looking for over-ear headphones with ANC and replaceable parts.

  • For the version shown, Fairphone states a maximum playback time of 26 hours with ANC on and a replaceable battery.
  • The revised version has different drivers from the original Fairbuds XL; don’t assume they’re the same product.

Headphones and earbuds at Joybuy

This selection includes over-ear headphones and in-ear earbuds with noise cancellation for listening on a train journey. Compare the fit, controls for outside noise and available sound settings for each model.

Sennheiser MOMENTUM 4 Wireless, white wireless over-ear headphones

Sennheiser MOMENTUM 4 Wireless, white

An option if you want to reduce train noise and adjust the sound of a recital recording.

The product description lists adaptive ANC, a transparency mode and EQ settings via the Smart Control app.

View at Joybuy
Sonos Ace over-ear Bluetooth headphones, black

Sonos Ace, black

An option if you want to use noise cancellation and an ambient sound setting while listening to piano music.

The product description lists ANC, Aware mode, EQ via the Sonos app and wired audio via USB-C or 3.5 mm.

View at Joybuy
Bose QuietComfort Ultra Earbuds, 2nd Gen, black

Bose QuietComfort Ultra Earbuds, 2nd Gen, black

An option if you’re looking for compact earbuds with noise cancellation and an ambient sound mode.

The product description lists CustomTune, Aware mode and a Fit Kit with three sizes of ear tips and stability bands. Don’t use noise cancellation in situations where hearing your surroundings is important for safety.

View at Joybuy
Sony WF-C710N wireless noise-cancelling earbuds, blue

Sony WF-C710N, blue

An option if you want to compare compact earbuds for travelling and listening with noise cancellation.

The product description lists ANC, Ambient Sound Mode, multipoint connectivity and touch controls. Don’t use noise cancellation when it’s important for your safety to hear outside noise.

View at Joybuy
Bose QuietComfort Ultra Headphones, 2nd Gen, black

Bose QuietComfort Ultra Headphones, 2nd Gen, black

An option if you want to combine noise cancellation with the choice of wireless or wired listening.

The product description lists Bluetooth 5.4 and a detachable cable with USB-C and 3.5mm connectors. The headphones are supplied without a charger; the description doesn’t mention support for PD fast charging.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do I need ANC to hear soft piano passages?

Not necessarily. Start with a good fit and a moderate volume. The World Health Organization recommends well-fitting noise-cancelling headphones in noisy situations to reduce the need for higher volumes; also pay attention to how long and how loudly you listen.

How can I switch back to outside noise during a recital?

Before buying, check whether the exact model has an ambient mode and try out how to use it. For example, Sonova Consumer Hearing lists a transparency mode for the Sennheiser MOMENTUM 4 Wireless; features and controls vary by model.

Should I buy an extended warranty in case the battery develops a problem?

An extended warranty product is not the same as your statutory rights. The Dutch government explains that there is no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands and that a product must meet the standards you can reasonably expect. Check what additional rights a paid warranty product offers; normal wear and tear or damage caused by your own use isn’t automatically covered under the same terms.

Can I listen to music in a quiet carriage in the Netherlands?

NS describes the quiet carriage as a place where passengers should keep quiet. Make sure other passengers can’t hear your music. NS’s guidance doesn’t make a separate statement about whether you’re required to wear headphones.

Do new headphones in the Netherlands have to have a USB-C connection?

According to the Dutch government, the USB-C rule has applied to new devices on the Dutch market, including headphones, since 28 December 2024. This doesn’t mean that every older or second-hand pair of headphones has a USB-C connection.