Who is this buying guide for?

Listeners who want to reduce train noise

If the sound of the train drowns out quieter passages, compare the fit and noise-cancelling performance of specific models. Try your recording at a moderate volume.

Listeners who want to hear the details in nature recordings

Want to pick out birds, wind and water in a familiar recording, for example? Listen to that recording yourself and assess both the sound and the fit. An ANC label alone won’t tell you how the details will sound.

Travellers who want to hear announcements

If you want to stay alert to your surroundings while listening, check how to pause playback or let in ambient sound. An open design will also let in more train noise.

What should you look for when choosing?

Over-ear with ANC

A good fit if: you listen for long periods and train noise drowns out your recording; compare the noise reduction and try your own recording.

The trade-off: according to the Consumers’ Association, over-ear headphones can be comfortable during long listening sessions, but take up more room in your bag.

In-ear with ANC

A good fit if: you want to save space in your bag and earbuds fit snugly in your ears.

The trade-off: the seal depends on your ears and the eartips you choose; also check the listening time per charge.

Letting in more ambient sound

A good fit if: you want to hear announcements quickly and are less concerned about sound isolation.

The trade-off: an open design lets in more train noise too. Transparency mode requires you to switch it on, and doesn’t guarantee you’ll hear every announcement.

What to consider What to look for when buying Who should pay particular attention?
Reducing train noise Compare the fit and the noise reduction of specific models; try your own recording at a moderate volume. If I miss quieter passages because of the train noise, I don’t want to keep turning up the volume. Around 36% of consumers prioritise reducing train noise.
Details in the recording Listen to the same familiar recording on different models and compare the sound at the same moderate volume. I want to be able to pick out birds, wind or water in my recording, even when the train is moving. Around 29% of consumers give these details top priority.
Hearing announcements Check whether it’s easy to pause playback or switch on transparency or ambient sound mode. If I don’t want to miss an announcement, I want to be able to focus on my surroundings quickly. Around 21% of consumers prioritise staying alert to their surroundings.
Comfort and portability Try the headphones during longer listening sessions and check their folded size and battery life with your chosen ANC setting. I want a comfortable fit that leaves enough room in my bag. Around 14% of consumers give comfort and portability top priority.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming ANC guarantees silence on your train route

    Noise reduction varies by model and sound. An ANC label doesn’t tell you how much train noise you’ll hear on a particular journey.

    Compare the noise reduction of specific models and try the same nature recording with comfortable headphones at a moderate volume.

  • Comparing battery life including the charging case with use per charge

    These figures are based on different usage conditions. Sony states that the WF-1000XM6 offers up to 8 hours of music playback per charge with noise cancelling on.

    Check the stated listening time per charge and compare models using the same ANC setting. Manufacturers’ figures don’t guarantee real-world battery life.

  • Not testing how easy it is to stay alert before travelling

    Transparency mode or an open design doesn’t replace paying attention to announcements yourself. An open design also lets in more train noise.

    Before you travel, try pausing the recording quickly or switching on ambient sound mode.

  • Confusing the manufacturer’s warranty with your statutory rights

    A manufacturer’s warranty or additional cover is separate from your statutory rights if a product is faulty.

    Check what any additional cover includes and contact the retailer if there’s a fault. The Dutch government explains that there is no fixed statutory warranty period for every product in the Netherlands.

Brands to compare

Sony

These Sony models include both over-ear and compact in-ear options to suit different fit preferences.

  • Sony states that the WF-1000XM6 has an ambient sound mode and offers up to 8 hours of music playback per charge with ANC on.
  • Sony describes the WH-1000XM6’s ANC as its most advanced to date. That’s a manufacturer claim, not an independent comparison of performance on a train journey.

Sennheiser

The MOMENTUM 4 Denim is an over-ear model to compare if adjustable sound and letting in ambient noise are important to you.

  • Sennheiser lists an equaliser, adaptive ANC, transparency mode and up to 60 hours of playback.
  • The stated playback time and sound settings don’t show how quiet details will sound on a particular train journey; also check the exact version.

JBL

The Tour One M3 is an over-ear option to compare if connectivity and adaptive noise cancelling are important to you.

  • JBL lists adaptive ANC, USB-C and a 3.5mm connection for the Tour One M3.
  • JBL states that total music playback can last up to 70 hours; don’t compare this figure with battery life under different ANC conditions. The Tour One M3 Smart Tx is a separate version that comes with a transmitter.

soundcore

The Space One is an over-ear model to compare if you want to weigh up adjustable transparency and battery life with ANC on.

  • soundcore lists five transparency levels and a stated battery life of 40 hours with ANC on.
  • The manufacturer’s figures don’t tell you how much train noise or recording detail you’ll hear on your journey.

Joybuy products

These Joybuy products include over-ear and in-ear models with noise cancelling. Focus on comparing fit, controls and the features that matter for your recording and train journey.

AirPods Max 2, Starlight

AirPods Max 2, Starlight

An over-ear option to compare if you’re weighing up noise cancelling against the ability to let in ambient sound.

View at Joybuy
Sennheiser MOMENTUM 4 Wireless, black

Sennheiser MOMENTUM 4 Wireless, black

An over-ear option to compare if you’re weighing up noise cancelling, sound settings and ambient sound.

Stated battery life: 60 hours.

View at Joybuy
Bose QuietComfort Headphones (2nd Gen), Rosewood Mauve

Bose QuietComfort Headphones (2nd Gen), Rosewood Mauve

An over-ear model to compare if you’re weighing up noise cancelling and an ambient sound mode; check beforehand how the controls work for you.

View at Joybuy
Samsung Galaxy Buds4 Pro, black

Samsung Galaxy Buds4 Pro, black

A compact in-ear option with active noise cancelling to compare if space in your bag matters; check which eartips feel comfortable and fit well.

View at Joybuy
MINISO MG210, black

MINISO MG210, black

An over-ear option with noise cancelling to compare if you want to reduce train noise during your journey.

Stated battery life: 24 hours.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Should I leave ANC on for the whole train journey?

No. Use the setting that lets you listen to your recording at a moderate volume, and pause playback or switch to ambient sound when you need to pay attention to an announcement. Check how the controls work on the specific model.

How do I choose eartips for a good seal?

Try different sizes and use the eartips that feel comfortable and fit snugly. Sony lists sound-isolating eartips for the WF-1000XM6; you’ll need to decide for yourself which size fits you best.

Can I play nature recordings in a quiet carriage on NS trains?

NS rules state that quiet carriages must be genuinely quiet, and that passengers mustn’t disturb each other with loud music on the train. So listen without making your audio audible to other passengers. This is an NS rule.

What are my rights if headphones bought online aren’t suitable or are faulty?

For a standard online purchase, ACM ConsuWijzer says you generally have up to 14 days from delivery to change your mind. Check the applicable exceptions first, including rules that may apply if the seal on a hygiene product has been broken. A fault is a separate matter: the Dutch government says you should contact the retailer about a faulty product. There is no fixed statutory warranty period for every product in the Netherlands.