Who should consider this printer choice?

Coordinator handling piles of forms

You regularly scan lots of individual questionnaires and want to know how many sheets the feeder can handle and whether completed reverse sides are scanned automatically too. The Consumentenbond treats automatic document feeding and duplex scanning as separate printer features.

Reviewer checking handwritten answers

You need to be able to see completed text and tick boxes, and would rather check the scans than rely on automatic text recognition. Microsoft Support warns that handwriting is rarely recognised.

Administrator managing identifiable answers

You decide who can view the files and how long they are kept when questionnaires contain personal data. The Dutch Data Protection Authority points out that organisations must decide for themselves which security measures are appropriate.

What should you look for when choosing?

First decide whether you want to scan stacks and completed reverse sides automatically. Then compare test scans, printing needs and how the group manages its files.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Stacks and reverse sides Compare the feeder capacity with the duplex scanning feature on the exact model. If possible, test it with your own paper too. If we regularly process stacks of forms, I want to know whether the feeder also scans completed reverse sides. Around 33% of consumers give stack handling and reverse sides their highest priority.
Readability of answers Make a test scan and check the handwriting, tick boxes, edges and page order. Microsoft Support says handwriting is rarely recognised. I want to be able to check handwritten answers and marks on the scan, without relying on text recognition alone. Around 27% of consumers give the readability of answers their highest priority.
Protecting personal data Decide on the scan destination, access rights and retention policy. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says organisations must determine appropriate security for their processing. If answers can be linked to participants, I want to decide in advance who can open scans and how long the group needs to keep them. Around 20% of consumers give data protection their highest priority.
Printing and replacement costs Estimate black-and-white and colour printing separately, and compare the consumables and maintenance parts for the exact model. If the printer is also used for printing, I want its consumables to suit our own black-and-white and colour volumes. Around 20% of consumers give total printing costs their highest priority.

Common mistakes

  • Assuming duplex printing means duplex scanning

    A printer can print automatically on both sides without automatically scanning both sides of a form. An ADF alone does not confirm that it can scan both sides either.

    Check the specifications for the exact model for an explicit mention of duplex scanning or a duplex ADF.

  • Confusing a searchable PDF with correctly recognised answers

    Microsoft Support says handwriting is rarely recognised. Text recognition is therefore no substitute for checking the scanned form.

    Check the scan itself, and review any recognised text if you use OCR.

  • Looking only at the purchase price or ink included

    The replacement supplies you need vary by model and usage. For the Brother MFC-L2800DW, for example, Brother lists toner and drum separately.

    Compare the consumables and any maintenance parts with the expected number of black-and-white and colour prints.

  • Automatically sharing scans of identifiable answers widely

    If answers can be linked to individuals, the scan destination and access rights should be considered as part of the entire workflow.

    Before scanning, decide who can open the files, where they will be saved and how the group will set its retention policy.

Brands to compare

Brother

The Brother MFC-L2800DW is an A4 all-in-one monochrome laser printer. Brother lists an automatic document feeder with a 50-sheet capacity for this model.

  • Brother lists network connectivity, with toner and drum supplied separately.
  • Automatic duplex printing does not confirm that the model also scans both sides automatically.

Epson

The Epson EcoTank ET-4951 combines colour printing with refillable ink tanks and a duplex ADF, as listed by Epson.

  • Epson lists ink bottles and high stated print yields.
  • Stated yields are manufacturer figures and do not, on their own, determine the cost of the group's actual usage.

Canon

The Canon MAXIFY GX4050 is a colour model with refillable ink tanks, a flatbed scanner and a 35-sheet ADF for A4 paper.

  • Canon lists Ethernet and a user-replaceable maintenance cartridge.
  • The listed duplex printing and single-sided scanning features do not confirm duplex ADF scanning.

HP

HP lists an automatic document feeder and duplex scanning for the OfficeJet Pro 9120e.

  • Duplex scanning is useful when completed reverse sides need to be captured automatically.
  • HP lists dynamic cartridge security; check which replacement cartridges suit your usage.

Joybuy products for scanning questionnaires

These Joybuy options are designed for scanning questionnaires: one model with an ADF for stacks of individual forms, and one for forms placed on the flatbed scanner one sheet at a time. Both require extra handling if you want to capture completed reverse sides.

HP Smart Tank 7305 Wireless All-in-One colour printer, duplex printing

HP Smart Tank 7305 Wireless All-in-One colour printer, duplex printing

Suitable for scanning stacks of compatible individual forms.

Duplex scanning is not available; scan completed reverse sides separately.

View at Joybuy
HP Smart Tank 7005 Wireless All-in-One colour printer, duplex printing

HP Smart Tank 7005 Wireless All-in-One colour printer, duplex printing

Suitable for a small number of questionnaires that you place on the flatbed scanner one sheet at a time.

Duplex scanning is not available; turn forms with completed reverse sides over by hand.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is automatic duplex printing the same as duplex scanning?

No. Check the scanning features separately: Brother lists an ADF and duplex printing for the MFC-L2800DW, while Epson lists a duplex ADF for the ET-4951.

Can OCR reliably capture handwritten answers?

Don't rely on it. Microsoft Support says handwriting is rarely recognised, so check the scan of the form and review any recognised text.

What should you check when setting up a shared scanner?

Use a test document to check the connection, scan destination, file access and page order. If the forms contain personal data, the organisation must tailor its security measures to the risks of its processing, as the Dutch Data Protection Authority advises.

How can you compare printing costs without confusing them with scanning volumes?

Estimate the number of black-and-white and colour pages printed separately from the scanning volume, then compare the models' consumables and maintenance parts. Brother lists toner and drum separately for the MFC-L2800DW; Canon lists a replaceable maintenance cartridge for the MAXIFY GX4050.

Can a group in the Netherlands scan completed questionnaires, and how long can scans be kept?

If answers can be linked to individuals, directly or indirectly, recording and storing them counts as processing personal data. This requires an applicable legal basis under the GDPR; consent is one possible basis, but it is not automatically the right choice. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says the GDPR does not set a specific general retention period. So decide how long the data needs to be kept for its purpose, and check whether other retention requirements apply to your situation.