Who is this choice relevant to?

Adventure gamer with a dedicated console

First, you want to know whether the controller works with your console and game. PlayStation, Microsoft and Nintendo each describe the support and features available on their own platforms.

Gamer who carefully considers the room lighting

You might want visible controller lighting, or prefer less distraction from bright indicators. Options vary by model and platform: PlayStation describes indicator settings for PS5, while PowerA offers adjustable lighting zones on Lumectra models.

Gamer who enjoys long adventure sessions

You’ll want to consider grip, power and freedom of movement. A cable, AA batteries and a rechargeable battery each involve different trade-offs, as information from Microsoft, Nintendo and 8BitDo shows.

What should you look for?

First check that your system and game support the controller. Then compare lighting, comfort, feedback and power based on how you play.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this most important for?
Compatibility Check that your console or operating system and the game support the controller and the features you want. I want to be sure my usual console and game work with the controller before anything else; around 29% of consumers put compatibility first.
Lighting in a dark room Check whether you can adjust the brightness on the exact model and whether the buttons themselves are illuminated. In a dark room, I want to choose between visible lighting and as little distraction as possible; around 23% of consumers consider controller lighting first.
Comfort during long sessions Compare the grip and layout. If you’re considering a wired model, check that the cable is long enough for where you sit. During long sessions, I want a comfortable grip and enough room to move where I’m sitting; around 18% of consumers prioritise grip and seating distance.
Feedback and extra controls Check which types of feedback your game supports and whether you can assign extra buttons as you wish. I want haptics, triggers or extra buttons to be genuinely useful in my game; around 18% of consumers prioritise feedback supported by the game.
Power and play time Check the power source, what’s included with the model and the conditions under which the stated battery life applies. For a long gaming session, I want to know whether I’ll need to change batteries, recharge or play with a cable; around 12% of consumers prioritise power for uninterrupted play.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming RGB lighting means the button labels are illuminated

    PowerA describes lighting zones, while PlayStation describes a setting for indicator brightness. Neither confirms that the button labels light up.

    For the exact model, check separately which parts are illuminated and how you can adjust the brightness.

  • Assuming all feedback will work in your game

    PlayStation says adaptive triggers and haptics require game support. Haptics on PC may also require a USB connection.

    Check support for your game and platform before making these features a deciding factor.

  • Choosing a wireless controller without considering its power source

    The Xbox quick-start guide explains how to insert batteries. Nintendo and 8BitDo list rechargeable batteries and usage-dependent play times for specific models.

    Check the power source and what’s included with the exact model. Treat stated battery life as dependent on usage, not as guaranteed play time.

Brands to consider

Sony PlayStation

The DualSense is designed for PS5 players who want to use haptics and adaptive triggers in games that support these features.

  • PlayStation describes a setting for adjusting controller indicator brightness on PS5.
  • PlayStation says not all features are available on other devices; haptics on PC may require USB. A brightness setting does not confirm that all lighting can be turned off.

Microsoft Xbox

The Xbox Wireless Controller is designed for Xbox and supported PCs. Microsoft lists Bluetooth and button mapping among its features.

  • Microsoft describes a hybrid D-pad and textured grip.
  • The quick-start guide explains how to insert batteries, so don’t assume the standard controller has a built-in rechargeable battery.

Nintendo

The Switch Pro Controller is designed for compatible Switch games and, according to Nintendo, features motion controls, HD rumble and amiibo functionality.

  • Nintendo gives an approximate battery life of 40 hours when the controller is fully charged.
  • Nintendo says play time may vary depending on the software and how the controller is used. The listed features do not confirm that the buttons are illuminated.

PowerA

The Advantage Wired with Lumectra is designed for supported Xbox systems and Windows PCs when adjustable RGB lighting is what you’re after.

  • PowerA describes four lighting zones and adjustable brightness through Gamer HQ.
  • This model is wired. Its lighting features are specifications provided by PowerA, not the result of an independent performance test; RGB lighting does not confirm that the button labels light up.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2C Wireless is designed for supported Windows and Android devices and features assignable extra bumpers and Hall Effect sticks.

  • According to 8BitDo, connection methods vary by platform: 2.4 GHz or cable on Windows, and Bluetooth on Android.
  • The stated play time is based on the manufacturer’s ideal test conditions. This does not mean the controller supports PS5, Xbox or Switch.

Joybuy products for this gaming scenario

This selection includes controllers for Nintendo Switch, PS5 and Xbox or Windows PC, with controller lighting listed for some models. Check whether the lighting illuminates the buttons themselves on the exact model.

NAXSIR wireless gamepad for Switch with LED lighting

NAXSIR Wireless Gamepad for Switch

For playing on Nintendo Switch. The specifications list Bluetooth, seven-colour LED lighting, vibration feedback and a stated range of 10 m.

Joybuy
NAXSIR wireless PS5 controller with RGB lighting

NAXSIR Wireless PS5 Controller

For anyone looking for a controller for PS5. This model lists RGB lighting, programmable buttons, Hall Effect sticks and a 1000 mAh battery.

Joybuy
GameSir Cyclone 2 multi-platform controller, Black-Bundle Edition

GameSir Cyclone 2 Multi-Platform Controller (Black-Bundle Edition)

For use with PC or Nintendo Switch; the listed platforms also include iOS and Android. This bundle lists Mag-Res TMR sticks, Hall and Micro 2-in-1 triggers, RGB lighting, a 1000 Hz polling rate and a charging dock.

Joybuy
Nintendo Switch Pro Controller in black

Nintendo Switch Pro Controller - Black

For Nintendo Switch players looking for a black Pro Controller.

Joybuy
GameSir T7 wired Xbox controller in blue

GameSir T7 Wired Xbox Controller (Blue)

For use with Xbox or a Windows PC. The product details list Hall Effect sticks and triggers, support for Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One, Windows 10/11 and Steam, and a detachable 3 m USB-C cable; the cable limits how far you can sit from the console or PC.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I dim the lights on a DualSense controller on PS5?

Yes. PlayStation describes the ‘Brightness of Controller Indicators’ setting under Settings > Accessories > Controller (General). This does not confirm that all lighting can be turned off completely.

Do DualSense feedback features work in every PC game?

No. PC compatibility alone does not guarantee this. According to PlayStation, the game must support adaptive triggers and haptic feedback; haptics on PC may also require USB.

What should I know about the power source for an Xbox Wireless Controller?

The Xbox quick-start guide explains how to insert batteries. For the exact model, check whether AA batteries are included and which charging option you’d like to use; don’t assume a battery is included as standard.

What are my rights when buying a controller online in the Netherlands?

According to ACM ConsuWijzer, online purchases generally come with a statutory cooling-off period of up to 14 days after delivery, although there are exceptions. If a product doesn’t perform as you could reasonably expect under normal use, you may also be entitled to a statutory guarantee from the seller.

Where can I recycle used batteries or an old controller?

The Dutch government lists collection points for used batteries at shops and supermarkets that sell batteries. There are also places to hand in small discarded electrical appliances; check the collection point’s terms and conditions.