Who is this choice for?

Player with a particular game in mind

You want to know first whether your mystery game works on your chosen console and in the edition you want. For example, Alan Wake 2 is listed for PS5 and Xbox Series X|S, according to PlayStation and Xbox.

Evening player using a TV

You mainly play on a large screen and want to be able to make out dark scenes. The final HDR picture also depends on your TV and the rest of your home set-up, according to PlayStation.

Player who enjoys portable puzzles

You also want to play without a TV, so you’re comparing the screens and game libraries of options such as Nintendo Switch 2 and Steam Deck OLED.

What should you look for?

First, check that the game you want is playable on the exact console and edition you’re considering. Then choose how you want to play, and only after that look at screen technology, disc use and any subscriptions.

What to consider What should you check? Who should weigh this up carefully?
Game availability Look up the full title and edition on the platform’s website; for older Switch games, also check compatibility with Switch 2. If I want to play one particular mystery game, I need to know whether that exact title and edition will work. Around 36% of consumers say availability of the game they want is their top buying priority.
Picture on a TV Check that the game, TV and output settings support the picture mode you want. HDR performance also depends in part on your home set-up. If I mainly play on a TV in the evening, I want to be able to make out dark scenes rather than relying on an HDR label alone. Around 29% of consumers prioritise TV picture quality when choosing.
Built-in screen Compare the screen type and how you want to play, then check compatibility with the handheld for each game. If I want to play without a TV, the built-in screen needs to suit how I play, and my game needs to work on it. Around 21% of consumers make portable play their top priority.
Discs and subscriptions Check whether the model you’ve chosen has a disc drive and whether a game is bought separately or included in a subscription. If I want to use my existing game discs or avoid an unnecessary subscription, I need to check the exact model and purchase option. Around 14% of consumers focus mainly on how they play and ongoing costs.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming HDR guarantees better visibility in dark scenes

    PlayStation says that the picture quality available also depends on your home set-up. So an HDR label on the console alone won’t tell you how the game will look on your TV.

    Check the game, TV and output settings together, rather than choosing based solely on an HDR specification.

  • Assuming a digital console can play game discs

    The PS5 Digital Edition doesn’t have a disc drive, and the Xbox Series S is all-digital. That means you can’t use existing physical games on either console.

    Check your game collection before choosing between a model with a disc drive and a digital model.

  • Buying an older Switch game without checking compatibility

    Nintendo warns that some Switch games aren’t compatible, or aren’t fully compatible, with Switch 2.

    Check the compatibility information for the exact game before you plan to play it on Switch 2.

Relevant brands and platforms

Sony PlayStation

PlayStation 5 is available in digital models and models with a disc drive. Alan Wake 2 is listed for PS5, according to PlayStation.

  • PlayStation lists HDR support for PS5.
  • HDR performance also depends on your home set-up. The Digital Edition doesn’t have a disc drive.

Microsoft Xbox

Xbox Series X|S is an option for playing on a TV. According to Xbox, Alan Wake 2 is listed as optimised for Series X|S.

  • Some Xbox Series X models have a disc drive; check the model you choose.
  • Xbox Series S is all-digital. Game Pass is a separate subscription option, so check whether the game you want is included.

Nintendo

Nintendo Switch 2 lets you play on its built-in screen or on a TV.

  • Nintendo specifies a 7.9-inch LCD screen with HDR10 support.
  • Some older Switch games aren’t supported, or aren’t fully supported, on Switch 2; check the game you want to play.

Valve

Steam Deck OLED is a portable option for players with games in their Steam library.

  • Valve describes the screen as HDR OLED.
  • Check compatibility for each game; owning a Steam game doesn’t automatically mean it’s playable on Steam Deck.

Joybuy games consoles

These games consoles are designed for handheld play and, with suitable models, let you switch between the built-in screen and a TV.

Lenovo Legion Go 8ASP2 handheld games console

Lenovo Legion Go 8ASP2

A handheld option if you want to play without a TV.

The product is described as having an 8.8-inch OLED touchscreen with HDR support.

View at Joybuy
Asus ROG Xbox Ally handheld games console, white

Asus ROG Xbox Ally, 16 GB RAM, 512 GB SSD, white

A handheld games console for playing without a TV.

The product is described as having a 7-inch FHD touchscreen with a 120 Hz refresh rate. The charger must be purchased separately.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch OLED Neon-Red/Blue

Nintendo Switch OLED Neon-Red/Blue

An option if you want to play on the built-in screen; check that the mystery game you want is available for this model.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch 2 console, EU

Nintendo Switch 2, EU console

A good choice if you want to switch between playing on the built-in screen and on a TV.

Some older Switch games aren’t compatible, or aren’t fully compatible; check the game you want in advance.

View at Joybuy
MSI Claw A8 BZ2EM-047NL handheld games console, white

MSI Claw A8 BZ2EM-047NL, 8 inch, 1 TB, white

A portable option if you want to play without a TV.

According to the product name, it has an 8-inch touchscreen and 1 TB of storage. The charger must be purchased separately.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Should you turn off all the lights for mystery games with dark scenes?

No. Sony advises PlayStation users to play in a well-lit room and sit a safe distance from the TV. You don’t need a dark room to play the game.

Will every Nintendo Switch mystery game work on Switch 2?

No, you can’t assume that. Nintendo says some Switch games aren’t compatible, or aren’t fully compatible, with Switch 2, so check the information for the specific game.

Do you automatically need a game subscription as well as a games console?

No. Buying a game and taking out a subscription are separate choices. If you want to play a particular game through a subscription service, check the game’s page and the service’s current terms.

What can you do if your console bought online isn’t working properly or you change your mind?

For normal use, ACM ConsuWijzer says you’re entitled to a product that meets what you could reasonably expect; the seller must resolve any fault covered by the legal guarantee. For an online purchase, you generally have a 14-day cooling-off period after delivery, subject to legal exceptions.

What should you consider if a child will be playing the mystery game?

Check the PEGI rating for the specific game and the applicable sales rules. According to Kijkwijzer, shops and libraries aren’t allowed to provide a game to anyone younger than the PEGI age rating for that game.