Guitar editor with a small desk
Wants to position two speakers either side of the screen while maintaining a practical, symmetrical listening setup. Comparing compact desktop systems with small separate monitors.
Choose a compact desktop stereo system if desk space is limited and you want to connect directly via USB-C. Two separate nearfield monitors are a better fit if you have enough room and suitable analogue outputs. Genelec recommends a symmetrical setup around your fixed listening position. Assess string detail, stereo imaging and bass response where you normally listen, as the room affects what you hear and stated low-frequency limits are not always measured on the same basis.
Wants to position two speakers either side of the screen while maintaining a practical, symmetrical listening setup. Comparing compact desktop systems with small separate monitors.
Already has analogue monitor outputs and wants to assess string detail and left-to-right balance using two separately positioned nearfield monitors. Genelec recommends an equilateral listening triangle for a fixed listening position.
Wants to work at a modest listening level while being considerate of housemates. The Dutch government recommends agreeing how to handle noise from neighbours together in the first instance.
| What to consider | What to look for when buying | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| String detail and stereo imaging | Check that both monitors can be positioned at a similar height and distance, facing your usual listening position. Genelec recommends symmetrical placement. | When I edit acoustic guitar, I want to assess left-to-right differences and string detail from my usual seat. Around 33% of consumers prioritise detail and stereo imaging. |
| Desk space | Measure the available width and depth on both sides of your screen, allowing for cables and your preferred listening setup. | At a small desk, I want to fit two monitors without accidentally making the setup asymmetrical. Around 27% of consumers say available desk space is their main consideration. |
| Listening at low levels | Assess the balance and audibility of details at your usual listening level, and take the speakers’ position in the room into account. | When I work quietly in a shared home, I want to assess my guitar tracks while being considerate of my housemates. Around 20% of consumers prioritise quiet listening. |
| Connections and stereo pair | Compare the inputs with those on your computer or audio interface, and check whether the box contains one monitor or two. | I want a setup that works with my equipment and is complete for stereo work. Around 20% of consumers give top priority to straightforward connections and a complete stereo pair. |
Genelec states that the 8010A comes with one monitor in the box; Yamaha lists the HS5 as individually packaged.
Check how many monitors are included in the specific listing before putting together a stereo system.
You’ll need two monitors and suitable connections for a stereo pair.
Yamaha gives HS5 figures at −10 dB and −3 dB, while Genelec gives a figure for the 8010A at −6 dB. The room also affects the bass you hear from your listening position.
Check the measurement basis for each stated figure and assess the guitar’s low end from your own listening position.
According to ADAM Audio, the D3V processes USB audio internally at 48 kHz/16 bit; ADAM specifies the analogue route for 24 bit.
Check that the connection route suits your workflow and preferred playback settings.
You may need an external converter or audio interface for the analogue route.
The D3V is an active desktop stereo system for a small desk, with USB-C and balanced TRS connections, according to ADAM Audio.
The LP-UNF is a desktop-focused stereo system with USB-C, balanced TRS and settings for different desk and wall positions.
The 8010A is a compact analogue XLR nearfield monitor for setups with room for two separate cabinets.
The Eris Studio 4 is a compact, individually sold analogue nearfield monitor with acoustic placement settings.
The HS5 is an active 5-inch nearfield monitor with analogue XLR and TRS inputs, designed for setups with room for two cabinets.
It depends on your computer and the model. ADAM Audio lists USB-C for the D3V, as does Kali Audio for the LP-UNF; the Yamaha HS5 and Genelec 8010A models reviewed have analogue inputs. According to ADAM Audio, the D3V processes USB audio internally at 48 kHz/16 bit.
Genelec recommends positioning two monitors equally and facing your listening position, ideally in an equilateral triangle. Assess the balance from where you normally sit, and take reflections and the room layout into account.
Not always. According to Genelec, the 8010A box contains one monitor, and Yamaha lists the HS5 as individually packaged. Check the specific listing and what you’ll need for a stereo pair.
Only if they use the same measurement basis. Yamaha lists the HS5 at 54 Hz at −10 dB and 74 Hz at −3 dB; Genelec lists the 8010A at 67 Hz at −6 dB. Also assess the bass where you normally listen, as the room affects what you hear.