Who is this relevant to?

Replay viewer with housemates

You often want to pause and rewind, but need to be mindful of keyboard noise in a shared living space.

Student with one desk

You use a limited workspace for studying, mouse movement and replay analysis, and want to keep essential shortcuts within easy reach.

Player who analyses too

You watch replays as well as playing competitively; adjustable actuation could be another reason to choose a particular keyboard.

What should you look for?

VideoLAN documents, among other things, the space bar for playing and pausing in VLC, and Shift with an arrow key for skipping. To save a Replay Buffer in OBS, you need to set a hotkey yourself, according to the OBS Project guide.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this most relevant to?
Keyboard noise in a shared room Check the switch type and the exact version; a claim such as ‘quiet’ doesn’t measure how loud it will be in your room. If I pause and rewind often, I want to be considerate of my housemates. Around 34% of consumers prioritise keeping keyboard noise down.
Keys for controlling replays Make a note of the hotkeys for your player, game or recording software, and check that the arrow and function keys you need are accessible individually. I want to play, navigate or save a clip quickly without awkward key combinations. For around 33% of consumers, easily accessible replay controls are their main concern.
Space next to the mouse Measure the space available and check the exact layout, rather than relying on the ‘compact’ label alone. With one desk for studying and gaming, I want to leave room for my mouse. This is the top consideration for around 20% of consumers.
Whether extra gaming features are useful Decide whether you also want to use adjustable actuation while playing competitively; Rapid Trigger isn’t essential for ordinary video navigation. I mainly want to choose features I’ll actually use, rather than settings I don’t need for controlling replays. Around 13% of consumers prioritise this.

Avoiding common buying mistakes

  • Choosing a 60% layout without checking your replay commands

    In VLC, you use Shift with an arrow key to skip; a smaller layout may leave out dedicated keys.

    Write down the commands you use most and check the physical layout before choosing an extra-compact version.

  • Confusing a ‘mechanical feel’ with mechanical switches

    SteelSeries describes the Apex 3 TKL as having a mechanical feel, but RTINGS discusses the model as a non-mechanical keyboard option.

    Check the actual switch mechanism if the switch type or the ability to replace the switches matters to you.

  • Assuming the Wooting 80HE+ is the same version as the 80HE

    According to Wooting, the 80HE+ and 80HE differ in their switches and switch plate, among other things.

    Check the full model name and compare the specifications of the version you’re considering.

Brands to compare

SteelSeries

The Apex 3 TKL is a compact option if you’re looking for a model the manufacturer describes as quiet.

  • SteelSeries lists Whisper Quiet switches and an IP32 rating for the Apex 3 TKL.
  • RTINGS considers the model suitable for quiet, non-competitive use, but doesn’t recommend it for competitive play because of its higher input lag. This assessment applies to this model.

Trust

The GXT 833 Thado is a straightforward TKL option; the GXT 864 Cada is a separate mechanical model.

  • Trust lists media keys and anti-ghosting for up to ten simultaneous keystrokes on the Thado.
  • The tactile Huano Brown switches are used in the Cada, not the Thado.

HyperX

The Alloy Origins Core is a mechanical TKL option for anyone using the same keyboard for gaming, typing and analysis.

  • HyperX lists a detachable USB-C cable and three adjustable tilt settings.
  • Keyboard noise depends partly on the switches and construction; a TKL layout alone doesn’t tell you how loud it will be in your room.

Razer

The BlackWidow V4 75% combines a compact layout with a function row, arrow keys and compatible hot-swappable switches.

  • Razer describes the pre-installed Orange Tactile Gen-3 switches as quieter than clicky switches.
  • Check which version you’re buying: the barebones version comes without switches, keycaps or a wrist rest.

Wooting

The 80HE is an option if you combine replay analysis with competitive gaming and want adjustable magnetic input.

  • Wooting lists Rapid Trigger and adjustable actuation for the 80HE.
  • According to Wooting, the 80HE+ has different switches and a different switch plate; compare the versions separately.

Joybuy products for replay analysis

This selection includes compact TKL and 75% models, including wired, mechanical and magnetic versions. Compare the layout and the listed switch or input features with the keys you need to control replays.

GXTrust Thado wired gaming keyboard, TKL, QWERTY, black

GXTrust Thado, wired gaming keyboard, TKL, QWERTY, black

The wired TKL layout is an option if you’re looking for a compact setup for controlling replays.

The product name lists a QWERTY layout and compatibility with PC and PS5.

View at Joybuy
Corsair K70 CORE TKL mechanical gaming keyboard, BE AZERTY, MLX Red, black

Corsair K70 CORE TKL, BE AZERTY, MLX Red, black

This mechanical TKL model could suit you if you’re looking for a compact layout and the Belgian AZERTY version works for you.

The product name lists MLX Red switches and a BE AZERTY layout.

View at Joybuy
AJAZZ AK820 MAX wired mechanical gaming keyboard with magnetic switches, 82 keys

AJAZZ AK820 MAX, wired, magnetic switches, 82 keys

The product name lists magnetic switches and adjustable RT, features to compare if you also want to use the keyboard for competitive play.

The product name also lists a wired connection and 82 keys.

View at Joybuy
AJAZZ AK820 Pro 75% tri-mode mechanical keyboard, QWERTY US, Purple Flying Fish switches

AJAZZ AK820 Pro 75%, tri-mode, QWERTY US, Purple Flying Fish switches

The 75% layout is an option if you’re looking for a compact model with a separate set of arrow and function keys.

The product name lists wired, Bluetooth and 2.4GHz connections, as well as hot-swappable Purple Flying Fish switches.

View at Joybuy
AULA F75 75% wireless mechanical gaming keyboard, QWERTY US

AULA F75 75%, wireless, QWERTY US

The 75% layout is worth considering if you’re looking for a compact setup with function keys included in the keyboard layout.

The product name lists a mechanical keyboard with three connection modes and PBT keycaps.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do you need a keyboard with Rapid Trigger for replay analysis?

No, not for the basic VLC controls described here or for setting an OBS hotkey. Adjustable actuation may be another reason to choose a keyboard if you also want to use those settings while playing competitively.

How do you set a key in OBS to save a replay clip?

If you use the OBS Replay Buffer, the OBS Project guide says to set a hotkey yourself under Hotkeys to save the buffer. Check that the combination doesn’t conflict with your game’s hotkeys.

What if you’re unhappy with a keyboard bought online, or it’s faulty?

In the Netherlands, purchases made online from a business often come with a 14-day cooling-off period. You also have statutory rights if a product is faulty; there’s no fixed statutory guarantee period in the Netherlands, and the seller is your point of contact if there’s a problem.