Who is this advice for?

Platformer player sharing a room

You play while someone else is resting in the same room. You want to keep game audio and vibration under control, without assuming that a headset will silence the buttons.

Player checking system compatibility first

You’re choosing between controllers for Switch, Switch 2, Xbox, PS5 or PC, and want to avoid buying a model that looks suitable but doesn’t work with your device or game.

Player who often makes precise jumps

You want to weigh up directional controls, grip and button layout against extra features your platform game may not use.

What should you look for when choosing?

First, check that the controller works with your system and game. Then consider noise in the room, controls and the practicalities of wired or wireless play separately.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Compatibility Check the exact system and model, any firmware requirements, connection type and game support. I want to avoid buying a controller that doesn’t work with my console or game. For around 33% of consumers, compatibility is the top priority.
Keeping things quiet for your room-mate Check where a headset will work, whether vibration can be adjusted and whether the button noise is acceptable in your room. I want to play while someone else is resting in the same room, so I consider game audio, vibration and button noise separately. For around 27% of consumers, keeping things quiet for their room-mate comes first.
Directional controls and comfort Compare the D-pad and grip with what feels comfortable to you. Also check whether button mapping is useful for your game. I often make jumps and change direction, so I want the buttons to be comfortable to reach. Around 20% of consumers prioritise directional controls and comfort.
Connection and power Check how far you’ll be from your screen, the cable and the power source for the exact model. I want to know whether a cable will be convenient or whether I’ll need to allow for charging or batteries. For around 20% of consumers, connection and power are the top priorities.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming every Pro Controller works with every Switch

    Nintendo says that the Switch 2 Pro Controller works only with Switch 2. It’s a different model from the Pro Controller for the original Switch.

    Before buying, check the full model name and the system you play on.

  • Expecting a headset to make your whole gaming session quiet

    A headset can keep game audio from disturbing others, but it won’t affect vibration or the noise made by physical buttons. Nintendo describes a setting to turn off controller vibration on the original Switch; this won’t silence the buttons.

    Check the audio connection and vibration settings for your setup, and bear in mind the noise made by the buttons themselves.

  • Confusing paid extra cover with your statutory guarantee rights

    Additional cover is different from your statutory rights if a product doesn’t do what you could reasonably expect. ACM ConsuWijzer explains the difference in its information about guarantees.

    Compare what extra cover offers before you pay for it.

Relevant brands to consider

Nintendo

Nintendo makes Pro Controllers for the original Switch and for Switch 2.

  • Nintendo lists a CTIA headset socket and mappable GL and GR buttons for the Switch 2 Pro Controller. The Pro Controller for the original Switch has a full-size directional pad.
  • Nintendo says the Switch 2 Pro Controller works only with Switch 2; the two models aren’t interchangeable.

Xbox

Xbox offers wireless controllers for supported Xbox consoles, Windows PCs and certain mobile devices.

  • Microsoft lists a hybrid D-pad, button mapping, Bluetooth and a socket for a compatible 3.5mm headset for the Xbox Wireless Controller.
  • These specifications don’t confirm that every PC game or audio setup supports all the features, so check support for your specific combination.

PlayStation

DualSense is designed for PS5 and works with compatible games on supported PCs and other devices.

  • Sony specifies USB and Bluetooth connections.
  • On PC, haptic feedback and the headset socket require a wired connection under the conditions specified by Sony. Available features also depend on the game.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2 Bluetooth is an adjustable option for the Switch and Windows setups listed by 8BitDo.

  • 8BitDo lists button mapping and adjustable vibration intensity.
  • According to 8BitDo, a firmware update is needed to use it with Switch 2. Adjustable vibration doesn’t mean the buttons are quiet.

GameSir

The G7 SE is a wired option for the Xbox and PC setups listed by GameSir.

  • GameSir lists Hall-effect sticks and a wired connection.
  • The cable limits where you can sit. The manufacturer’s claim about resistance to stick drift isn’t independent evidence of the product’s lifespan.

Joybuy products

These products are suited to selected Switch, Android and Xbox or Windows setups. Check whether each controller and game is right for your gaming setup.

SUBSONIC Wireless Controller SW2 & SW with LED, Pink

SUBSONIC Wireless Controller SW2 & SW with LED, Pink

The product information lists Switch and Switch 2 setups; check that your game and system support the controller.

Wireless Bluetooth connection; two programmable buttons and three adjustable vibration levels, according to the product information.

View at Joybuy
ASUS ROG Tessen Black, Grey USB 3.2 Gen 1 Gamepad for Android

ASUS ROG Tessen, Black, Grey, USB 3.2 Gen 1

The product information lists Android gaming; check that your device and game are compatible.

Wired USB-C connection and D-pad, according to the product information.

View at Joybuy
Hyperkin Duchess Wired Controller for Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Windows, Black

Hyperkin Duchess Wired Controller for Xbox Series X|S / Xbox One / Windows, Black

For a supported Xbox or Windows setup; check that it works with your game and audio settings.

Wired, with a detachable 3-metre USB-C cable and 3.5mm headset socket, according to the product information. Hall-effect sticks and impulse triggers are also listed.

The cable needs to run between the controller and the device.

View at Joybuy
Hyperkin Xenon Wired Controller for Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Windows, Red

Hyperkin Xenon Wired Controller for Xbox Series X|S / Xbox One / Windows, Red

For a supported Xbox or Windows setup; check game and audio support for your device.

Wired, with a detachable Type-C cable and 3.5mm headset socket, according to the product information. Impulse triggers and vibration feedback are also listed.

The controller needs to be connected to the device by cable.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch Pro Controller, Black

Nintendo Switch Pro Controller, Black

For the original Nintendo Switch. Nintendo says you can turn off controller vibration in the system settings. This setting applies to all synchronised controllers.

Wireless connection, HD Rumble and motion controls, according to the product information.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I use a Switch 2 Pro Controller with my original Switch?

No. Nintendo says the Switch 2 Pro Controller doesn’t work with the original Nintendo Switch; the Switch Pro Controller is a different model.

How do I turn off controller vibration on an original Switch?

According to Nintendo, go to System Settings from the HOME Menu, then select Controllers and Sensors to turn off Controller Vibration. Nintendo says this setting applies to all synchronised controllers.

Does the DualSense headset socket work on a PC over Bluetooth?

Sony says a wired connection to the PC is needed to use the headset socket. Also check that the game supports the audio features you want.

What are my rights when buying a controller online in the Netherlands?

According to ACM ConsuWijzer, online purchases generally come with a statutory 14-day cooling-off period after delivery, with some exceptions. Separately, if a product doesn’t perform as you could reasonably expect under normal use, you have statutory rights against the seller. These aren’t automatically limited to the length of the manufacturer’s guarantee.

Can I put a flat controller battery in the general waste?

No. The Dutch government says used batteries must be taken to a collection point and shouldn’t go in the bin.