Choose an HDD if you mainly want to keep a growing video archive locally, and an SSD if you regularly move recordings between devices or edit them on the go. First, check how your device handles storage: PlayStation explains how to copy captures from the PS5 Media Gallery to USB, while Xbox requires USB 3.0 and NTFS for direct external recording. Keep irreplaceable recordings in a second local location too.
Who is this choice relevant to?
Clip collector
You want to keep lots of game videos and screenshots offline, so capacity is your main concern. The Consumers’ Association and product specifications from Western Digital and Seagate provide useful context when choosing an external drive and storage capacity.
Console gamer
You want to store PS5 or Xbox recordings without the cloud, and need to follow the correct recording or copying process. PlayStation and Xbox Support explain the relevant features and storage requirements.
Clip editor
You regularly transfer recordings to a PC, so you need to consider transfer speeds, ports and cables. Kingston and Crucial provide product specifications where the host device and connection matter.
What should you look for when buying?
First decide whether you’ll copy captures or record directly to the drive. Then choose enough storage for an archive, or an SSD if you often move files.
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Room for a growing archive |
Compare the capacity in TB with the size of your clips, and leave room for new recordings. |
If I mainly want to keep lots of clips offline, I prioritise archive space over transfer speed. Around 33% of consumers put sufficient archive space at the top of their purchase priorities. |
| Works with your console or PC |
Decide whether you’ll record directly on Xbox, copy PS5 recordings from the Media Gallery or move PC files. Then check the port, cable and file format. |
If I want the drive to suit the way I use my console or PC, I check the requirements before choosing. Around 27% of consumers prioritise device compatibility. |
| Regularly transferring large clips |
Compare the drive’s USB connection with the port and cable on the receiving PC; maximum speeds depend on the host device. |
When I often move recordings to an editing PC, I want the ports and cable to work with both devices. Around 20% of consumers give frequent transfers top priority. |
| A second local copy |
Plan a separate storage location and check that you can open important files from that copy. |
If I can’t recreate my clips and don’t want to use the cloud, I keep a separate local copy too. Around 20% of consumers prioritise this kind of backup. |
Common pitfalls
-
Confusing a drive for console games with storage for captures
Recording and game storage features may require different formats and processes. Xbox Support says that a drive formatted for Xbox games won’t work as an external storage location for captures.
Before formatting, decide whether you want to store games, record clips directly or copy existing clips. Move any files you want to keep somewhere else first.
Reformatting can take time, and you’ll need to move your files somewhere safe beforehand.
-
Assuming an SSD’s maximum speed is its guaranteed transfer speed
The maximum speed quoted isn’t necessarily the speed you’ll get on your computer; the host device, port and cable all make a difference.
Check the USB connection on both the drive and the PC, and see which cables are included with the exact model.
You may need a suitable cable or adapter if the connections don’t match.
-
Calling your only offline copy a backup
If the only copy of a clip is on one drive, that file depends on that single storage location.
Keep important recordings in a separate local location too, and regularly check that you can open the copy.
Relevant brands to consider
Western Digital
The WD Elements Portable range is an option for a portable HDD archive.
- Western Digital lists models from 1 to 6 TB. For the USB-A range mentioned, the manufacturer specifies USB 3.2 Gen 1.
- You may need to reformat the drive for a different operating system. Check the exact model and the storage process you need.
Seagate
The Portable HDD range could suit storing videos on a computer.
- Seagate lists models with capacities of 1, 2, 4 and 5 TB.
- The manufacturer describes a USB-A cable as included with the model shown; check the box contents for the capacity you choose.
Kingston
The XS1000 range is an external SSD for moving recordings between devices.
- Kingston lists 1 and 2 TB models, with maximum speeds of 1,050 MB/s read and 1,000 MB/s write.
- These are manufacturer figures and depend on the host device. Check that the cable and any adapter are suitable for the model you choose.
Crucial
The X9 2TB is a compact USB-C SSD for taking files with you or transferring them.
- Crucial lists a maximum read speed of 1,050 MB/s and says the X9 2TB comes formatted as exFAT.
- Xbox Support says NTFS is required for direct external recording on Xbox. Compatibility also depends on the host device and formatting.
Samsung
The T7 Shield is a portable SSD range positioned around a dust- and water-resistant casing.
- For the US T7 Shield 2TB model, Samsung lists IP65 and maximum read and write speeds of 1,050 and 1,000 MB/s.
- Check the Dutch model code separately; the US model listed here doesn’t confirm that an identical Dutch version is available.
Joybuy products for local storage
This selection from Joybuy includes portable SSDs for moving recordings and portable HDDs for local clip archives. Check that the connection and file format are suitable for your device.
Image unavailable
SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1TB 2000 MB/s
A portable SSD for anyone who regularly moves game clips between devices.
Product specifications: 1 TB and 2000 MB/s.
View at Joybuy
Image unavailable
My Passport 4TB Black Portable Hard Drive
A portable HDD for anyone who wants to keep a local archive of clips.
Capacity: 4 TB.
View at Joybuy
Image unavailable
Western Digital My Passport USB-C 4TB Black
A portable HDD for anyone who wants to store clips locally and move files between devices.
Capacity: 4 TB; USB-C.
View at Joybuy
Image unavailable
WD Elements Portable 2TB USB-C Graphite Black
A portable HDD for anyone who wants to keep an offline archive of clips.
Capacity: 2 TB; USB-C.
View at Joybuy
Image unavailable
WD Elements Portable 4TB USB-C Graphite Black
A portable HDD for anyone looking for more space for a local recording archive.
Capacity: 4 TB; USB-C.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Can I save PS5 game recordings to an external drive without using the cloud?
Yes. PlayStation explains that you can copy a recording to a connected USB storage device from the Media Gallery. This is different from setting up a USB drive as extended game storage.
What format do I need to record Xbox clips directly to an external drive?
According to Xbox Support, connect a USB 3.0 device formatted as NTFS and select it as the recording location. A drive formatted for Xbox games can’t also be used for captures. Move any files you want to keep before reformatting, as formatting erases the contents.
How many recordings will fit on my external drive?
It depends on the available space and the size of your clips. Divide the space actually available by the average file size of your recordings to get a personal estimate.
Is one external drive enough as a backup if I don’t use the cloud?
Not if that drive contains your only copy. Keep important clips in a separate local storage location too, and regularly check that you can open the copy.
Who should I contact in the Netherlands if a drive fails too soon?
Report the problem to the retailer. ACM ConsuWijzer explains that if a product doesn’t meet reasonable expectations under normal use, you’re entitled to a free solution under the statutory guarantee. Whether a particular fault is covered depends on the circumstances.