Who is this for?

Replay analyst

You listen to short gameplay moments repeatedly and want to pick out ambient cues, speech and other details. Always compare the same familiar recording. RTINGS highlights accurate reproduction of in-game cues as something to consider when choosing a gaming headset.

Long-session gamer

You wear your headset for hours at a time and want to minimise pressure, heat or discomfort caused by the fit. RTINGS highlights comfort during long sessions. HyperX describes memory foam for the wired Cloud III, while Logitech G lists different ear cushion materials for the PRO X 2. Fit is a personal matter.

Multiplatform gamer

You switch between devices such as a PC and console, and want to check that the connection, microphone and any software features work with each one. HyperX and SteelSeries describe different connection options for specific headset models.

What should you look for when choosing?

Start by choosing a suitable connection and fit. Then compare sound settings using a familiar replay at the same volume.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this most relevant to?
Replay details Compare the same familiar recording at the same volume, with and without any available EQ or presets. If I listen to short clips repeatedly, I want to pick out cues without relying on an unproven profile advantage. Around 31% of consumers put replay details first.
Comfort during long sessions Assess the fit, headband and ear cushion material for yourself. Material alone doesn’t predict how a headset will feel on your head. If I wear my headset for a long time, I want to minimise pressure and heat so the fit doesn’t distract me. Around 31% of consumers put comfort first.
Platform and connectivity Check the exact version, connection, dongle support and availability of software features for your device. If I switch between devices, I want to know which features work with each one before choosing a version. Around 25% of consumers put platform and connection compatibility first.
Uninterrupted use For wireless models, check the stated battery life and charging method. For a wired headset, consider whether the cable will work well with your setup. If I spend a long time at my playback device, I want to avoid being distracted by a cable or a flat battery. Around 13% of consumers put uninterrupted use first.

Pitfalls to avoid when buying

  • Assuming a profile that emphasises footsteps will improve replay analysis

    A customised profile changes how sound is reproduced. A manufacturer’s description of enhanced competitive sounds doesn’t prove that it will help you assess your recordings more accurately.

    Compare the same clip at the same volume, with and without the profile.

  • Assuming every version with the same model name is identical

    Connections and platform versions can differ. The 2023 BlackShark V2 Pro version described by Razer isn’t necessarily the same as a model with that family name and a PlayStation licence.

    Before buying, compare the full model name and connection with your playback device.

  • Confusing an additional warranty with your existing statutory rights

    According to the Rijksoverheid, an additional warranty is only worthwhile if its terms genuinely add to your rights when a product is faulty.

    Read the terms and check what the provider is offering on top of your existing rights before choosing it.

Brands to consider

HyperX

The wired Cloud III may suit a setup where having several physical connection options is important to you.

  • HyperX lists memory foam, 53 mm drivers and 3.5 mm, USB-A and USB-C connections for the wired Cloud III.
  • These features don’t prove that every HyperX headset will feel comfortable or make replay details easier to hear. Check which connection and features work with your device.

SteelSeries

The Arctis Nova 5 is worth considering if you want to pair a 2.4GHz dongle with Bluetooth switching and adjustable sound profiles.

  • SteelSeries describes presets, supported USB-C devices and a stated battery life of up to 60 hours.
  • Emphasising footsteps is a manufacturer’s description, not proof of better replay analysis. Check the platform version and compare the sound for yourself.

Logitech G

The PRO X 2 LIGHTSPEED may suit you if you want to listen wirelessly and choose between different ear cushion materials.

  • For this model, Logitech G lists LIGHTSPEED, a stated battery life of up to 50 hours and leatherette or velour ear cushions.
  • The claim of competitive audio precision hasn’t been independently verified for your replays. Assess the fit and listen to a familiar recording for yourself.

Razer

The 2023 BlackShark V2 Pro version described by Razer is aimed at wireless competitive gaming and voice communication.

  • For this version, Razer lists FPS profiles, a detachable microphone and a stated battery life of up to 70 hours.
  • These features don’t automatically apply to other versions with the same model name. Check the exact version and its features.

Audeze

The Maxwell 2 may be worth considering if sound quality matters more to you than a lightweight design.

  • RTINGS covers the Maxwell 2 in its gaming headset guide.
  • RTINGS also notes its relatively heavy weight. If comfortable listening for long periods is your priority, assess the fit for yourself.

Headsets for different setups

This selection of Joybuy products includes wired and wireless gaming headsets for different replay setups. Check that each model’s connection and version are suitable for your device.

ASUS ROG Pelta wired and wireless gaming headset

ASUS ROG Pelta, wired and wireless

Worth considering if you want the option of a wired or wireless setup.

The product name lists USB Type-C and Bluetooth.

Remember that you’ll need to recharge it when using it wirelessly.

View at Joybuy
Razer Barracuda X wireless gaming headset in white

Razer Barracuda X, wireless, white

Worth considering if you’re looking for a wireless headset for a replay setup.

Before buying, check that the connection and version are suitable for your playback device.

View at Joybuy
HyperX Cloud III S wireless gaming headset

HyperX Cloud III S, wireless

Worth considering if you want to listen wirelessly and are choosing between Bluetooth and 2.4 GHz.

The product name lists up to 200 hours via Bluetooth and up to 120 hours via 2.4 GHz; these are stated usage times.

The product name lists memory foam, a detachable 10 mm microphone and compatibility with PC, PS5, PS4, Switch and mobile devices.

View at Joybuy
Razer BlackShark V2 X 7.1 wired gaming headset

Razer BlackShark V2 X 7.1, wired

A wired version worth considering if you stay close to your playback device.

Check that this version’s connection is suitable for your device.

View at Joybuy
HyperX Cloud III wired gaming headset for PC, PS5 and Xbox Series X|S

HyperX Cloud III, wired

A wired option worth considering if you’re connecting the headset to a fixed replay setup.

The product name lists PC, PS5 and Xbox Series X|S. Check that this version’s connection is suitable for your device.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Should you automatically enable virtual surround sound for competitive replays?

No. First, compare the same familiar passage at the same volume using the available sound modes. A preset that the manufacturer says emphasises footsteps doesn’t, by itself, prove that you’ll assess the replay more accurately.

How should you connect a headset for your replays?

First, check which device you use to play back the replay, then choose a supported connection. HyperX lists 3.5 mm, USB-A and USB-C connections for the wired Cloud III. For the Arctis Nova 5, SteelSeries describes a USB-C dongle for supported devices, with the option to switch to Bluetooth. Check which features work with your device and exact version.

How can you reduce the risks of listening for long periods?

Pay attention to both volume and listening time. VeiligheidNL recommends well-fitting headphones, as this can reduce the temptation to turn up the volume to block out background noise. It also recommends using a volume limit on mobile devices.

What are your rights if a headset bought online disappoints or is faulty?

According to ACM ConsuWijzer, online purchases generally come with a 14-day cooling-off period after delivery, subject to legal exceptions. The Rijksoverheid states that there is no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands. If a product is faulty, the retailer is your point of contact.