Who is this guide for?

Replay listeners comparing details

You listen to clips repeatedly to compare direction and subtle sounds. Assess headsets using the same replay and volume setting, rather than basing your choice on a surround label alone.

Listeners during long sessions

You wear your headset for extended periods and want a headband and ear cushions that suit you. A description of the materials won’t tell you how the headset will fit your head.

Replay reviewers who discuss clips

You discuss clips over voice chat, so you’ll need a usable microphone as well as playback audio and a connection that suits your device.

What should you look for in a gaming headset for replays?

First, check that the connection and features work with your replay device. Then compare the same passage at the same, moderate volume, and decide whether the fit and controls are suitable for long sessions.

What to consider What should you check? Who should pay particular attention?
Replay details Compare the same passage at the same volume, and check whether any spatial processing works on your device. If I listen to clips repeatedly, I want to assess the details without relying on a surround label. Around 28% of consumers give sound detail top priority.
Comfort Assess the fit, including when wearing glasses, and try wearing the headset for a while if possible. During a long review session, I don’t want to feel pressure from the headband or ear cushions. Around 22% of consumers put comfort first.
Device compatibility Check the exact headset variant, available ports and whether the features you want will work. If I want to know first whether the headset works with my PC or console, I’ll check the connection and features together. Around 22% of consumers choose compatibility as their top consideration.
Controls in the dark Test whether you can find the buttons by touch and whether any lighting can be adjusted to suit you. In a dark room, I want to adjust the volume and mute the microphone without the lighting distracting me. Around 17% of consumers prioritise unobtrusive controls.
Voice chat Make a test recording on your own platform and check the mute control. If I discuss a replay with teammates, a usable microphone matters just as much as the playback audio. Around 11% of consumers prioritise team communication.

Pitfalls when buying a headset for replays

  • Assuming a surround label means better positional accuracy

    Surround playback also depends on the platform you use; the label doesn’t tell you how a specific replay will sound on your device.

    Compare the same passage and settings on your own device.

  • Choosing a wireless headset without checking the platform variant

    Connections and supported features vary by model and variant. A feature won’t necessarily work with every PC or console.

    Check the full model name, the ports available on your device and the features you want to use.

  • Overlooking lighting and controls in a dark room

    Logitech states that advanced lighting settings on the G733 require G HUB. It’s also worth checking in advance whether you can find the controls by touch.

    Check whether you can adjust the lighting to suit you and whether the volume and mute controls are easy to use.

  • Confusing an additional warranty service with your statutory rights

    According to the Dutch government, the seller is responsible for resolving issues with faulty products. The Netherlands has no fixed statutory warranty period.

    Before choosing an additional service, compare its cover with your existing statutory rights.

Brands to compare

These brands offer models with different connections and features. The details below apply to the product ranges mentioned, not to every model from each brand.

HyperX

The Cloud III Wired is a wired option to compare if you’re looking for several connection options and a detachable microphone.

  • HyperX lists 3.5 mm, USB-C and USB-A connections, memory foam and a detachable microphone for this model.
  • Check which connection and features work with your device; the materials description doesn’t guarantee a fit that suits you.

SteelSeries

The Arctis Nova 5 Wireless is worth considering if you want to listen wirelessly and compare audio profiles or on-headset controls.

  • SteelSeries lists a USB-C dongle, switching between 2.4 GHz and Bluetooth, and a quoted battery life of 60 hours.
  • Check that you’re looking at the right platform variant and that your preferred profiles are available; the quoted battery life isn’t guaranteed in every situation.

Logitech G

The PRO X 2 LIGHTSPEED and G733 offer different wireless features to compare against your needs and device compatibility.

  • For the PRO X 2, Logitech quotes up to 50 hours of battery life and a choice of velour or leatherette ear cushions.
  • G HUB is required for the advanced lighting settings mentioned for the G733; check whether you can use those settings on your system.

JBL

The Quantum 200 is a wired 3.5 mm option to compare if you’re looking for a simple connection and a flip-up microphone.

  • JBL lists a 3.5 mm connection and memory foam ear cushions.
  • Check that the connection fits your device; the material alone doesn’t tell you how comfortable the headset will feel.

Razer

The BlackShark V2 Pro is a wireless option to compare if microphone features and the version you choose matter to you.

  • For the PC variant, Razer lists a Super Wideband microphone, 50mm drivers and HyperSpeed Wireless.
  • Check whether you’re looking at the PC or console variant; the features listed don’t, on their own, prove better results when locating replay sounds.

Gaming headsets at Joybuy

A selection of gaming headsets at Joybuy to compare for replay use.

SteelSeries Arctis Nova Pro Wireless, PlayStation, black

SteelSeries Arctis Nova Pro Wireless – PlayStation Black

An option for comparing replay settings and voice features; check that the PlayStation version and the features you want suit your setup.

The product information lists EQ adjustment and game audio presets via the base station. The quoted battery life for the swappable batteries is up to 22 hours per battery.

View at Joybuy
Corsair VOID RGB V2 Wireless gaming headset, white, Dolby Atmos

Corsair VOID RGB V2 Wireless Gaming Headset – White, Dolby Atmos

An option if you want to compare wireless listening and on-earcup controls; the product information lists 2.4 GHz via a USB receiver and Bluetooth.

Audio and RGB customisation requires iCUE on a Windows PC.

View at Joybuy
Razer Kraken V3 X headset, black

Razer Kraken V3 X Headset – Black

An option to compare if you also use voice chat during replay reviews; the product information lists a cardioid microphone and on-earcup controls.

The 7.1 surround functionality mentioned is for Windows.

View at Joybuy
ASUS ROG Pelta wired and wireless gaming headset, black

ASUS ROG Pelta Wired & Wireless Gaming Headset – Black

An option for comparing connection options across different replay devices. The product information lists USB-C, 2.4 GHz via a USB receiver and Bluetooth.

Check which connection and controls work with your device and the features you want.

View at Joybuy
HyperX Cloud III S gaming headset, black and red

HyperX Cloud III S Gaming Headset – Black/Red

An option for comparing wireless playback and voice chat during a review; the product information lists 2.4 GHz, Bluetooth and a detachable microphone.

The controls listed include volume and mode. Check that the connection and features suit your replay device.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is virtual surround necessary for assessing competitive replays?

No, don’t choose a headset based on that label alone. Testaankoop Belgium explains that surround playback also depends on the gaming platform you use. So compare the same replay on your own device with the available settings.

How can you listen during long review sessions without constantly turning up the volume?

Keep the volume moderate and take regular listening breaks. The World Health Organization explains that listening louder and for longer increases the risk of hearing damage. Its example of 80 dB for up to 40 hours per week is health guidance, not a guaranteed safe level for every user.

Which connection should you check?

First, check the ports on your replay device and the exact headset variant. The Cloud III Wired lists 3.5 mm, USB-C and USB-A; the Arctis Nova 5 Wireless lists a USB-C dongle for supported platforms. Then check which audio and microphone features work through your connection.

What are your rights if a headset bought online doesn’t suit you or develops a fault?

According to ACM ConsuWijzer, for a standard online product purchase you’ll generally have 14 days from delivery to change your mind; check whether any exceptions apply. If a product is faulty, you also have statutory rights and should contact the seller. The Dutch government states that the Netherlands has no fixed statutory warranty period.