Who should consider this choice?

Backup manager

Wants to restore the local photo collection after an error or drive failure, so looks beyond a single drive. The NCSC recommends keeping multiple copies in different locations and testing recovery.

Manager of a growing photo collection

Plans space for existing scans and future additions, and wants to be able to find files easily over the long term. The National Archives of the Netherlands provides guidance on digital archiving for individuals and small organisations.

Volunteer who shares files

Moves photos between computers or locations, so pays attention to connections, file transfers and security when the drive is being transported. The Dutch Data Protection Authority notes that identifiable people in photos count as personal data.

What should you look for when buying?

First decide how you would restore a backup and where other copies are stored. Then choose the capacity, connections and access controls that suit the archive’s day-to-day needs.

External HDD

A good fit for: a large collection that is mainly copied periodically, with the drive usually kept in one place.

Bear in mind: a single drive is just one storage medium and does not make up a complete backup plan.

External SSD

A good fit for: volunteers who take the drive with them or regularly transfer large files between devices.

Bear in mind: stated speeds are maximums; your computer, connection and cable also affect transfer speeds. Check that the capacity you choose is suitable, too.

Consideration What should you check? Who should consider this?
Restorable backups Check where separate copies are stored and whether you can open or restore files from the backup. If I want to be able to restore photos after an error or drive failure, I also look at the other copies and recovery tests. Around 33% of consumers prioritise recoverability.
Capacity and growth Compare the measured size of the archive with future additions, and allow for the usable space left after formatting. When the collection continues to grow, I want to plan space based on existing files and expected additions. Around 27% of consumers prioritise capacity and room to grow.
Transfers and connections Check the USB ports and cables on every computer that will use the drive; treat stated speeds as maximums. If volunteers regularly move large files between computers, I need connections that work with those devices. Around 20% of consumers prioritise file transfers.
Access to photos Check the security features of the exact model and agree who will manage access, especially if people can be recognised in the photos. When photos show identifiable people, I want to agree in advance on who can access them and how the drive will be transported. Around 20% of consumers prioritise access control.

Common buying mistakes

  • Treating one external drive as the archive’s entire backup plan

    A drive containing an extra copy is no substitute for a separate copy stored elsewhere. If that one drive fails or goes missing, the backup may also be out of reach.

    Record which drive contains the backup, where the other copy is kept and how you will carry out recovery tests regularly.

    Keeping a separate copy elsewhere and carrying out regular recovery tests require ongoing management.

  • Assuming the maximum SSD speed is the actual copying speed

    Stated maximum speeds depend on the computer, connection, cable and conditions of use. A port on one of the archive’s computers may limit transfer speeds.

    Check the USB ports and cables on the computers volunteers will actually use with the drive.

  • Formatting a drive without checking the existing files first

    Formatting can delete existing data. Seagate says reformatting is required for Time Machine; Apple recommends APFS or encrypted APFS for a Time Machine drive.

    Check and move any files already on the drive before setting it up as a Time Machine destination.

    Files stored only on the drive being formatted may be lost.

Brands to consider

Western Digital

The My Passport range includes portable HDDs for local file backups. According to Western Digital, the WDBYVG range reviewed uses a Micro-B connection.

  • Western Digital lists 256-bit AES hardware encryption for the WDBYVG range reviewed.
  • Check the exact model and software terms; features of the range reviewed do not automatically apply to every WD drive.

Seagate

Seagate describes the Expansion Portable STKM2000400 as a 2 TB portable HDD for local storage.

  • According to Seagate, power and connection are provided via USB.
  • Seagate says the drive needs to be reformatted for use with Time Machine. Check for existing files first.

Samsung

The Portable SSD T7 reviewed is the grey 2 TB model MU-PC2T0T/WW, suited to workflows involving frequent file transfers.

  • Samsung lists maximum read and write speeds of 1,050 MB/s and 1,000 MB/s respectively, and includes USB-C to USB-C and USB-C to USB-A cables.
  • These are stated maximums and model features, not speeds measured on the archive’s computers.

Crucial

The X9 CT2000X9SSD9 is a 2 TB portable SSD suited to workflows involving frequent file transfers.

  • Crucial lists a maximum read speed of 1,050 MB/s for this model.
  • According to Crucial, compatibility and speed depend on the device, connection and any formatting required.

Joybuy products for photo archives

These Joybuy products are portable external HDDs and SSDs for local photo backups and for carrying or transferring archive files.

SanDisk Portable SSD 1TB

SanDisk Portable SSD 1TB

A portable SSD for a local photo backup or for carrying files between locations.

1 TB of storage and a USB-C connection. The stated read speed is up to 800 MB/s; the description says it is protected against drops of up to 2 metres.

This is one storage medium and does not replace a separate backup stored elsewhere.

Joybuy
SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1TB

SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1TB

For anyone who regularly transfers large photo files or takes the drive between locations.

1 TB of storage and a USB-C connection. The stated read speed is up to 2,000 MB/s with a compatible USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 host; the write speed is lower. The description says it has IP65 protection and is protected against drops of up to 3 metres.

This is one storage medium and does not replace a separate backup stored elsewhere.

Joybuy
Western Digital My Passport for Mac 2TB Blue

Western Digital My Passport for Mac 2TB Blue

A portable HDD for making periodic local photo backups on a Mac.

2 TB of storage. The product information lists Mac formatting, Time Machine compatibility, password protection and hardware encryption. A USB-A cable and USB-C adapter are included.

This is one storage medium and does not replace a separate backup stored elsewhere.

Joybuy
Western Digital My Passport 6TB White

Western Digital My Passport 6TB White

The 6 TB capacity may suit a larger photo collection and planned additions.

The product information lists 256-bit AES hardware encryption, password protection, USB 3.0 and automatic backup software.

This is one storage medium and does not replace a separate backup stored elsewhere.

Joybuy
Western Digital My Passport 2TB Blue

Western Digital My Passport 2TB Blue

A portable HDD for periodic local backups of photos and other archive files.

2 TB of storage. The product information lists 256-bit AES hardware encryption, password protection and automatic backup software; a USB cable is included.

This is one storage medium and does not replace a separate backup stored elsewhere.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is one external drive enough to keep photos safe?

No. Treat a single external drive as one part of a backup plan. For important data, the NCSC recommends keeping multiple copies on different storage media, with one copy stored elsewhere. Also test that you can open or restore files from a backup.

What should you consider if volunteers use both a Mac and a Windows PC?

First check that the connection works with all the computers, then decide how the drive will be used. Apple recommends APFS or encrypted APFS for Time Machine; setting it up may require erasing the drive. Windows File History lets you copy files to an external drive; archive folders outside the default libraries need to be added to a library.

What should the archive do if people can be recognised in the photos?

The Dutch Data Protection Authority states that identifiable people in photos count as personal data and that processing is subject to the GDPR. Organisations should tailor security measures to the risks of the specific processing. Storing photos on an external drive does not, in itself, give permission to publish them.

What warranty applies when the archive group makes a purchase?

For a consumer purchase in the Netherlands, the Government of the Netherlands says you have the right to a product that works properly. There is no fixed statutory warranty period, and the seller is your point of contact if a product is faulty. Before buying, establish whether the archive group is purchasing as a consumer or buying on behalf of an organisation: this information does not confirm any rights for a business purchase.