Who is this choice relevant to?

Custodian of irreplaceable scans

You want to be able to recover original scans and family tree files after loss, mistakes or damage. The National Cyber Security Centre therefore recommends keeping a separate backup and testing recovery.

Volunteer coordinator

You want volunteers to work together on the collection while controlling who can view or edit files, particularly when the material also contains information about living people. The Dutch Data Protection Authority highlights the importance of protecting personal data.

Manager of a growing collection

You want to catalogue existing files and new additions, then work out how much usable storage you need. The Dutch Digital Heritage Network highlights the importance of an inventory, while the National Archives explains how metadata records the context of archival material.

What should you look for?

Start by assessing your files, expected growth and recovery needs. Then choose the drive bays and access features that suit the volunteers’ work.

What to consider What to look for when buying Who is this important for?
Recovering files Check whether you can copy files to a separate destination and who will carry out recovery tests. If scans are difficult to collect again, I want to know I can restore them after a loss or mistake. Around 33% of consumers rank recoverability as their top priority.
Access and privacy Check accounts, folder permissions and how volunteers can access files remotely, if needed. When volunteers have different roles, I want to tailor their access to the files they need. Around 27% of consumers put controlled access at the top of their list.
Finding scans and their context Test the folder structure, file names and export of files with their contextual information. If a scan is to remain meaningful in the future, I want to be able to find its provenance and description too. Around 20% of consumers rank ease of retrieval as their top priority.
Usable capacity and storage costs Calculate the space available with your chosen drives and configuration; check compatibility with the exact NAS model. When new items are added, I want to have enough usable space left and not focus only on the drives’ raw capacity. Around 20% of consumers put room to grow at the top of their list.

Common pitfalls

  • Relying on RAID or snapshots as the only archive copy

    Drive redundancy within the same NAS is no substitute for a separate backup. If the NAS holds the only copy, a problem with that storage could still make the collection inaccessible.

    Before you buy, agree where an independent copy will be kept and plan recovery tests. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends checking that you can restore files from a backup.

  • Assuming raw capacity or the number of bays equals usable space

    The available space depends on the installed drives and the configuration you choose. The enclosure may also be sold without hard drives.

    Calculate the usable space for your planned configuration and check the packaging and compatibility information for the exact model.

  • Assuming central storage automatically creates a searchable, public archive

    Files need descriptive metadata and context to be found and understood later. Publishing material that contains information about living people also requires a separate privacy assessment.

    Test the organisation and export process with your own scans. Keep internal collaboration separate from public access, and decide separately whether material can be published.

NAS brands to compare

Synology

The DS225+ has two drive bays, while the DS925+ has four. Both models are worth comparing for centralised file management and scheduled backups.

  • Synology lists one 2.5GbE port for the DS225+ and two for the DS925+.
  • Usable capacity depends on the drives and configuration. Check the compatibility information for the exact model; the policy on third-party drives for certain Plus models changed from DSM 7.3.

QNAP

The TS-264-8G is a two-bay model to compare for centralised file management and backup features.

  • QNAP lists two 2.5GbE ports for the TS-264-8G.
  • QNAP supplies this model without hard drives. Check the software configuration required for features such as WORM in QuTS hero.

ASUSTOR

The Lockerstor 2 Gen2 AS6702T is a two-bay model for anyone who also wants to explore the snapshot capabilities described by the manufacturer.

  • ASUSTOR lists two 2.5GbE ports and options for drive layouts and snapshots.
  • Snapshots on the same NAS are not a separately stored archive copy. Check the configuration and recovery procedure for the exact model.

TerraMaster

The F4-424 is a four-bay model for collections where your growth projections make extra internal drive capacity desirable.

  • TerraMaster lists two 2.5GbE ports and support for various RAID layouts.
  • The transfer rate published by the manufacturer was measured using four specific drives in RAID 0. It does not predict the speed or data protection of a different configuration.

Joybuy product picks

These NAS models offer options for centralised file sharing and backup management, with different numbers of internal drive bays to suit collections with varying growth needs.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

This model suits a collection where five internal drive bays match your projected growth and you need centralised file sharing.

According to the product description, the NAS has five drive bays, can be expanded to fifteen and has two 2.5GbE ports. Hard drives are not included.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation Intel Celeron J4125 Q

Synology DiskStation Intel Celeron J4125 Q

This model may suit a collection that will fit within a two-bay configuration and where volunteers need shared folders.

The product description lists RAID 0/1/JBOD, user accounts, shared folders and Cloud Sync. The enclosure is supplied without drives; RAID is no substitute for a separate backup.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

This model is an option if your inventory and expected incoming additions suit a NAS with eight internal drive bays.

The product description lists eight drive bays and expansion with an expansion unit. The DSM applications mentioned include file sharing and backup.

Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+ without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

This model suits a collection where four internal bays match your projected growth and you need centralised file sharing.

The product description lists expansion to nine drive bays and two 2.5GbE ports. Hard drives are not included; check compatibility for the exact model.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does a NAS with two drives also count as a backup?

No. A NAS with two drives is not, by itself, a separate backup. The National Cyber Security Centre distinguishes between RAID redundancy and a backup, so plan an additional copy on another destination and test that you can restore files.

What should you do with existing scans before installation?

Make an inventory of file sizes, formats and current locations before moving the collection. Keep existing copies until you have checked that the new storage and a separate copy can be used for recovery, and choose drives that are compatible with the exact NAS model.

How can you keep a genealogy collection useful in the long term?

Keep provenance and descriptive metadata with the files, and keep track of formats and storage locations. The Dutch Digital Heritage Network highlights that long-term preservation takes more than a storage medium alone; check your copies and recovery process too.

Can a community archive simply put information about living people online?

Not without first assessing the applicable privacy rules and circumstances. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, processing personal data requires a lawful basis under the GDPR, and consent is needed in most cases to publish it online. Information about people who have died can also reveal details about living relatives.

What ongoing costs and support should you factor in?

Budget for suitable drives, a separate backup destination and time for administration, as well as the NAS enclosure. Also check drive compatibility information and the software configuration you plan to use; QNAP, for example, states that the TS-264-8G is supplied without hard drives.