Start by working out how much storage space your archive needs. An HDD is a sensible choice if capacity is your priority and the drive won’t be moved often, while an SSD is better suited to regular transport or file transfers. The Consumers’ Association describes HDDs as more vulnerable to knocks than SSDs, so it’s important to keep an additional, recoverable copy whichever type of drive you choose. If the recordings contain personal data, also decide who needs access and how long you need to keep it for your purposes, as the Dutch Data Protection Authority advises.
Who is this guide for?
Manager of a large recording archive
You want to work out how much space you need before the move and avoid moving the equipment along with your only copy of the archive. The Digital Trust Center advises against relying on a single location for backups.
Manager of confidential recordings
You need to align access, security and retention periods for recordings containing personal data with their content and purpose. The Dutch Data Protection Authority explains that personal data must not be kept for longer than necessary.
Studio with limited time for transferring data
You need to copy large files before the move and may take the drive to another location. The connection, actual transfer time and how you transport the drive are all important considerations.
What should you consider when choosing?
External HDD
Best suited when: your archive needs plenty of space, the drive won’t be moved often and you’ve worked out the capacity you need.
Bear in mind: the Consumers’ Association describes HDDs as more vulnerable to knocks than SSDs, so protect the drive when transporting it.
External SSD
Best suited when: you regularly take the drive between locations or need to transfer recording files repeatedly.
Bear in mind: quoted top speeds depend on factors such as your computer and connection. A sturdy casing is no substitute for a separate backup.
Measure your files and check the computer you plan to use the drive with after the move. This will help you assess capacity, connection and file system before copying anything.
| Point to consider |
What should you check? |
Who should pay particular attention? |
| Recoverable copy |
Keep a separate copy and, before you leave, test that you can restore files from it. |
I want to be sure I can restore the recordings after the move, not just that they’ve been copied; around 31% of consumers prioritise recoverability. |
| Confidentiality |
Check whether the recordings contain personal data and who needs access. |
If identifiable people appear in the recordings, I want to carefully align access and the retention period with the purpose; around 25% of consumers prioritise confidentiality. |
| Archive space |
Count your existing files and expected additions, then compare the total with the available space on the exact variant. |
I want all the files that need to be kept to fit on the drive; around 25% of consumers prioritise having enough archive space. |
| Transfer and transport |
Check your computer’s port, cable, file system and available transfer time. |
With a deadline approaching, I want to copy the files in time and then transport the drive safely; around 19% of consumers prioritise transfer and transport. |
Common pitfalls
-
Putting your only copy on the new drive and deleting the original
If the drive fails or goes missing during the move, you could lose your archive if you don’t have another copy.
Keep a separate copy and, before you leave, test that you can restore the files from it.
-
Assuming a sturdy casing means your data is secure
Protection against knocks or dust doesn’t control who can access personal data. Samsung also states that protection for the T7 Shield depends on the conditions, and that damage caused by liquids, dust or drops isn’t covered by the warranty.
Assess physical protection and access security separately, and set up security features that suit the way you use the drive.
-
Assuming an SSD’s quoted maximum speed is a guaranteed transfer time
Kingston specifies a USB 3.2 Gen 2 host for optimum speed with the XS1000, and says actual speeds may vary.
Check your computer’s port and cable, and allow time for a test transfer using representative files.
-
Assuming a different model name refers to the same drive
The same capacity or brand doesn’t mean two variants are the same product. Canvio Ready and Canvio Basics are listed as separate ranges.
Before buying, compare the full model name and the specifications that matter for your computer and archive.
Brands to compare
Western Digital
WD Elements Portable is a USB-powered HDD range for archives where capacity matters and files aren’t transferred constantly.
- Western Digital lists 2 TB and 4 TB variants and a USB-A cable included in the box.
- The manufacturer lists Windows compatibility; reformatting may be needed for other operating systems. Check the exact variant.
Seagate
Expansion Portable is a portable, USB-powered HDD range for recordings that aren’t edited constantly.
- Seagate lists a 2 TB capacity and a USB 3.0 cable included with model STKM2000400.
- According to the data sheet, reformatting is needed for Time Machine; the listed Rescue services aren’t available in every country.
Samsung
The T7 Shield is an external SSD range for an archive drive that regularly travels between studio locations.
- For variant MU-PE2T0S/EU, Samsung specifies 2 TB, USB 3.2 Gen 2 and sequential speeds of up to 1.050/1.000 MB/s.
- Samsung lists IP65 and drop resistance based on tests carried out under controlled conditions. The manufacturer says protection may vary and that damage caused by liquids, dust or drops isn’t covered by the warranty.
Kingston
The XS1000 is a compact external SSD range for transferring files between devices with compatible USB connections.
- Kingston lists 1 TB and 2 TB variants, a USB-A cable with a USB-C adapter, and quoted speeds of up to 1.050/1.000 MB/s.
- Kingston says a USB 3.2 Gen 2 host is needed for optimum speed; actual speeds may vary.
Toshiba
Canvio Basics is a portable HDD range for anyone looking for an archive drive that’s easy to connect.
- Toshiba lists a 2 TB variant, among others, with USB power and use on Windows without installing software.
- If you plan to use it with a Mac, check the file system and connection. These features don’t automatically apply to other Canvio ranges.
Joybuy products for archiving and transport
These portable HDD and SSD options are designed for storing meeting recordings and taking an archive between locations.
Image unavailable
Portable SSD, 1 TB, 1.000 MB/s
A portable SSD for anyone who wants to take their storage between locations.
The product title lists 1 TB, 1.000 MB/s and USB-C. The quoted speed isn’t a guaranteed transfer time.
The product information lists drop protection from heights of up to 2 metres.
Joybuy
Image unavailable
Samsung Portable SSD T7, 2 TB, blue
A portable SSD for archiving and taking with you; the product information also lists password protection features.
The title lists 2 TB, USB Type-C and USB 3.2 Gen 2 (3.1 Gen 2). The product information lists AES 256-bit hardware encryption and drop protection from heights of up to 2 metres.
Joybuy
Image unavailable
WD My Passport, 6 TB, white
A portable HDD for an archive that fits within the stated capacity.
The title lists 6 TB. The product information lists AES 256-bit hardware encryption, password protection and automatic backup software.
The Consumers’ Association describes HDDs as more vulnerable to knocks than SSDs; protect the drive when transporting it.
Joybuy
Image unavailable
WD Elements Portable, 5 TB, USB-C
A portable HDD for anyone who wants to store a measured archive on a variant with a suitable capacity.
The title lists 5 TB. The product information lists USB-C, USB 3.2 Gen 1 and compatibility with Windows and Mac.
The Consumers’ Association describes HDDs as more vulnerable to knocks than SSDs; protect the drive when transporting it between locations.
Joybuy
Image unavailable
Toshiba Canvio Basics, 4 TB, black
A portable HDD for an archive that fits within the chosen capacity.
The title lists 4 TB. The product information lists USB 3.2 Gen 1 and plug-and-play use on Windows without installing software.
According to the product information, reformatting is needed to use it with macOS. Make a separate copy first if there are already files on the drive. The Consumers’ Association describes HDDs as more vulnerable to knocks than SSDs; protect the drive when transporting it.
Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is one external drive enough for the move?
Not if it becomes your only remaining copy. The Digital Trust Center advises keeping backups in different locations and testing them periodically by restoring files. Do this before the move with recordings you want to keep.
How do you work out how much capacity you need?
First, measure the total size of the files you want to keep and allow for expected additions. Compare this with the available space on the exact variant; Kingston notes that some of an SSD’s stated capacity is used for formatting and other functions.
Can you use the same archive drive with Windows and a Mac?
This depends in part on the file system. Apple lists exFAT as compatible with Windows and says a Mac may be able to read an NTFS drive but not write to it. Check the format before transferring files; reformatting requires you to make a separate copy first.
How can you check that copied recordings are usable?
Open files from the copy or restore a selection and check that they play. The Digital Trust Center recommends restoring files as a way to test a backup.
Can you keep meeting recordings featuring identifiable people indefinitely?
No. If the recordings contain personal data, you need a legal basis under the GDPR to process it, and you must not keep the data for longer than necessary. The GDPR doesn’t set one general retention period. The right legal basis, retention period and security measures depend on the content and purpose. The Dutch Data Protection Authority doesn’t prescribe one specific drive model.