Who should consider this choice?

Group archive managers

Anyone managing the full collection needs to work out not only how much space is required, but also how the group can recover files if a drive is lost. The National Archives of the Netherlands stresses that digital archive management involves more than storage space; Veilig Internetten describes a backup as a copy of files.

Managers of information about living people

If you manage information that can be linked to living people, you need to match access and security measures to the content and the risks. The Dutch Data Protection Authority points out that information about someone who has died can also reveal something about a living person.

Volunteers transferring scans

Volunteers who share files between workstations need a drive and cables that suit the available connections. In the July 2022 issue of Digitaalgids, the Consumentenbond discussed the differences between SSDs and HDDs. Check the connections on your computers before choosing a model.

What should you look for when buying?

First, assess the size and growth of the collection, as well as the recovery copy you’ll need. Then consider how personal data is handled, how the drive will be transported and which connections are available on volunteers’ computers.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Recoverability and capacity Measure the existing collection, allow for growth and decide where the separate recovery copy will be kept. Check that you can restore files from it. I want to avoid a full or faulty drive making my only collection of scans inaccessible. Around 33% of consumers put recoverability and sufficient storage first.
Data protection Establish whether the collection includes information about living people and who needs access. Then assess the appropriate security measures and key management. If my group manages information that can be linked to living people, I want to tailor access accordingly. Around 25% of consumers give data protection top priority.
Transport and transfers Check how often the drive will be carried around, which USB ports are available and which cables are included. A quoted top speed is not necessarily the speed you’ll get on every computer. I regularly share scans between workstations, so I want the drive and connection to suit the way we use them. Around 17% of consumers prioritise portability and file transfers.
Compatibility and management Make a note of the operating systems and connections in use. Check the required formatting before saving files to the drive, and agree how the group will manage the collection. If volunteers use different computers, I want the files to remain usable on all of them. Around 25% of consumers prioritise shared use and compatibility.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming a large drive is a complete archive

    A high-capacity drive is not the same as a separate copy that lets the group restore its files. The National Archives of the Netherlands describes digital archive management as involving more than storage space alone.

    Before you buy, decide where the working collection and recovery copy will be kept, and who will regularly check that files can be restored.

  • Treating an SSD’s quoted top speed as its everyday speed

    Crucial states that the X9’s maximum read speed was measured on a specific test computer. Speed also depends on the host and formatting.

    Check the USB ports and cables on the computers volunteers will use to copy files.

  • Setting a password without agreeing how to recover access

    Western Digital warns that support cannot recover a forgotten WD Security password. The drive must then be erased before it can be used again.

    Agree who will manage access and how the group will restore files from a separate copy.

Relevant brands to consider

Seagate

The Expansion Portable range includes portable HDDs, including the STKM2000400 model with 2 TB. Seagate’s data sheet states that it is powered via the USB cable.

  • The model mentioned is a portable, USB-powered HDD.
  • Seagate states that Rescue Data Recovery Services are not available in every country. Check the terms for the specific model and country; a recovery service is no substitute for your own recovery copy.

Samsung

The T7 Shield is a range of portable SSDs. Samsung Netherlands describes the 2 TB version and the included USB-C-to-C and USB-C-to-A cables.

  • Samsung lists IP65 protection, a drop-resistant design and hardware encryption for the T7 Shield.
  • The quoted transfer speed is not an independent measurement on your group’s computers. Protection and encryption are no substitute for a separate recovery copy.

Crucial

The X9 Portable SSD, including the CT2000X9SSD9 with 2 TB, is a USB-C option for transferring files between devices.

  • The manufacturer describes the X9 as a portable SSD with USB-C.
  • Crucial says the quoted maximum read speed was measured on a specific test computer. Compatibility may depend on the host and formatting, so check the connections in advance.

Western Digital

Supported My Passport models are worth considering if your group is looking for a portable drive with a manufacturer-supported password feature.

  • According to Western Digital, WD Security works on supported drives.
  • Western Digital says that support cannot recover a forgotten password. Agree in advance who will manage access and the recovery copy.

Joybuy products for storage and transfers

This selection includes portable SSDs and HDDs for storage and file transfers. Work out the capacity you need based on the collection, and check that the connections are compatible with your group’s computers.

SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1TB

SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1TB

A portable SSD option for storage and file transfers, provided the connection you choose is compatible with your group’s computers.

The product information lists 1 TB, USB-C and USB 3.2 Gen 2x2, with password protection via 256-bit AES.

The quoted maximum speed of 2.000 MB/s requires a suitable USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 host; write speeds are lower. You should also keep a separate recovery copy.

Joybuy
WD My Passport 6TB White portable hard drive

WD My Passport 6TB White

A portable HDD option if your group is looking for a drive with the stated storage capacity of 6 TB.

The product information mentions 256-bit AES hardware encryption and software for scheduled backups.

A separate recovery copy is still essential. Also agree in advance who will manage passwords and access.

Joybuy
Western Digital My Passport USB-C 4TB

Western Digital My Passport USB-C 4TB

A portable HDD option for groups looking for 4 TB of storage and able to check the USB-C connection in advance.

The product information lists exFAT, compatibility with Windows and Mac, and 256-bit AES hardware encryption.

Check that the formatting is suitable for your group’s computers, and keep a separate recovery copy.

Joybuy
Toshiba Canvio Ready 4TB external hard drive

Toshiba Canvio Ready 4TB Black

A portable HDD option for a collection that can be accommodated by the stated capacity of 4 TB.

The product information lists a Micro-USB B connection, USB 2.0 and USB 3.2 Gen 1 (3.1 Gen 1), USB power and an included USB cable.

The description warns against physical knocks while the drive is in use or being transported. Keep a separate recovery copy too.

Joybuy
Samsung Portable SSD T7 2TB Blue

Samsung Portable SSD T7 2TB Blue

A portable SSD option for storage and file transfers, provided the capacity and connection suit your group’s computers.

The product information lists 2 TB, USB 3.2 Gen 2, AES 256-bit encryption, and both a USB-C-to-C and a USB-C-to-A cable.

The description says it can withstand drops of up to 2 metres, but notes that this does not guarantee protection against every impact. A separate recovery copy is still essential.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is one external drive enough for the group archive?

No, not if it contains the only copy. Keep a separate, up-to-date copy and check that you can restore files from it. Archive management also requires you to consider long-term accessibility.

What should we check before volunteers connect a new drive?

Check the connections, cables, operating systems and required formatting on the workstations. Crucial warns that formatting can erase data on the drive, so decide on the formatting before putting the archive on it.

What else should we consider besides the drive itself?

Plan for a separate recovery copy and check the terms for any services that apply to the specific model and country. Seagate states that Rescue Data Recovery Services are not available in every country.

Does the GDPR apply to our family history data, and does it require a particular type of drive?

Information about people who have died is not in itself covered by the GDPR, but family history information can also reveal something about living people. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says that organisations must protect personal data properly. The appropriate measures depend on the processing and the risks, not on a specific HDD or SSD type.

Does a volunteer group need to use the National Archives of the Netherlands’ preferred file formats?

The National Archives of the Netherlands’ standard for preferred formats is intended for government information and is not described as a general requirement for volunteer groups. However, your group can take file formats into account when preserving the archive and keeping it accessible.