Who are these games consoles for?

Players with a particular detective game in mind

You want to check first that your chosen title and edition work on the console. Nintendo, the PlayStation Store and Xbox list mystery games for different systems; compatibility can vary by game and edition.

Players who want to use their current headphones

You want to know whether your headphones support audio and, if needed, chat. Nintendo, Sony and Xbox explain the different options for Bluetooth audio and wired connections.

Mystery game fans who also want to play on the go

You want to investigate clues without always needing a television. Switch 2 supports handheld gaming; Steam Deck lets you play games from your Steam library on the go, with a compatibility rating for each game according to Valve.

What should you look for when choosing?

PlayStation 5 Digital Edition

Right for: anyone who mainly plays on a television and wants to play, for example, The Rise of the Golden Idol for PS5, as listed in the PlayStation Store.

Worth noting: the 825 GB digital edition reviewed here has no disc drive. Sony also says that Bluetooth audio devices that are not compatible cannot be used with PS5.

Nintendo Switch 2

Right for: anyone who wants to play mystery games both handheld and on a television. Nintendo lists The Case of the Golden Idol: Complete Edition for Switch.

Worth noting: some Switch games are not fully compatible, or are not compatible at all, with Switch 2. Bluetooth audio may have a delay, and Bluetooth microphones are not supported, according to Nintendo.

Xbox Series S

Right for: anyone who plays on a television, buys digital games and wants to play The Case of the Golden Idol on Xbox Series X|S, as listed in the Xbox Store.

Worth noting: Microsoft lists the Series S reviewed here as having 512 GB of storage and no disc drive. Xbox Support explains how to connect a wired headset through the controller.

Steam Deck OLED

Right for: anyone who wants to play their Steam library on the go. Valve gives each game a compatibility rating; Steam marks Return of the Obra Dinn as Verified for Steam Deck.

Worth noting: Steam Deck is a handheld gaming PC with console-style controls, not a PlayStation, Xbox or Nintendo console. Check the rating for every game you want to play.

When choosing a console for mystery games and headphones, the key things to consider are which game you want to play, how your headset connects and whether you want to play without a television.

What to consider What should you look for? Who is this important for?
Game availability Search for the exact title and edition in the relevant store; Nintendo warns that some Switch games are not fully compatible with Switch 2. I want to make sure my chosen detective game works on the system; around 33% of consumers put game availability first.
How your headphones connect Check whether you need Bluetooth or a wired connection, and whether the microphone and chat work. Nintendo says Bluetooth microphones do not work with Switch 2; Sony warns that incompatible Bluetooth audio devices do not work with PS5. I want to keep using my current headphones and know whether chat works too; around 27% of consumers make headset compatibility their top priority.
Playing without a television Decide whether you want to play in handheld mode, then check that your chosen games are compatible; Valve gives each Steam game a rating. If I also want to play on the go, a built-in screen is important; around 20% of consumers prioritise playing without a television.
Physical games and digital-only models Check whether you own any games on disc. The PS5 Digital Edition and Xbox Series S models reviewed here have no disc drive. I want to keep using my disc collection; around 20% of consumers focus on the choice between physical and digital games.

Common buying pitfalls

  • Choosing a console before checking which games you want

    Stores list the systems each game is available for. Some Switch games may also have compatibility exceptions on Switch 2.

    Make a short list of the titles you want to play, then check the platform, edition and any compatibility information for each one.

    If a title does not work on your chosen system, you may need a different edition of the game or another system to play it.

  • Confusing Bluetooth audio with full headset support

    Bluetooth audio, microphone support and chat are not the same thing. Nintendo warns that audio may be delayed on Switch 2 and says Bluetooth microphones are not supported. Sony says incompatible Bluetooth audio devices do not work with PS5.

    Check audio and chat separately for the combination of headphones, console and controller you plan to use.

    You may need a suitable headset or a wired connection through a compatible controller to use a different connection method.

  • Choosing a digital-only console when you own games on disc

    The PS5 Digital Edition reviewed here has no disc drive, and the Xbox Series S is digital-only. This means you cannot use games on disc with these models.

    Check which titles you already own on disc before choosing a digital-only model.

Relevant brands to consider

PlayStation

PS5 home consoles for anyone who wants to play digital games on a television.

  • The PlayStation Store lists The Rise of the Golden Idol for PS5.
  • The 825 GB PS5 Digital Edition reviewed here has no disc drive. Sony says incompatible Bluetooth audio devices do not work with PS5; the PULSE 3D is designed for PS5 according to Sony, but this does not prove universal Bluetooth compatibility.

Nintendo

Switch 2 for handheld or television gaming, and a good choice for anyone who wants to check compatibility with existing Switch games.

  • Nintendo lists The Case of the Golden Idol: Complete Edition for Switch and provides information about Bluetooth audio on Switch 2.
  • Nintendo warns that some Switch games are not fully compatible, or are not compatible at all, with Switch 2. Bluetooth audio may have a delay, and Bluetooth microphones are not supported.

Xbox

Digital home consoles for mystery games available in the Xbox Store.

  • The Xbox Store lists The Case of the Golden Idol for Xbox Series X|S; Xbox Support explains how to connect a wired headset through the controller.
  • Microsoft lists the Xbox Series S reviewed here as having 512 GB of storage and no disc drive.

Valve

Steam Deck OLED is a handheld gaming PC with console-style controls for anyone who wants to play games from their Steam library.

  • Valve gives each game a compatibility rating; Steam marks Return of the Obra Dinn as Verified for Steam Deck.
  • The rating applies to each individual title and does not automatically mean that other mystery games will work on Steam Deck.

Joybuy products for mystery games

The Joybuy selection below includes Nintendo Switch models and bundles for mystery games on Switch, with options for handheld and television gaming. Check that each game is compatible with the system you choose.

Nintendo Switch 2 console with replaceable battery, 2026

Nintendo Switch 2, replaceable battery (2026)

An option for anyone who wants to play mystery games in handheld mode too; check compatibility with Switch 2 for each Switch game.

The product name specifies a replaceable battery and the 2026 model.

Nintendo warns that some Switch games are not fully compatible, or are not compatible at all, with Switch 2. Bluetooth audio may have a delay, and Bluetooth microphones are not supported.

View at Joybuy
32 GB Nintendo Switch bundle with Mario Kart 8 Deluxe game card

32 GB Nintendo Switch bundle with Mario Kart 8 Deluxe game card

An option for anyone looking for a Switch system for mystery games and considering both handheld and television gaming.

The product name specifies 32 GB and a physical Mario Kart 8 Deluxe game card. The product description mentions TV, tabletop and handheld play.

Nintendo lists The Case of the Golden Idol: Complete Edition for Switch; check that the edition you want is compatible with your system.

View at Joybuy
Turquoise 32 GB Nintendo Switch Lite bundle with Tomodachi Life download and Nintendo Switch Online trial

32 GB Nintendo Switch Lite, turquoise, with Tomodachi Life download and 30-day Nintendo Switch Online trial

Right for anyone who wants to play mystery games in handheld mode only and does not need TV output.

The product name specifies 32 GB, the turquoise colour, a Tomodachi Life download and a 30-day Nintendo Switch Online trial.

According to the product information, this model is designed for handheld play only and does not support TV output. Nintendo lists The Case of the Golden Idol: Complete Edition for Switch; check that your chosen game is compatible.

View at Joybuy
256 GB Nintendo Switch 2 bundle with Mario Kart World download and three months of Nintendo Switch Online

256 GB Nintendo Switch 2 bundle with Mario Kart World download and 3 months of Nintendo Switch Online

An option for anyone who wants to use Switch 2 both handheld and on a television; the bundle description mentions an included dock.

The product name specifies 256 GB, a Mario Kart World download and 3 months of Nintendo Switch Online.

Nintendo warns that some Switch games are not fully compatible, or are not compatible at all, with Switch 2. Bluetooth audio may have a delay, and Bluetooth microphones are not supported.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch 2 console, EU model

Nintendo Switch 2 (EU)

Right for anyone who wants to play mystery games both handheld and on a connected television.

The product description mentions handheld, tabletop and TV play using the dock.

Nintendo warns that some Switch games are not fully compatible, or are not compatible at all, with Switch 2. Bluetooth audio may have a delay, and Bluetooth microphones are not supported.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Will any Bluetooth headphones connect directly to these games consoles?

No, do not assume they will. Nintendo provides information about Bluetooth audio on Switch 2, but warns of possible delays and says Bluetooth microphones do not work. Sony says incompatible Bluetooth audio devices cannot be used with PS5, so check the exact headphones and connection method.

How do I connect a wired headset when playing on a television?

Xbox Support explains how to connect a wired headset through the Xbox controller’s 3.5 mm socket. Nintendo lists a 3.5 mm socket on the separate Switch 2 Pro Controller; check whether you need that controller and whether the connection is suitable for your headset.

Can I play my existing Switch games on Switch 2?

Switch 2 can play Switch games, but Nintendo warns that some titles are not fully compatible, or are not compatible at all. Check each game you want to play before relying on your existing library.

Do I need a subscription to play mystery games?

Not for every game available to buy individually. The Xbox Store lists The Case of the Golden Idol as a game for Xbox Series X|S, while Microsoft describes Game Pass Ultimate as a separate membership. Check the current terms for each game and online feature.

What rights do I have when I buy a games console online in the Netherlands?

When you buy at a distance from a business, you are generally entitled to a 14-day cooling-off period, according to the Dutch government; the exact terms matter. Separate rights apply to faulty products, such as repair or replacement. Check the terms that apply to your specific purchase.