Who is this choice relevant to?

Moving house with irreplaceable photos

You want to make an extra copy before packing, check that you can open the files and avoid having all your copies travel together. Dutch Photo Academy recommends keeping at least one backup outside your home.

Photographer with a large archive

You want to work out how much space your entire collection needs and compare it with the capacity of a portable HDD or SSD. Toshiba, Seagate and Crucial list a range of capacities for the product lines reviewed.

Photographer who takes their drive with them

You use your copy in different places, so you want to compare each model’s connections, stated speed and any protection features. Samsung and Crucial’s specifications apply to the stated models and conditions.

What should you look for in an external drive?

Portable HDD

Good for: anyone looking for plenty of space for a large photo collection who can transport the drive with care.

Bear in mind: check the connection and formatting for your computer; the Toshiba Canvio Basics reviewed comes preformatted for Windows.

Portable SSD

Good for: anyone who takes their drive with them often or regularly transfers large files, and wants to match the exact model’s specifications to their computer.

Bear in mind: maximum speeds depend on the connection and computer; drop and water protection vary by model.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Restorable copy Copy your photos, exports and, if needed, catalogue separately. Check that you can open the files you need from the copy. If I want to be able to recover both my photos and my catalogue after the move, I want to check both. For around 40% of consumers, the ability to restore files is the main priority.
Capacity Compare the total size of the files you want to keep with the stated capacity. Formatting can use up some space. I want to make sure my entire archive, including any exports, will fit on the drive. Capacity is the main priority for around 30% of consumers.
Protection during transport Check the claims for the exact model and the conditions, such as the stated drop test. An SSD isn’t automatically protected against every drop or immersion in water. If the drive will travel with me often during the move, I want to know what protection this specific model offers. This is the top priority for around 20% of consumers.
Connection and copying time Check the ports, cables and file format. Maximum speeds apply under stated conditions and don’t directly predict how long your full backup will take. I want to use the drive without connection issues and make the copy within the time I have available. For around 10% of consumers, connection, file format or speed is the main priority.

Common mistakes

  • Moving your photos to one external drive and deleting the originals

    If that drive becomes your only copy, you won’t have a separate backup.

    Copy the files rather than moving them, check the copy and keep another copy in a separate location.

  • Backing up only your photo catalogue

    Adobe states that a backup from Lightroom Classic contains only the catalogue file, not the photos themselves.

    Also make separate copies of the photos and any export files you want to keep.

  • Assuming the SSD’s maximum speed is the speed of your own backup

    A manufacturer’s stated speed depends on factors including the connection and computer.

    Check your USB port and cable. Don’t choose a drive just because it has a higher speed rating if your setup may not be able to make use of it.

  • Assuming every portable drive works straight away with every computer

    Connections and default formats vary by model; some computers may require the drive to be reformatted.

    Before copying, check the ports, supplied cable and formatting. Secure any existing data first if you’re going to reformat the drive.

    You may need another cable or allow time for reformatting.

Brands to compare

Samsung

The portable T7 SSD is a compact storage option; the T7 Shield is a separate, ruggedised product line. The Shield’s features don’t automatically apply to the standard T7.

  • Samsung states that the 2 TB T7 offers read speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s and write speeds of up to 1.000 MB/s via USB 3.2 Gen 2. These are manufacturer specifications, not speeds measured on your computer.
  • For the T7 reviewed, Samsung lists optional password protection and USB-C-to-C and USB-C-to-A cables in the box.

Toshiba

Canvio Basics is a range of USB-powered portable HDDs for anyone comparing capacity for a backup.

  • Toshiba lists 1 TB, 2 TB and 4 TB versions.
  • The Canvio Basics reviewed is formatted for Windows. Toshiba says it needs to be reformatted for the macOS versions listed; the supplied cable is Type-A-to-Micro-B.

Seagate

Expansion Portable is a USB-powered portable HDD, so it doesn’t need a separate power supply.

  • The Seagate datasheet consulted lists a USB 3.0 cable and a 2 TB version with model number STKM2000400.
  • The datasheet states that the Rescue Data Recovery Services mentioned aren’t available in every country.

Crucial

The X9 Pro is a range of portable SSDs; compare connection requirements and protection claims for each version.

  • For the 2 TB version reviewed, Crucial states speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s, depending on the system and USB 3.2 Gen 2. The drive is supplied in exFAT format.
  • Crucial limits the stated drop test to a drop onto carpet and advises against immersion in water.

Joybuy products

This selection includes portable SSDs and HDDs for making and carrying an extra copy of your photo archive.

SanDisk Portable SSD 1 TB

SanDisk Portable SSD 1TB

A portable SSD with 1 TB of storage for an extra copy of your photos and files.

Read speeds of up to 800 MB/s; the description states drop protection up to 2 metres.

Joybuy
SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1 TB

SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1TB

This 1 TB SSD is an option if you want a portable backup and this model’s protection and connection requirements suit the way you’ll use it.

The description states IP65 and drop protection up to 3 metres. The maximum read speed of 2.000 MB/s requires a compatible USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 host; write speeds are lower. Clean and dry the casing after exposure to water before using the drive.

Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 1 TB USB-C, Graphite Black

WD Elements Portable 1TB USB-C, Graphite Black

A portable HDD with 1 TB of storage for an extra copy of your photos and other files.

The description lists USB-C and plug-and-play use. Avoid dropping, shaking or subjecting the drive to strong impacts.

Joybuy
Portable SSD 1 TB 1.000 MB/s

Portable SSD 1TB 1000MB/s

A portable SSD with 1 TB of storage for an extra copy of your photos and other large files.

According to the description, the maximum read speed of 1.000 MB/s requires a compatible USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 host; write speeds are lower. The available storage is less than 1 TB because of formatting and system functions.

Joybuy
Toshiba Canvas Basics 1 TB, Black, 2.5 inch, USB 3.2

Toshiba Canvas Basics 1TB Black 2.5" USB 3.2

A 1 TB portable external HDD for an extra copy of your photos and files.

The description lists USB 3.2, USB 2.0 compatibility and plug-and-play use. It states that the drive is preformatted for Windows; it needs to be reformatted for use with a Mac.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does a Lightroom Classic catalogue backup also back up your photos?

No. Adobe states that a catalogue backup contains only the catalogue file. Copy your photos and any exports separately, and check that you can open the files you need before deleting the originals.

Do you need to format a new external drive before using it with a Mac?

It depends on the exact model and your computer. Toshiba states that the Canvio Basics reviewed is formatted for Windows and needs to be reformatted for the macOS versions listed; Crucial lists exFAT for the X9 Pro reviewed. Reformatting erases any existing data on the drive.

Can you pack your backup drive in the same moving box as your computer?

Don’t keep all your copies in the same place. Transporting a drive separately or keeping a copy elsewhere reduces the risk of one problem affecting several copies at once.

Are you always entitled to exactly two years’ legal guarantee on an external drive in the Netherlands?

No. According to the Dutch government, the Netherlands has no fixed legal guarantee period. If a product doesn’t perform as you could reasonably expect under normal use, the seller must offer a solution in line with the applicable terms; the manufacturer’s guarantee is separate.