Who is this choice relevant to?

Family photo archivist

You want to be able to find and restore both the original scan and the edited final version. Having a separate backup matters more to you than the fastest transfer speeds. Veilig Internetten and the Digital Trust Center explain why a backup is a separate copy and why you should avoid relying on a single storage location.

Regular photo editor

You reopen large photo files or take your archive with you. So you need to weigh speed and portability against the storage space you need. The Dutch Consumers' Association discusses the differences between external HDDs and SSDs; the quoted speed of a specific SSD still depends on the connection and computer.

User of multiple computers

You want to open scans on different computers or use a built-in backup feature. The file format and the feature's settings will affect how you can use the drive, so check that it suits your intended setup before deleting existing files or formatting the drive.

What should you look for when choosing?

First decide whether the drive will mainly be an archive or whether you will also use it regularly to open and move large scans. Then check its capacity and connection, and how you will set up your backup.

What to consider What to look for Who should pay particular attention?
Restorable copies Check that your process copies both originals and final versions, and that you can also use a separate storage location. Test whether you can restore a file. If I want to keep both the original scan and the final version after a long editing session, I also want to know that I can actually restore them. Around 33% of consumers therefore put recoverability first.
Space for your archive Compare the capacity of the specific model with the size of your scans and versions, and allow for files you may add later. If I want to keep the originals and several edited versions, the total storage space matters. Around 27% of consumers give archive space top priority.
Opening and moving files Check your computer's USB connection and cable against the drive's requirements. Quoted maximum speeds depend on the connection and test conditions. When I regularly reopen large scans or move them between computers, I want to know whether the connection is compatible with my equipment. Around 20% of consumers put working speed first.
Computer and backup feature Decide whether you want to share files between Windows and Mac or use the drive for Time Machine. Apple recommends ExFAT for Windows-compatible volumes and APFS or encrypted APFS for a new Time Machine drive. If I want to use the drive with different computers or a built-in backup feature, I want to know in advance which format I need. Around 20% of consumers put computer compatibility first.

Common pitfalls

  • Treating the external drive as your only saved copy

    An external drive is still just one storage location. Veilig Internetten and the Digital Trust Center describe backups as copies and highlight the importance of not relying on a single location.

    Keep the originals and final versions in a separate location too, and periodically try restoring a file, whether you choose an HDD or an SSD.

  • Choosing an SSD based only on its advertised MB/s

    Manufacturers' quoted maximum SSD speeds depend on the connection, cable and computer. The Dutch Consumers' Association discusses the difference between HDDs and SSDs; Samsung and Crucial list conditions that apply to their models' speeds.

    Check your computer's USB port and cable. If you mainly want to store scans and won't often open them from the drive, compare HDD models for capacity too.

  • Formatting an existing drive without checking its backup feature

    A format for sharing files between Windows and Mac is not automatically suitable for a new Time Machine drive. Apple recommends APFS or encrypted APFS for Time Machine and ExFAT for Windows-compatible volumes. Formatting may erase existing files.

    Before formatting, decide whether you want to share files or use the drive for Time Machine. First save any existing files somewhere else.

  • Mistaking a recovery service or warranty for a photo backup

    A product warranty is not the same as a restorable copy of your photos. Seagate states that its Rescue Data Recovery Services are not available in every country.

    Check the terms for the specific model and any recovery service. Protect irreplaceable scans with separate copies that you can test.

Brands to consider

Western Digital

The WD Elements Portable range includes portable HDD models, including a 2 TB model that may be worth considering for local photo storage.

  • For the 2 TB WD Elements Portable model, Western Digital lists USB 3.2 Gen 1 and a USB-A cable included in the box.
  • Reformatting may be necessary for operating systems other than Windows. A single drive is not a complete backup on its own.

Seagate

The Expansion Portable range includes portable HDDs, including the 2 TB model STKM2000400.

  • Seagate says this model works via USB 3.0 without a separate power supply.
  • Seagate states that its Rescue Data Recovery Services are not available in every country. Check the terms for the specific model; a recovery service does not replace a separate backup.

Samsung

The Portable SSD T7 range is an option if you regularly transfer scans or take them with you. Samsung describes, among other models, the grey 1 TB version MU-PC1T0T/WW.

  • Samsung quotes maximum sequential read and write speeds of 1,050 and 1,000 MB/s respectively for the T7, and lists USB-C to C and USB-C to A cables as included.
  • These are manufacturer figures, not guaranteed speeds on every computer.

Crucial

The X9 Portable SSD range is designed for regularly moving and reopening photo files; Crucial identifies a 1 TB model as CT1000X9SSD9.

  • Crucial quotes read speeds of up to 1,050 MB/s, measured on a high-performance test computer.
  • According to Crucial, the top speeds depend on USB 3.2 Gen 2 and a suitable USB-C cable. Usability may also depend on the format and device.

Joybuy products for photo archiving and editing

This selection includes external HDDs for storage space and SSDs for anyone who also regularly opens or moves scans. The right model depends on factors such as the capacity you need, your computer and its connection. Remember to keep a separate backup too.

SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1 TB

SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1 TB

A good fit if you regularly want to transfer scans or take them with you; the product specifications list 1 TB of storage.

The product title quotes read speeds of up to 2,000 MB/s. This speed requires a suitable USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 host; the stated write speed is lower.

A single drive is still just one storage location and does not replace a separate copy.

Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 6 TB, USB-C, Graphite Black

WD Elements Portable 6 TB USB-C Graphite Black

A good fit if you need plenty of space for scans and edited versions; the product title lists 6 TB and USB-C.

Bear in mind that a single drive is not a separate backup.

Joybuy
Western Digital My Passport 2 TB Black

Western Digital My Passport 2 TB Black

A good fit if you want a portable HDD for photos and edited versions; the product title lists 2 TB.

Don't use the drive as the only saved copy of irreplaceable scans.

Joybuy
Toshiba Canvio Basics 4 TB, 2.5-inch, USB Type-A / Micro-USB B

Toshiba Canvio Basics 4 TB

A good fit if you want an HDD for a larger archive; the product title lists 4 TB and a portable 2.5-inch model.

The title lists USB Type-A / Micro-USB B and USB 2.0/3.2 Gen 1. According to the product information, the drive is formatted for Windows; reformatting may be necessary for macOS. This can erase existing data.

You still need a separate copy to avoid relying on a single storage location.

Joybuy
Samsung Portable SSD T7 2 TB USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2 Blue

Samsung Portable SSD T7 2 TB USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2 Blue

A good fit if you regularly want to transfer or reopen scans; the product title lists 2 TB and USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2.

Achievable speeds depend on the connection and computer. A single SSD does not replace a separate backup.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Should I keep the original scan if I've already exported the edited version?

Yes. If you want to be able to edit it again later, keep both the original scan and the final version you want, and include both in your backup. Test that you can restore a file from the copy.

Can I use one drive for Windows, Mac and Time Machine at the same time?

That depends on the drive's format and what you want to use it for. Apple recommends ExFAT for Windows-compatible volumes and APFS or encrypted APFS for a new Time Machine drive. You may need to reformat it, which erases existing data, so save that data somewhere else first.

How can I check that my backup includes my scan folder after an editing session?

Check which folders have been selected and whether the drive is set as the backup destination. Microsoft Support explains how to add folders to File History; start the backup, then try restoring a file.

Are a manufacturer's warranty or a recovery service the same as protecting my photos?

No. Dutch statutory warranty covers a product that does not meet what you could reasonably expect under normal use; it is not a separate copy of your files. Check the terms of any data recovery service separately: Seagate states that its Rescue service is not available in every country.

Can I store private scans showing identifiable family members on an external drive?

According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, personal or household use generally falls outside the GDPR if you keep the images private or share them only with a very limited group. This exception does not automatically apply if you publish identifiable photos more widely or use them for business purposes.