Who is this choice relevant to?

Photo editors refining fine mask edges

For example, you might use targeted brush strokes to correct hair or other complex transitions. A graphics tablet can give you pen control while you continue using the selection tools in your editing software.

Photo editors working at a bright desk

You work beside a bright window and want to weigh up whether your existing monitor is enough, or whether an additional pen display would be practical to use in that spot.

Photo editors with limited desk space

You want to use a pen with your computer without automatically adding another screen to your desk. The setup and how you use it also factor into your choice.

What should you consider when choosing?

Screenless graphics tablet

A good fit if: your existing monitor is easy to see at your workstation and you want to refine mask edges by hand while looking at that screen.

Keep in mind: you draw on a different surface from the image you’re assessing. Also check that the driver and pen features work with your computer and software.

Pen display

A good fit if: drawing directly on the image matters more to you than simply using your existing monitor.

Keep in mind: you’re adding a screen that you’ll need to position beside the window and connect. Check the stand, cables and power supply included with the exact model.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Fine mask edges Check that the pen, driver and editing software work together. Try the brush settings you need for manual corrections. If I want to refine hair or other complex edges precisely, I want to know whether pen control suits the way I work. Around 33% of consumers prioritise control over fine mask edges.
Visibility beside the window Assess the screen in the intended spot; don’t assume it will be visible in bright ambient light just because it’s described as anti-reflective. If I want to use a pen display beside a bright window, I need to be able to judge whether the image is clear enough for me in that spot. Around 27% of consumers prioritise this readability.
Connectivity and software Check your computer ports, driver and software support for the exact model. A pen display may also need video and power connections. If I want to be sure the tablet works with my computer and editing software, I check the connections and features in advance. Around 20% of consumers give compatibility and software functionality top priority.
Desk setup Compare the desk space required and, for a pen display, the screen size and included stand. If I want to keep using my existing monitor and don’t want another screen on my desk, the space the setup takes up matters. Around 20% of consumers focus on workspace and practical layout.

Things to watch out for when buying

  • Assuming anti-reflective means it will be easy to see beside the window

    An anti-reflective finish describes a feature of the screen surface, but on its own it doesn’t tell you how clearly you’ll be able to assess the image in the light from your window.

    Consider where you plan to position the screen and assess the image in the lighting conditions you’ll be working in before choosing a pen display.

  • Treating different generations of the Intuos Pro Medium as the same model

    A Joybuy page for an Intuos Pro Medium mentions a Pro Pen and Touch Ring, while Wacom lists a Pro Pen 3 and customisable controls for the PTK670. These product descriptions don’t necessarily refer to the same version.

    Before buying, compare the full model code, pen and controls. Don’t use the Joybuy page mentioned as a purchase link for the PTK670.

  • Assuming every tablet is officially supported by Photoshop

    Adobe says that it doesn’t test or officially support tablets from other brands. That doesn’t, by itself, tell you whether a specific combination will work for the way you use it.

    Check support with the tablet manufacturer and test the pen and brush features you need with your computer and software.

Relevant brands to consider

Wacom

Wacom offers both screenless graphics tablets and pen displays, so you can choose between drawing on a tablet and working directly on a screen.

  • For the Intuos Pro Medium PTK670, Wacom lists a Pro Pen 3 and customisable controls. For the Cintiq 16 DTK168, Wacom specifies etched anti-reflective glass.
  • These features are specific to each model. An anti-reflective finish doesn’t prove that a Cintiq screen will be easy to see beside every window.

Huion

Huion offers the screenless Inspiroy 2 M and the Kamvas 13 (Gen 3) pen display.

  • Huion lists a scroller and keys for the Inspiroy 2 M, and laminated glass with an anti-reflective finish for the Kamvas 13 (Gen 3).
  • For the Kamvas, check the exact version and which stand is included. The screen finish isn’t an independent comparison of visibility in light from a window.

XPPen

XPPen offers a screenless option with the Deco Pro (Gen 2) and a pen display with the Artist Pro 16 (Gen 2).

  • XPPen lists an X3 Pro pen for these product lines.
  • Manufacturer claims about pressure levels or accuracy don’t prove that complex masks will be better. Check the exact version and how it works with your software.

Screenless graphics tablets at Joybuy

These Joybuy products are screenless graphics tablets for anyone who wants to assess mask edges on an existing monitor.

Wacom Intuos Pro Medium graphics tablet

Wacom Intuos Pro Medium Pen Tablet

A screenless tablet for anyone who wants to assess brush corrections on their existing monitor.

The product description lists 8,192 pressure levels, customisable ExpressKeys and a Touch Ring. Check the model version and controls you need before ordering.

View at Joybuy
Wacom Intuos Pro Large graphics tablet

Wacom Intuos Pro Large

A screenless graphics tablet for anyone who wants to work on an existing monitor and is looking for a Large version.

The product name lists a Pro Pen 3 and 8,192 pressure levels. The description mentions Bluetooth and USB-C.

View at Joybuy
Wacom Intuos S Black graphics tablet

Wacom Intuos S Black

A screenless option that lets you draw with a pen on the tablet and view the mask edge on your existing monitor.

The product description lists a pressure-sensitive pen, 4,096 pressure levels and four customisable ExpressKeys.

View at Joybuy
Wacom Intuos Pro Small graphics tablet

Wacom Intuos Pro Small Pen Tablet

A screenless graphics tablet for anyone who wants to view mask edges on an existing monitor and is looking for a Small version.

The product description lists 8,192 pressure levels, four customisable ExpressKeys and Bluetooth/USB-C. The active drawing area is specified as 187 × 105 mm.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do more pressure levels automatically make a difficult hair selection better?

No. Adobe describes separate Photoshop features for refining hair selections and edges; pen pressure affects brush behaviour, among other things. So consider both your software workflow and the pen, rather than choosing based only on the stated number of pressure levels.

What should you set up after connecting your tablet for manual corrections?

Install the appropriate driver and check the pen settings in your editing software. Adobe explains how to set up pen pressure for brush behaviour in Photoshop; then check that the setting works with your computer and tablet.

Which parts should you check when buying a graphics tablet?

Check which pen nibs, cables and any stand are included with the version you’ve chosen, and which replacement parts are available for that model. This helps you make sure the set is complete for your workspace.

In the Netherlands, are you always limited to a two-year guarantee, and can you cancel an online purchase?

No. According to the Dutch government, there’s no fixed term for the statutory guarantee in the Netherlands: what you could reasonably expect from the product is what matters, and the seller is your point of contact if a product is faulty. For distance purchases, you usually have a 14-day cooling-off period; check whether these rules apply to your purchase.