A compact gamepad is a good choice if you play using a D-pad and thumb buttons and have limited storage space. An arcade stick, on the other hand, gives you a physical joystick and separate action buttons. Neither type of controller is automatically quiet because of its size or wireless connection, so weigh up the controls you want against noise and available table space. Before buying, check the exact model, connection and correct CE marking.
Who is this choice for?
Sharing a bedroom and keen to minimise disruption
You play while someone else is using the room, so you want to consider button noise, where you place the controller and how it might make contact with furniture. A description of the controls alone won’t tell you how loud they are.
Retro gamer with limited space
You want to put your controller away easily after playing, so you’re weighing up a handheld controller against a small wired arcade stick. According to 8BitDo, the M30 Bluetooth measures 147 × 74 × 31 mm.
Arcade gamer with a specific system
You want a joystick or a classic button layout, but need to check which model, receiver and input mode will work with your PC or console. Manufacturers list compatibility for each product and model.
What should you consider when choosing?
Compact six-button gamepad
Best for: anyone who mainly plays with a D-pad and thumb buttons and wants to put their controller away after use.
Trade-off: you won’t get the physical joystick of an arcade stick. According to 8BitDo, the M30 Bluetooth and models with a 2.4GHz receiver use different connections and have different compatibility.
Small wired arcade stick
Best for: anyone who wants a joystick and separate action buttons but has limited table or storage space. HORI lists PC compatibility for the Fighting Stick Mini for Nintendo Switch.
Trade-off: you’ll need to make room for the cable where you play. The specified microswitch joystick doesn’t tell you how loud the controls are.
Larger arcade stick with connection options
Best for: anyone who wants an arcade stick and values multiple connection options or customisable parts. 8BitDo lists Bluetooth, 2.4GHz and USB for the Arcade Stick; MAYFLASH lists replaceable parts for the F300.
Trade-off: the casing takes up more table space. MAYFLASH requires an additional wired controller to be connected when using the F300 with PS4 and Xbox One; check the requirements for your system.
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this most important for? |
| Disruption to your roommate |
If possible, assess the button noise in your own setup and watch out for contact with furniture. |
If I play while someone else is using the bedroom, I want to minimise disruption without relying on claims that a controller is quiet. Around 31% of consumers in this situation put this first. |
| Compatibility |
Compare the exact model, your PC or console, the connection and any firmware or additional controller requirements. |
If I want to be sure the controller works with my own device, I check the model and connection requirements first. Around 25% of consumers make compatibility their top priority. |
| Controls for your game |
Check how many directions and action buttons you need, and whether the button layout suits your game. |
If I’m mainly looking for classic arcade controls, I weigh up a joystick and separate buttons against a gamepad. Around 25% of consumers put these controls first. |
| Table and storage space |
Measure the available space and think about where the controller, cable or receiver will go after you’ve finished playing. |
If I have limited space to play or store my controller, I want to know whether it will fit where I need it. Around 19% of consumers consider saving space their top priority. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Assuming all wireless connections are interchangeable
8BitDo distinguishes the M30 Bluetooth from M30 models with a 2.4GHz receiver. The connections and supported devices aren’t necessarily the same.
Check the full model name and which receiver is actually included with that model.
-
Assuming an arcade stick works straight away with every console
MAYFLASH specifies that an additional wired controller must be connected when using the F300 with PS4 and Xbox One. The manufacturer also provides firmware-dependent information for certain mini consoles.
Before ordering, check the connection process for your console and firmware. You may also need an extra controller with those consoles.
-
Assuming ‘compact’ or ‘wireless’ means ‘quiet’
Size and connection type don’t tell you how loud the buttons, joystick or contact with furniture will be. In a 2025 review, RetroReady noted loud shoulder buttons on one Retro-Bit model; this isn’t a standardised noise comparison.
Assess the noise from the exact controller in your own setup instead of assuming it will be quiet based on its specifications.
Relevant brands to consider
8BitDo
According to 8BitDo’s product information, options for this type of use include the M30 Bluetooth gamepad and a separate Arcade Stick for Switch and Windows.
- 8BitDo lists three connection options for the Arcade Stick: Bluetooth, 2.4GHz and USB.
- Compatibility for the Arcade Stick doesn’t automatically apply to the M30; check the details for each model.
HORI
According to HORI, the Fighting Stick Mini for Nintendo Switch is a wired tabletop model with an arcade joystick; the manufacturer also lists PC compatibility.
- HORI specifies eight action buttons and a microswitch joystick.
- The cable and joystick are practical considerations in a shared room; the specifications don’t provide a measured noise level.
MAYFLASH
According to MAYFLASH, the wired F300 is designed for arcade stick controls, with support for multiple systems and customisable parts.
- MAYFLASH lists XInput and DInput for PC, and compatibility with Sanwa parts.
- MAYFLASH specifies that an additional wired console controller must be connected when using the F300 with PS4 and Xbox One; also check the requirements for your system.
Retro-Bit
Retro-Bit offers, among other products, a wireless 2.4GHz Arcade Pad styled after the SEGA Mega Drive.
- Retro-Bit lists a classic six-button layout and included receivers for original connections and USB.
- In 2025, RetroReady described loud shoulder buttons on one model; this observation doesn’t necessarily apply to other models and isn’t a noise measurement.
Products on Joybuy
Related products will be available soon.
Frequently asked questions
Will every retro controller work straight away with my PC or console?
No, it depends on the exact model and connection. 8BitDo distinguishes the M30 Bluetooth from models with a 2.4GHz receiver. MAYFLASH also specifies that a wired console controller must be connected when using the F300 with PS4 and Xbox One.
How do I set up a MAYFLASH F300 for PC or Switch?
MAYFLASH lists XInput and DInput for PC and specifies particular switch positions for PC-XInput and Nintendo Switch. Before connecting the stick, check the instructions for your exact device and firmware combination.
What product regulations apply to an electronic controller sold in the Netherlands?
According to the Dutch Authority for Digital Infrastructure, electronic equipment must have the correct CE marking; applicable radio equipment rules also apply to wireless equipment. A brand name or compatibility claim alone doesn’t confirm that a particular model meets these requirements.
What if a controller I bought online doesn’t suit my setup or develops a fault?
For a distance purchase by a consumer, you’ll often have a 14-day cooling-off period, according to the Dutch government; check whether it applies to your purchase. You’re also entitled to a product that works as it should. If there’s a fault, the retailer is your point of contact and can’t simply send you to the manufacturer.