Who is this choice relevant to?

Console players who prioritise compatibility

You mainly want a controller that works with your Xbox, PS5 or Switch 2, with the features you need available in your game.

Evening gamers who want control over the lighting

You play in a dark room and want to be able to adjust or switch off the lighting to suit your preferences.

Players who take on long quests

You want to stay comfortable during long sessions, so you compare power options, connectivity and how easy the controls are to reach.

What should you look for when choosing?

First, check that the controller and the game features you want work on your platform. Then compare lighting, controls and connectivity for the way you play.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Platform and game Check which systems are supported, the full model name and whether the game supports the features you want. If I want to be sure the controller works with my console or PC, I also check that my game supports the features I need. Compatibility is the main priority for around 31% of consumers in this gaming setup.
Lighting Check whether you can adjust the brightness or light zones, and whether you can switch all the lighting off. I want to decide for myself whether controller lighting is comfortable or distracting in a dark room. Around 25% of consumers prioritise adjustable lighting.
Controls for long sessions Compare the grip and button layout, and check which buttons you can remap on the version you’re considering. When I play for a long time, I want to reach the buttons without constantly adjusting how I hold the controller. Around 19% of consumers in this gaming setup prioritise comfort during extended play.
Connection and power Check the power source, whether a cable is included and whether its length suits where you sit. I want to play from my seat without a cable getting in the way, while also keeping the power needs of a wireless controller in mind. Around 13% of consumers prioritise the freedom of wireless play.
Stick technology Check the stick technology on the exact version you’re considering, along with any adjustment options. If I’m specifically looking for a certain type of stick or extra customisable controls, I want to find out what the particular model offers. Around 12% of consumers in this gaming setup have this as their main technical priority.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming RGB lighting makes the buttons easier to see

    Adjustable lighting doesn’t mean the button labels will be easier to read in the dark. Bright or poorly positioned lights can also be distracting.

    Check where the lights are on the exact version you’re considering, and whether you can adjust the brightness or switch them off.

  • Assuming all Ultimate 2 versions support the same systems

    8BitDo lists different compatibility for the Ultimate 2 Bluetooth and Ultimate 2 Wireless. According to 8BitDo, the Bluetooth version requires a firmware update for Switch 2.

    Before choosing, compare the full version name and any firmware requirements with your system.

  • Confusing a manufacturer’s warranty with your statutory rights

    A manufacturer’s or seller’s warranty is in addition to your rights to a product that is fit for purpose. The Government of the Netherlands states that there is no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands.

    Keep your proof of purchase and contact the seller if something goes wrong. When considering an extended warranty, check what additional cover it provides.

Brands to compare

Microsoft Xbox

Xbox wireless controllers are designed for supported Xbox consoles, Windows PCs and the mobile systems listed.

  • Microsoft lists a textured grip, Bluetooth and mappable buttons.
  • The controller uses AA batteries. Check whether a USB-C cable is included with the version you’re considering; battery life depends on how you use it.

Sony PlayStation

The DualSense is an option for PS5 players who want to use haptic feedback and adaptive triggers when supported by a game.

  • Sony describes haptic feedback and adaptive triggers as DualSense features.
  • Availability depends on the game. Using the controller with systems other than PS5 may require a USB connection.

PowerA

The Advantage Wired Controller with Lumectra is a wired option for supported Xbox systems and Windows.

  • PowerA lists four adjustable lighting zones and two mappable buttons for this model.
  • The lighting doesn’t make this model wireless. PowerA specifies a USB-C cable of around 3 m for this version.

Nintendo

The Switch 2 Pro Controller is designed for use with Nintendo Switch 2.

  • Nintendo lists mappable GL/GR buttons and a headset jack.
  • Nintendo lists this controller for Switch 2 only; actual battery life may differ from the stated figure.

GameSir

The T7 is a wired option for the Xbox systems and Windows versions listed by GameSir.

  • GameSir specifies Hall effect sticks and triggers, plus a detachable 3 m cable.
  • That stick technology alone doesn’t prove that a controller will never develop stick drift or last longer.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2 Bluetooth is an option for the Switch and Windows systems listed by 8BitDo.

  • For this version, 8BitDo lists a charging dock, TMR sticks and adjustable buttons.
  • For Switch 2, 8BitDo specifies a firmware update. The Ultimate 2 Wireless has different listed compatibility.

Joybuy products for this gaming setup

This selection includes wireless and wired controllers for Xbox and PC, a DualSense for PS5 and a Pro Controller for Switch 2. Check that the connection and features of the specific version suit your system.

Xbox Wireless Controller for Xbox Series/PC - Ice Breaker Special Edition

Xbox Wireless Controller - Ice Breaker Special Edition

A wireless option to compare if you play on a supported Xbox or Windows PC.

The product information lists textured grips and AA batteries. According to the product information, the USB-C cable for wired use is sold separately.

View at Joybuy
PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller - Grand Theft Auto VI White Limited Edition

PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller - Grand Theft Auto VI White Limited Edition

An option for PS5 players who want to use this version’s supported haptics and adaptive triggers.

The product information also lists a built-in microphone, USB-C and a motion sensor. Sony says that haptics and adaptive triggers depend on the game; a USB connection may be needed for some uses.

View at Joybuy
GameSir T7 Wired Xbox Controller with Hall effect joysticks and triggers, blue

GameSir T7 Wired Xbox Controller - Blue

A wired option to compare if you play on Xbox, Windows or Steam and are looking for Hall effect sticks.

The product name lists Hall effect joysticks and triggers. GameSir specifies a detachable 3 m USB-C cable, so consider the distance between your seat and your system.

View at Joybuy
GameSir G7 Pro Tri-Mode Xbox Wired, PC & Mobile Wireless Controller - Shadow Ember

GameSir G7 Pro Tri-Mode Controller - Shadow Ember

An option to compare if you want to play wired on Xbox and are looking for wireless connectivity for PC or mobile.

The product name distinguishes wired use on Xbox from wireless use on PC and mobile. Check which connection mode is right for your device.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch 2 Official Pro Controller - Black

Nintendo Switch 2 Official Pro Controller - Black

An option if you play on Nintendo Switch 2 and are looking for a controller for that system.

Nintendo states that this controller is for Switch 2 only and doesn’t work with the original Nintendo Switch.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does the lighting have to stay on when you play in the dark?

No. According to the model manual, you can adjust the lighting on the PowerA Advantage Wired Controller with Lumectra and switch off all the LEDs. Check that the exact version you’re considering has the same controls.

Do DualSense haptics and adaptive triggers work in every PC game?

No, don’t assume they do. Sony says the features are available when a game supports them, and a USB connection may be required.

Can you also use the Switch 2 Pro Controller with your original Switch?

No. Nintendo states that the Switch 2 Pro Controller doesn’t work with the original Nintendo Switch.

What can you do if your controller doesn’t work properly after purchase?

In the Netherlands, you’re entitled to a product that is fit for purpose, and you can contact the seller if there’s a fault. The Government of the Netherlands states that there is no fixed statutory warranty period of exactly two years. For most online consumer purchases, you also have a 14-day cancellation period, with some exceptions.

Where can you take an old controller and used AA batteries?

Take an old electrical controller to a suitable collection point, or use the take-back scheme when buying a similar device. Don’t put used batteries in general waste; the Government of the Netherlands lists collection points at shops that sell batteries.