Who is this guide for?

Players who want to check compatibility

You’re choosing a controller for a console or PC you already own, and want to know before buying whether both the controller and puzzle game support the controls you need. The Puzzle Cottage game page lists support for Xbox and PlayStation controllers.

Puzzle players in a bright room

You want to enjoy your game, but screen glare and your choice of controller need to be considered separately. A controller with lighting won’t change the screen surface.

Players who like to relax on the sofa

You’re comparing a familiar button layout and freedom of movement with practical considerations such as batteries, charging or whether a cable will reach your gaming spot.

What should you look for in a game controller?

First, check whether your device and game support the controller. Consider screen glare separately, so you don’t choose a controller feature expecting it to improve the picture.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Compatibility Check the exact controller version for your console or PC, as well as whether the specific game supports controllers. If I want to play on a device I already own, I want to know in advance whether the game supports the controller. Around 36% of consumers prioritise compatibility with their device and game.
Screen visibility Consider your screen’s position and settings separately; don’t treat controller lighting as a solution to glare. If glare makes puzzle details hard to see, I want to address the problem at the screen. Around 21% of consumers prioritise visibility in a bright room.
Comfort and controls Compare the button layout and check whether your game supports features such as extra buttons or special triggers. If I’m taking my time over a puzzle, I want a layout that feels comfortable, without extra features I won’t use. Around 29% of consumers prioritise comfort and controls.
Cable and power Check how the version is powered and whether its cable is long enough for your gaming spot. If I want to sit where I like, I weigh up wireless play against using batteries or charging. With a wired controller, I want to know whether the cable will reach my seat. Around 14% of consumers prioritise connectivity and power.

Common purchasing mistakes

  • Assuming Switch and Switch 2 Pro Controllers are interchangeable

    Nintendo states that the Switch 2 Pro Controller doesn’t work with the original Switch. The original Switch Pro Controller can be used with Switch 2, but its HOME button can’t wake the console from sleep mode.

    Check which Switch generation you own and read the full controller name before choosing.

  • Confusing the two 8BitDo Ultimate 2C versions

    8BitDo lists different platforms for the Ultimate 2C Bluetooth and Ultimate 2C Wireless. For using the Bluetooth version with Switch 2, the manufacturer specifies a firmware update.

    Check the full model name and whether your device requires a firmware update.

  • Choosing controller lighting to fix screen glare

    Lighting zones are on the controller, while glare occurs on the screen. So lighting on the controller doesn’t mean that puzzle details will be easier to see on screen.

    Address visibility separately, and choose your controller based on compatibility and controls.

  • Assuming a commercial guarantee covers all your legal rights

    ACM ConsuWijzer distinguishes between a guarantee offered by the seller and your legal right to receive a product that meets what you could reasonably expect from it.

    Consider any additional guarantee as extra cover, and keep your purchase details in case you need to make a complaint to the seller.

Brands to consider

Xbox

An Xbox controller is worth considering for compatible Xbox consoles and Windows PCs.

  • Xbox lists features including a hybrid D-pad, button mapping and Bluetooth for its standard wireless controller.
  • The standard version uses AA batteries. If you’re playing on PC, also check whether your specific game supports the controller.

PlayStation

DualSense is primarily a PS5 controller, though Sony also lists use with PCs and other compatible devices.

  • Sony lists haptic feedback and adaptive triggers.
  • Whether these features work depends on the game and device; don’t assume they’ll be supported in the same way everywhere.

Nintendo

With Pro Controllers, the Switch generation matters, particularly if you want to reuse a controller you already own.

  • Nintendo states that the original Switch Pro Controller can be used wirelessly with Switch 2.
  • The Switch 2 Pro Controller doesn’t work with the original Switch. The original controller can’t wake Switch 2 from sleep mode using the HOME button.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2C name covers versions for different devices, so check the full model name.

  • 8BitDo lists Switch support for the Ultimate 2C Bluetooth, and Windows and Android support for the Ultimate 2C Wireless.
  • For using the Bluetooth version with Switch 2, 8BitDo specifies a firmware update.

PowerA

The Enhanced Wired Controller for Xbox Series X|S is a wired option for the Xbox and Windows devices listed by PowerA.

  • PowerA lists two mappable extra buttons and a detachable 3 m USB cable for this model.
  • The cable limits where you can play, so check that it’s long enough to reach your device.

Joybuy products for different devices

This selection includes controllers for PS4, PS5, PC, Switch and Xbox. Check which controls are supported for each game and controller version.

Wireless Dualshock controller for PS4 and PC

Wireless Dualshock controller for PS4 and PC

An option if you play on PS4 or PC; also check whether your puzzle game supports controller controls.

The product title lists PS4 and PC as compatible systems.

View on Joybuy
PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller – Grand Theft Auto VI White Limited Edition

PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller – Grand Theft Auto VI White Limited Edition

Worth considering if you play on PS5. For PC, Mac or a mobile device, check whether your game supports the controller controls you want.

The product title lists PS5, PC, Mac and mobile.

View on Joybuy
VIELLAN wireless Bluetooth controller for PS4

VIELLAN wireless Bluetooth controller for PS4

An option to compare if you’re looking for a wireless controller for PS4; check whether your game supports it.

The product title lists PS4 and Bluetooth.

View on Joybuy
Game controller with dual vibration and gyroscope for Switch and PC

Game controller with dual vibration and gyroscope for Switch and PC

An option if you play on Switch or PC; check support for your specific game and device.

The product title lists Switch and PC.

View on Joybuy
Xbox Wireless Controller Robot White

Xbox Wireless Controller Robot White

Worth considering for a compatible Xbox or Windows PC. If you’re playing on PC, also check whether your puzzle game supports controller controls.

The product title lists a wireless Xbox controller.

View on Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Will a controller with lighting help with glare in a bright room?

No, lighting on a controller won’t change the screen. Consider your screen’s position and picture settings separately; lighting on a controller doesn’t make puzzle details easier to see.

Will any controller automatically work with my PC puzzle game?

No. Check that your exact controller is supported on PC, and that the specific game supports it too. A game page may tell you which controller types are supported.

Can I use my original Switch Pro Controller with Switch 2?

Yes. Nintendo states that the original Switch Pro Controller works wirelessly with Switch 2, but its HOME button can’t wake the console from sleep mode. Nintendo says the Switch 2 Pro Controller doesn’t work with the original Switch.

What should I check if my wireless controller won’t pair?

Follow the pairing steps for your exact model and device. For a 2.4 GHz connection to Windows, 8BitDo says to use the adapter and set the mode switch to the correct position for the Ultimate 2C Wireless.

What are my rights when I buy a controller online in the Netherlands?

According to ACM ConsuWijzer, online purchases generally come with a cooling-off period of up to and including 14 days after delivery, subject to legal exceptions. You’re also entitled to a product that, under normal use, meets what you could reasonably expect from it; an additional guarantee offered by the seller doesn’t replace this legal right.