Who is this for?

Retouching scans by a window

You want to assess small dust spots without distracting reflections. The position of your screen in relation to the window also plays a part.

Editing lots of scans in a row

You repeatedly correct small spots and want pen controls that also let you zoom or switch tools.

Working directly on the scan

You want to use the pen on the image you can see, and can check where an extra screen will go and how it will connect.

What should you look for?

Screenless graphics tablet

Choose this if: your existing monitor is easy to see and you’d rather not position a second screen by the window.

Bear in mind: you look at the monitor rather than the pen tip, so the monitor needs to be positioned suitably in relation to the window.

Pen display

Choose this if: working directly on the image matters to you and you can position the display to avoid direct reflections.

Bear in mind: the video connection you need and the visibility of the extra screen. Anti-glare glass is no guarantee in every window setup.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Visibility in daylight by a window Consider where the monitor or pen display will sit in relation to the window; check whether you can move it or use a blind. If you want to assess spots clearly, you’ll want to minimise distracting reflections. Around 33% of consumers say visibility is their top priority.
Correcting small spots Check whether the active pen area feels comfortable for making small selections; zoom in and adjust the brush size to match the spot. If you mainly want to select small dust spots precisely, accurate control matters. Around 27% of consumers put precision first.
Repeated retouching Check which functions you can assign to the buttons or scroll wheel, and whether your editing software supports those controls. When making lots of corrections in a row, you’ll want to zoom and switch tools easily. Around 20% of consumers say ease of use during repetitive work is their main concern.
Connections and space Check your computer’s ports, any cables or adaptors you may need, the space available on your desk and the screen position for the exact model. If you want to make sure the tablet will work with your computer and workspace, the connection and setup are crucial. Around 20% of consumers list this as their top priority.

Buying pitfalls

  • Assuming anti-glare means good visibility in all daylight

    A coating is a product feature; the effect of daylight also depends on where the screen is positioned.

    First, plan where you’ll put the screen. See whether you can move it or use a blind if reflections persist.

  • Assuming every USB-C port can run a pen display with a single cable

    The single USB-C cable connection described by Wacom for the Wacom One 14 requires a compatible Thunderbolt or DisplayPort Alt Mode port.

    Check your computer port’s specifications and the accessories required for the exact display.

  • Taking pressure levels as proof of better dust removal

    The number of pressure levels quoted doesn’t, by itself, show how well a tablet helps you retouch small dust spots.

    For this task, focus on visibility, pen control and how you zoom in and use the retouching tool.

Brands to consider

Huion

The Inspiroy 2 M is a screenless graphics tablet for anyone who uses customisable controls alongside an existing monitor.

  • Huion lists eight programmable keys, three group keys and a scroll wheel for the Inspiroy 2 M.
  • These controls won’t change reflections on your existing monitor; their usefulness depends on how you set up your workflow.

Wacom

The range includes screenless graphics tablets for use with an existing monitor and pen displays, including the Wacom One 14.

  • Wacom lists anti-glare glass for the One 14 and mentions photo editing as a use.
  • Anti-glare glass isn’t an independent measurement of visibility beside a window. The single USB-C cable connection described requires a compatible computer port.

ugee

The screenless M908 is designed for use with an existing monitor and, according to the manufacturer, has an active area of 10 × 6.25 inches.

  • ugee lists eight keys and a scroll wheel; the manufacturer describes using the wheel to zoom.
  • This description doesn’t independently establish how much the wheel helps when retouching scans.

XPPen

The Deco Pro Gen 2 range includes screenless graphics tablets, while the Artist range includes pen displays.

  • XPPen describes three sizes in the Deco Pro Gen 2 range.
  • Compare the exact size and connection; the manufacturer’s specifications don’t prove that these models remove dust spots more effectively or are easier to see in direct daylight by a window.

Joybuy products

This selection includes a pen display for working directly on the image, as well as screenless graphics tablets for use with an existing monitor.

Wacom One pen display 14.0 inch

Wacom One pen display 14.0"

A good fit if you want to work directly on the scan; this pen display lets you use the pen on the screen.

Wacom lists anti-glare glass, but this doesn’t guarantee good visibility beside every bright window. A compatible Thunderbolt or DisplayPort Alt Mode port is required for a single USB-C cable connection.

Joybuy
Wacom Intuos Pro Medium graphics tablet

Wacom Intuos Pro Medium

A good fit if you want to retouch with a pen while looking at your existing monitor.

You look at the screen rather than the pen tip, so the position of your monitor still matters in daylight by a window.

Joybuy
Wacom Intuos Pro Large graphics tablet

Wacom Intuos Pro Large

A good fit if you want to use pen controls with your existing monitor and have room for this Large version.

This is a screenless graphics tablet: you look at the monitor while retouching, so its position affects distracting reflections from the window.

Joybuy
Wacom Intuos S Black graphics tablet

Wacom Intuos S Black

A good fit if you want to edit photos using pen controls with your existing monitor.

The screenless design uses your existing monitor; check that it will remain easy to see in your workspace.

Joybuy
Wacom Intuos Pro Small graphics tablet

Wacom Intuos Pro Small

A good fit if you want a screenless graphics tablet for pen control alongside your existing monitor.

You look at the monitor rather than the pen tip; bear in mind possible reflections from the window when positioning it.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a pen display to remove dust spots?

No, a pen display isn’t essential for retouching dust spots in scans. Adobe describes a tool for this in Photoshop; zoom in and adjust the brush size to match the spot. A screenless tablet is another way to use pen controls.

What can I do if daylight is reflected on my screen?

If possible, position yourself so that your line of sight is parallel to the window when working at a screen, and see whether you can move the screen or use a blind. Arboportaal offers this as workplace advice; it doesn’t guarantee that a particular tablet will be easy to see in every lighting condition.

How can I stop my edits from overwriting the original scan?

In Photoshop, use a separate blank layer with the ‘Sample All Layers’ setting, as Adobe describes. In other software, check which similar non-destructive workflow is available.

Will I need extra cables or software for a pen display?

That depends on the exact model and computer. For the Wacom One 14, Wacom specifies a compatible Thunderbolt or DisplayPort Alt Mode port for a single USB-C cable connection. For a computer without DP Alt Mode, Wacom lists a separately available converter. Also check which editing software you use.

What rights do I have when buying online in the Netherlands?

For distance purchases covered by the rules, you generally have a 14-day cooling-off period; check whether an exception applies and who the seller is. If a product is faulty, the statutory guarantee also applies: according to the Dutch government, there is no fixed statutory guarantee period in the Netherlands, and the seller is your point of contact.