Flight sim enthusiast sharing a desk
This flight sim enthusiast wants to view instruments and make small control adjustments, but put the controls away afterwards.
For virtual instrument scanning, a single flight stick may be enough if you can assign the functions you need in your simulator to it, keeping your setup to one device. A HOTAS has a separate throttle, but takes up more space on and around your desk. A yoke may suit exercises involving an aircraft with that type of control, while none of the specifications listed here prove which control is the quietest.
This flight sim enthusiast wants to view instruments and make small control adjustments, but put the controls away afterwards.
This flight sim enthusiast wants to keep several functions within reach while scanning instruments, and is comparing controls on a single device with a separate throttle.
This flight sim enthusiast wants to check first whether the stick is suitable for their PC or Xbox and works with their simulator.
A good fit if: you want to put away one device and can operate the functions you need on the stick.
Bear in mind: integrated throttle controls are not the same as a separate throttle.
A good fit if: you want to operate the throttle and stick separately and have room for two components.
Bear in mind: the throttle needs extra space to set up and put away.
A good fit if: the controls of the aircraft you’re simulating matter more to you than the flexibility of a stick. Microsoft Flight Simulator says a yoke is more realistic for aircraft such as the Cessna 172.
Bear in mind: the same guide says a joystick is more flexible for different types of aircraft; measure the available desk and storage space beforehand.
When practising in a shared bedroom, the main considerations are available space, accessible controls, platform compatibility and any potential disturbance to a flatmate or roommate.
| Consideration | What should you check? | Who is this relevant for? |
|---|---|---|
| Space and storage | Measure the available space and check whether the model includes one device or a separate throttle as well. | If I want to put the controller away after practising without taking up space on our shared desk, I’ll check how many separate components there are. Around 36% of consumers prioritise being able to put their equipment away. |
| Controls while scanning | Check the rudder, throttle and viewing controls, along with the functions you can assign in your simulator. | If I want to keep my eyes on the instruments while making small adjustments, I need the functions I use to be within reach. Around 29% of consumers prioritise accessible controls. |
| Platform and simulator | Check the exact model, compatibility with PC or console, simulator version and available controller profiles. | If I still need to find out whether my PC, Xbox and simulator work together, I’ll check before buying. Around 21% of consumers say platform compatibility is their top priority. |
| Potential noise disturbance | Assess how noisy the controls are separately; don’t assume they’re quiet based on the sensor technology or number of components. | If noise might bother a roommate, I’ll want to assess the controls for myself first. Around 14% of consumers prioritise minimising potential disturbance. |
The Thrustmaster TCA Sidestick X Airbus Edition is listed as compatible with Xbox and PC. You can’t assume the same compatibility for a similarly named model.
Check the full model name and platform information, not just the product photo or an abbreviated model name.
The Thrustmaster T.16000M FCS HOTAS consists of a stick and a separate TWCS throttle, so there are two components to set up and put away.
Before you start, decide where both components can go while you’re practising and afterwards.
According to Microsoft Flight Simulator, some controllers may need to have their functions assigned manually. Assignments can also conflict with one another.
Check the control axes in your simulator and assign only the functions you need for your exercises.
A mention of contactless main axes doesn’t tell you how much noise the buttons or stick make during use.
If your roommate is sensitive to noise, assess it separately; don’t assume the stick is quiet based on its sensor technology.
For this kind of setup, the single TCA Sidestick X Airbus Edition and the T.16000M FCS HOTAS with a separate throttle are both worth considering.
The VelocityOne Flightstick is a single controller with integrated levers, for anyone comparing controls and platform compatibility.
The Extreme 3D Pro is a single stick worth comparing if you’re looking at a PC setup with a twist rudder and a hat switch.
This selection of Joybuy products includes a flight stick with integrated controls and a PC flight control set with a separate stick and throttle. Check that each model’s platform support and function assignments are compatible with your simulator.
No image available
A single flight stick with integrated levers for anyone who wants to operate several functions on one device.
According to the product specifications: 8 axes, two multifunction levers, 27 programmable buttons and an 8-way hat switch.
Listed platform support includes Xbox and Windows 10/11. Check the functions and assignments in your simulator.
Wired via USB-C.
No image available
A PC flight control set for anyone who wants to operate the stick and throttle separately; bear in mind that there are two separate components to set up and put away.
The product name lists PC compatibility. Also check compatibility and function assignments for your simulator.
No, a yoke isn’t a general requirement for this exercise. Microsoft Flight Simulator says a yoke is more realistic for an aircraft such as the Cessna 172, while a joystick is more flexible for different types of aircraft. Choose based on the aircraft and controls you want to simulate.
In Microsoft Flight Simulator 2024, first select the connected controller under CONTROLS, then check the general profile or the profile for the aircraft. Resolve any duplicate assignments; for another simulator, check its own controller settings.
Check that all the components of your chosen model fit on the desk and can be put away after use. After moving or reconnecting the controller, also check that the simulator recognises it and that your preferred assignments are still correct.
For eligible online consumer purchases from a business, the Dutch government says that in many cases you have a 14-day cooling-off period; the distance selling rules don’t apply in the same way when buying from a private individual. You’re also entitled to a product that is fit for purpose, and if it’s faulty you can ask the seller to put things right. The Netherlands doesn’t have a fixed statutory warranty period of exactly two years.