Who is this choice relevant to?

Console puzzle players

Want to know whether a controller is compatible with their Xbox, PlayStation or Nintendo Switch generation before weighing up any extra features.

PC players on the sofa

Need a suitable connection and familiar controls. Also check whether the specific game supports controller input; Steamworks offers settings for supported input devices.

Players who want to see the controls

Want to find the buttons more easily in a dark room or adjust the lighting. Controller lighting and illuminated button labels aren’t the same thing.

What should you look for?

First, check compatibility with your system and game. Then choose based on controls, visibility, comfort and connection.

Consideration What should you check? Who is this important for?
Compatibility Check your console generation or PC version, as well as whether the game supports the controller. I want the controller to work with my system and my puzzle game to support its input, so the basic controls work as expected. Around 29% of consumers give system and game compatibility top priority.
Controls Compare the button layout and check whether button mapping is available on the exact model. For relaxed puzzle games, I want familiar buttons or a layout I can customise, without unnecessarily complicated settings. Around 23% of consumers put familiar, customisable controls first.
Visibility Check whether the button labels themselves light up and whether the brightness can be adjusted. In a dark room, I want to find the buttons without bright lighting effects distracting me from the story. Around 18% of consumers give adjustable lighting and visible controls top priority.
Comfort Compare the shape, grip and reach of the buttons. When I’m playing for longer stretches at a relaxed pace, I want the controller to feel comfortable in my hands and the controls to be easy to reach. Around 18% of consumers prioritise comfort and accessibility.
Power and connection Check whether the controller is wireless or wired, and which cable or adapter you’ll need. I want to know whether I can sit freely without a cable or play without interruption. Around 12% of consumers give their preferred connection and power method top priority.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming Switch Pro controllers are interchangeable

    Nintendo confirms that the original Switch Pro Controller can be paired wirelessly with Switch 2. According to Nintendo, the Switch 2 Pro Controller doesn’t work with the original Switch.

    Check the full product name and your console generation.

  • Confusing RGB lighting with illuminated button labels

    PowerA describes the Lumectra controller reviewed here as having lighting zones, but this doesn’t confirm that every button label lights up.

    Check that the specific buttons you want to see in the dark are illuminated.

  • Assuming a Bluetooth connection means full PC support

    Connecting a DualSense to a PC doesn’t automatically give you access to all its features. Sony says that haptic feedback requires game support and a USB connection.

    Check support for the specific game, the connection and the features you want to use.

  • Looking at the controller alone

    Wired and wireless models need different connections and power options. An extended warranty is separate from your statutory rights.

    Check which cable, adapter or charging solution you need, and see what’s included with the model. If you need an adapter or charging solution, you may need to buy an extra accessory.

Relevant brands to consider

Xbox

A standard wireless Xbox controller is an option for Xbox consoles and Windows PCs.

  • Microsoft lists Bluetooth, button mapping and a hybrid D-pad.
  • These specifications don’t confirm that the buttons are illuminated or that the controller works with every PC game.

PlayStation

DualSense is the option reviewed here for PS5, and can also be used with compatible games on supported PCs.

  • Sony describes DualSense as a controller for PS5.
  • On PC, Sony says haptic feedback requires game support and a USB connection.

Nintendo

The Switch Pro Controller and Switch 2 Pro Controller are made for different console generations.

  • Nintendo confirms that the original Switch Pro Controller can be paired wirelessly with Switch 2.
  • According to Nintendo, the Switch 2 Pro Controller doesn’t work with the original Switch. Nintendo estimates that the original Switch Pro Controller’s battery lasts around 40 hours, though this can vary depending on use.

PowerA

The Advantage Wired with Lumectra reviewed here is a wired option for Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Windows 10/11.

  • For this model, PowerA lists four RGB zones, three lighting modes and a USB-C cable.
  • The lighting zones don’t prove that the labels on individual buttons light up.

8BitDo

According to 8BitDo, the Ultimate 2C Wireless is designed for Windows PCs and Android, with different connections for each platform.

  • 8BitDo lists customisable buttons and Hall Effect sticks.
  • The stated compatibility doesn’t confirm support for Xbox, PlayStation or Nintendo consoles.

Joybuy products

This selection includes controllers for Nintendo Switch systems, Xbox and Windows PC, PS5 and multiple platforms. Check support for each game, and make sure the lighting suits what you want to see in the dark.

Turtle Beach Afterglow Wave Wireless Controller in a transparent finish

Turtle Beach Afterglow Wave Wireless Controller — Transparent

An option for Nintendo Switch players looking for adjustable RGB lighting and customisable buttons.

The product information lists support for Switch 2, Switch, Switch Lite and Switch OLED, four RGB modes with adjustable brightness and colour, and two programmable rear buttons.

View at Joybuy
Xbox Wireless Controller Ice Breaker Special Edition

Xbox Wireless Controller — Ice Breaker Special Edition

An option if you’re looking for an Xbox controller for an Xbox console or Windows PC.

The product information lists Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Windows 10/11, Bluetooth and Xbox Wireless. You can map buttons using the Xbox Accessories app.

View at Joybuy
PS5 DualSense Wireless Controller V3 in Cosmic Red

PS5 DualSense Wireless Controller V3 — Cosmic Red

A controller option for a PS5 setup.

The product information lists haptic feedback and adaptive triggers. For haptic feedback on PC, Sony requires game support and a USB connection.

View at Joybuy
GameSir Cyclone 2 multi-platform controller, black bundle

GameSir Cyclone 2 — Black Bundle Edition

A multi-platform option if you want RGB lighting and play on PC, Switch, iOS or Android.

The product name lists TMR sticks, 2-in-1 triggers and a 1000 Hz polling rate. The product information also mentions an RGB light strip and an included charging dock.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch Pro Controller in black

Nintendo Switch Pro Controller — Black

An option for Nintendo Switch; Nintendo also confirms that this controller can be used wirelessly with Switch 2.

The product information lists wireless controls, motion controls and HD Rumble.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does a DualSense connected to a PC via Bluetooth support all its special features?

No, don’t assume that it does. Sony says features may vary by device, and that haptic feedback on PC requires game support and a USB connection.

Can I use a Switch Pro Controller with Switch 2?

Yes. Nintendo confirms that the original Switch Pro Controller can be paired wirelessly with Switch 2. The Switch 2 Pro Controller doesn’t work with the original Switch, according to Nintendo.

How can I check whether a PC puzzle game works with a controller?

Check the support and settings for the specific game. Steam offers configuration options for supported input devices, but this doesn’t prove that every game works fully or comfortably with a controller.

Does RGB lighting mean I can read the buttons in the dark?

Not necessarily. A controller’s lighting zones may light up without illuminating the labels on individual buttons. Check the specifications for the exact model to see whether the buttons you want to find are illuminated.