Manager of a growing photo archive
You collect photos from several families and need enough space, along with a process that lets you restore a missing or damaged file.
Start by working out how much space your current photo archive needs, how much it is expected to grow and whether you need to keep different versions. Then check that the connection, file system and security features suit the group’s computers and the people managing the archive. An HDD suits an archive that is mostly managed in one place, while an SSD is worth considering if volunteers often take the drive with them or transfer large numbers of photos. Neither replaces a separate copy that you can restore.
You collect photos from several families and need enough space, along with a process that lets you restore a missing or damaged file.
You manage identifiable photos on behalf of the group and need to agree on access, appropriate security and retention periods based on how they are used.
You take the drive with you and want its connection, cable and file system to work with the computers you use to copy or restore photos.
For a shared photo archive, the choice between an HDD and an SSD mainly depends on where the drive will be used and how often volunteers transfer files.
A good fit when: the archive is usually managed in one place and you mainly need storage space.
Bear in mind: an HDD has moving parts and is more vulnerable to knocks while being transported, according to the Consumentenbond in a 2022 buying guide.
A good fit when: volunteers often take the drive with them or regularly transfer large numbers of photos.
Bear in mind: a model’s stated maximum speed only applies under the specified connection conditions and does not guarantee how quickly your entire photo archive will copy.
| What to consider | What to look for when buying | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Restorable backup copies | Decide which folders and versions will be copied, where a second copy will be kept and who will regularly test restoring files. | If I want to be able to restore photos after losing them, I look beyond the drive itself to the copying and recovery process. Around 26% of consumers put recoverability first. |
| Space for the archive | Measure the current photo folders and estimate how quickly they will grow; count any versions you want to keep separately. | When I collect photos from several families, I want to know how much space those files take up together and how much growth to expect. Around 21% of consumers are mainly looking for enough archive space. |
| Access to identifiable photos | Check the security features of the exact model and agree who can access it and how administrators will manage that access. | If the group stores photos of identifiable people, I want to manage access carefully and choose appropriate security. Around 21% of consumers put privacy first. |
| Computer compatibility | Check operating systems, ports, cables, file system and intended backup software before transferring files. | When volunteers use different computers, I want them to be able to copy and restore files without first having to change the process. Around 16% of consumers consider compatibility the most important factor. |
| Transport and transfer | Consider how often the drive will be taken out and whether the computer and cable support the connection needed for the stated speed. | If I often take the drive with me or transfer large photo folders, portability matters to me. Around 16% of consumers prioritise mobile use and transferring files. |
A backup is only useful if you can restore files from it. If the original and the only copy are lost at the same time, that copy cannot help you recover anything.
Keep a separate copy and regularly test restoring a file.
A matching plug does not necessarily mean the file system and backup software will work on every computer in the group. Toshiba says the Canvio Ready model tested was formatted for Windows and may need to be reformatted for use with macOS.
Before transferring files, check the ports, cables, file system and intended software on the computers the volunteers use.
A brand may offer models with different security features. The product range name alone does not tell you what protection a specific model includes.
Check the full model code and the security specifications for that model; also agree separately who will have access.
Canvio Ready is a range of portable HDDs; Canvio Advance is a separate range.
My Passport is a range of portable HDDs; the black 2 TB model tested has the model code WDBYVG0020BBK-WESN.
The Portable SSD T9 is a range of SSDs for people who use an external drive to transfer files.
Kingston offers the XS1000 as a portable SSD range, as well as a Dual Portable SSD for devices with USB-A and USB-C.
Expansion Portable is a range of portable HDDs; check the full model code to identify the right model and connection.
This selection includes portable HDDs and SSDs for storing or transferring a shared photo archive. Compare the capacity, connection and any security features for each model.
No image available
Worth comparing if you need space for a growing photo archive.
6 TB; password protection; automatic backup software.
No image available
Worth comparing if you’re looking for a portable HDD for your photo archive.
4 TB; password protection; automatic backup software.
No image available
An HDD worth comparing if you mainly need space for a photo archive.
4 TB; 2.5-inch; Micro-USB B; USB 2.0/3.2 Gen 1 (3.1 Gen 1); black.
No image available
An SSD worth comparing if volunteers take the drive between computers.
2 TB; USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2 (3.1 Gen 2); blue.
No image available
An SSD worth comparing if you’re looking for a compact drive to use with photos across different devices.
2 TB; USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2x2; black.
First, measure your current collection and estimate how many new photos and saved versions will be added; then choose a capacity. For a full Mac backup using Time Machine, Apple recommends a drive with at least twice the Mac’s storage capacity. That recommendation does not automatically apply to copying photo folders only.
First, check the file system and backup software your group plans to use. Toshiba says the Canvio Ready model tested was formatted for Windows and may need to be reformatted for use with macOS; formatting can erase existing files. Follow Apple’s instructions for Time Machine.
No. Don’t assume that a hardware warranty also covers data recovery. Seagate says data loss and recovery costs are not covered by its limited warranty unless applicable Rescue coverage applies. EU rules on the statutory consumer guarantee apply to consumer purchases, so establish who the contracting party is and which terms apply to the purchase.
If the group processes personal data as an organisation, it must assess which GDPR obligations apply. The Dutch Data Protection Authority considers identifiable people in photos to be personal data; an organisation must determine, among other things, an appropriate legal basis, security measures and retention period. The exception for strictly personal or household use depends on who processes the photos and how limited their sharing is. A password on a drive does not, by itself, prove compliance.
On behalf of the organisation, immediately assess whether personal data has become inaccessible or may have been accessed without authorisation. The Dutch Data Protection Authority advises limiting the impact, assessing whether the incident must be reported and recording it internally; whether the Authority and affected individuals need to be notified depends on that assessment.