A portable HDD is a good choice if you mainly need space for recordings that you copy periodically. An SSD is more suitable if you carry the drive around frequently or regularly transfer large files. Choose the capacity based on your existing files and what you expect to add, check the ports and file formats of the computers you use, and keep a separate copy that you can open. If participants can be identified, make sure access, security and the retention period are in line with how the recordings are used and the school’s policies.
Who should consider this choice?
Managing a growing recording archive
You keep meeting recordings for future reference and want to choose enough storage without forgetting to keep a separate, recoverable copy. Safe Internet and the National Cyber Security Centre offer practical advice on backups.
A student who takes recordings on the go
You move the drive between computers and want to check that its connection and file system work with the devices you use. Toshiba and Samsung describe these features for their specific portable storage models.
A project group with identifiable participants
You store or share recordings in which people can be identified. Access, appropriate security and a suitable retention period should all inform your choice. The Dutch Data Protection Authority considers identifiable audio recordings to be personal data.
What should you look for when buying?
| Consideration |
What should you check? |
Who should give this more weight? |
| Recoverable copies |
Decide where to keep the original files and a separate copy. After copying, open a file from the copy to check it works. |
If the original drive fails, I want to be able to open a usable recording. Around 28% of consumers put recoverability first. |
| Space for your archive |
Add up your current files and allow for recordings you expect to keep in the future. |
I want to keep both existing and future project recordings, so I compare the capacity with my own archive. Around 22% of consumers prioritise archive storage. |
| Access and privacy |
Work out who needs access and what security measures and retention period are appropriate for the project. The Dutch Data Protection Authority notes that identifiable audio recordings may be personal data. |
If participants can be identified, I want to know who can view the recordings and how long they need to be kept. Around 17% of consumers put privacy and access first. |
| Works with the right computers |
Make a note of the ports and operating systems on all the computers you use. Check the cable and the drive’s default file system. |
I want to be able to open my files on the computers used for the project without needing an unexpected change. Around 17% of consumers prioritise compatibility. |
| Portability and transfers |
Consider how often and how much data you transfer, and check that the connection and cable work with the computer you use. |
If I carry the drive around frequently or transfer large recordings, I pay extra attention to how easy it is to use on the go. Around 16% of consumers prioritise portability and transfers. |
Pitfalls when choosing and storing a drive
-
Using your archive drive as your only copy
An external drive gives you storage, but it doesn’t give you a separate copy. If that one drive fails or goes missing, your recordings may become inaccessible.
Keep a second copy somewhere separate and check that you can open files from it. Safe Internet and the National Cyber Security Centre offer advice on backups.
-
Assuming USB speed means a guaranteed transfer speed
Samsung lists maximum sequential read and write speeds for the T7 Shield. These figures don’t guarantee that every computer and cable will achieve the same transfer speed.
Consider your actual transfer needs and check your computer’s port and cable before choosing a model based on its stated speed.
-
Assuming every cable and file system will work with every laptop
Toshiba lists a Type-A-to-Micro-B cable and NTFS formatting for the standard Canvio Basics. Toshiba says the drive needs to be reformatted for use with a Mac.
Check which computers you’ll use and the exact model before you start. Save any existing files somewhere else before reformatting a drive.
Brands to consider
Toshiba
The Canvio Basics is a range of portable HDDs for anyone who copies their recording archive periodically. Toshiba lists the HDTB520EK3AA model, with 2 TB of storage, among its options.
- Toshiba says the drive is USB-powered and comes formatted as NTFS for Windows.
- The cable supplied is Type-A-to-Micro-B. Toshiba says the drive needs to be reformatted for use with a Mac; check what this means for any existing files.
Seagate
The Expansion Portable is a range of portable HDDs. Seagate’s 2021 datasheet identifies the black STKM2000400 model as having 2 TB of storage.
- Seagate specifies USB power and an included USB 3.0 cable.
- According to the datasheet, compatibility depends on the hardware and operating system. The drive needs to be reformatted for Time Machine, and the Rescue service mentioned isn’t available in every country.
Samsung
The portable T7 Shield SSD is available in a black 1 TB model, MU-PE1T0S/EU, among other options.
- Samsung says this model has USB 3.2 Gen 2, maximum sequential read and write speeds of 1.050 and 1.000 MB/s, an IP65 rating and drop resistance up to 3 metres.
- These are Samsung’s specifications and claims, not a guarantee of transfer speeds on every computer or of data recovery. A rugged casing is no substitute for a separate copy.
Joybuy product picks
This selection of Joybuy products includes portable external SSDs for carrying and transferring files, and portable HDDs for storing a recording archive. Compare the stated capacity with your own files and check that the drive you choose works with the computers you’ll use for your project.
No image available
SanDisk Portable SSD 1TB
A portable external SSD for anyone who wants to take recording files between locations.
The product name states that it has 1 TB of storage.
View at Joybuy
No image available
SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1TB 2000MB/s
A portable external SSD for anyone who regularly wants to take recordings with them or transfer them.
The product name states 1 TB and 2000 MB/s. Check that your computer’s connection suits your transfer needs.
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD Elements Portable 5TB USB-C, Graphite Black
A portable external HDD for anyone who wants to store a recording archive and take the drive with them.
The product name states 5 TB and USB-C.
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD My Passport for Mac 2TB Blue
A portable HDD whose product name specifies Mac use; check that its format works with every computer in your project.
The product name states 2 TB, Time Machine Ready and Password Protection.
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD Elements Portable 6TB USB-C, Graphite Black
A portable external HDD for anyone who wants to store lots of recording files and take their storage between locations.
The product name states 6 TB and USB-C.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
How do you work out how much storage you need?
Add up your current recording files and allow for recordings you expect to keep in the future. The 1 TB and 2 TB models mentioned are examples, not minimum capacities for your project.
Can you use the same drive with Windows and Mac without any preparation?
Not always. Toshiba says the standard Canvio Basics is formatted as NTFS and needs to be reformatted for use with a Mac. Check the format of the exact drive and save any existing files somewhere else before formatting it.
Is one external drive enough for both an archive and a backup?
Not if it holds your only usable copy. Keep a separate copy and check that you can open a recording from it. The National Cyber Security Centre describes the 3-2-1 approach as backup advice, not a product specification.
What are your rights if a drive bought in the Netherlands doesn’t work properly?
When you buy as a consumer, you’re entitled to a product that meets the terms of the agreement, and you can contact the retailer if there’s a fault. According to the Government of the Netherlands, there is no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands; a manufacturer’s warranty is in addition to your statutory rights.
Can you keep identifiable meeting participants on a drive for a long time without further consideration?
You can’t decide this without considering the circumstances. The Dutch Data Protection Authority considers identifiable audio recordings to be personal data. You need an appropriate lawful basis for processing; personal data must not be kept for longer than necessary and must be protected appropriately. For a school project, also check the school’s policies on recording, access and deletion. Consent is one possible lawful basis, but it isn’t automatically the only one.