Sim pilot sharing a desk
You want to enjoy virtual coastal flights and put the controls away afterwards. Compare a stick with controls on the base against a setup with a separate throttle; a compact design alone tells you nothing about button noise.
Start by considering your platform, the aircraft you usually fly and how much desk space you can give up for the controls. A stick with throttle controls on the base has fewer separate parts than a HOTAS; a HOTAS has a separate throttle, but may take up more space. Based on the specifications available, none of the models discussed can be described as quiet, so assess the operating noise in your own setup if you want to avoid disturbing a roommate.
You want to enjoy virtual coastal flights and put the controls away afterwards. Compare a stick with controls on the base against a setup with a separate throttle; a compact design alone tells you nothing about button noise.
Your choice starts with checking whether the exact model is compatible with your PC or console. Xbox support for one model does not automatically mean that other models in the same product range will work too.
You may want functions such as engine power or flaps within easy reach, and need to weigh that against the extra controls and space the setup requires.
First check that the model is compatible with your platform, then consider how much space you can make for it. Treat noise as a separate consideration: specifications about buttons or a weighted base do not tell you how much operating noise you will hear.
| What to consider | What should you look for? | Who is this important to? |
|---|---|---|
| Noise in the bedroom | Assess the sound of the buttons and moving controls in your own setup; don't assume a model is quiet based on its design alone. | If someone sleeps or works next to you, you'll want to minimise disruption. Around 31% of consumers prioritise avoiding disturbance to a roommate as their main purchase concern. |
| Desk space and storage | Consider how the stick and any throttle will be set up. Thrustmaster says the throttle on the T.Flight Hotas One can be attached to the stick or positioned separately. | If you want to clear your desk after flying, the setup matters. Around 25% of consumers say storage and available desk space are their main purchase concern. |
| Compatibility | Check the platform specifications for the exact model and, if necessary, the required connections or additional equipment. | If you want to use the stick with your own PC or console, compatibility is crucial. Around 25% of consumers put platform compatibility first. |
| Controls and extra components | Decide which functions you want to control directly, and check whether the throttle or other components you need are included with your chosen model. | If you want to control functions such as engine power and flaps directly, you'll also want to know what you need to do so. Around 19% of consumers prioritise accessible functions and the size of the required setup as their main purchase concern. |
Compatibility can vary by model. A product name or another version in the same range doesn't prove that the stick will work with your console.
Before buying, check the full model name and platform specifications for your own PC or console.
A model that doesn't work with your platform could be unusable, or you may need to buy replacement hardware.
A HOTAS may consist of a stick and a separate throttle. This can affect the space available and how you position the components.
Check what's included with the model and consider where the components and cables will go. Thrustmaster says the throttle on the T.Flight Hotas One can be positioned separately or attached to the stick.
When set up separately, the two components take up space individually; attaching the throttle to the stick changes the layout.
The product information describes the controls and components, but doesn't provide comparable measurements of audible noise.
If quiet operation matters in a shared bedroom, assess the operating noise separately in your own setup.
The range includes both sticks with controls on the base and HOTAS setups with a separate throttle.
According to Turtle Beach, the VelocityOne Flightstick combines a stick with two multifunction levers.
The models mentioned have different controls: the Extreme 3D Pro is a stick with a twist rudder, while the X52 Pro is a HOTAS.
Honeycomb describes the Foxtrot Aviation Stick as a flight simulation stick for PC and Mac.
This selection includes flight sticks with integrated or separate controls, as well as a TCA quadrant for additional flight controls. Check the space required, platform compatibility and which components you'll need for your setup for each model.
No image available
This stick with two levers is a good fit if you want to control several flight functions from one device.
The product name lists USB-C, 8 axes and 27 programmable buttons. The listed platforms are Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and PC with Windows 10/11.
No image available
According to the product information, this PC flight control system consists of a flight stick and throttle, making it an option if you're looking for a separate throttle.
The listed dimensions for the system are 371 × 264 × 233 mm. Bear in mind the space needed for the setup if you're sharing a desk.
No image available
This is a TCA quadrant, not a complete flight stick; it's only relevant if you're specifically looking for these additional flight controls.
The product information lists three axes and 17 action buttons. For Xbox use, it says the TCA Yoke Boeing Edition must be connected.
No, they're not essential for everyone: a stick can provide the basic controls, and its twist axis can act as a rudder. A separate throttle or pedals are optional, depending on the controls you want; they aren't standard components of every stick.
First decide where the base and cable will go, then assign the functions you use in your simulator. Thrustmaster says the T.Flight Hotas One's throttle can be attached to the stick or positioned separately; the TCA Sidestick X has throttle controls on the base.
For a standard product bought online, ACM ConsuWijzer says you generally have a 14-day cooling-off period after delivery, subject to legal exceptions. You also have statutory warranty rights if a product used normally doesn't meet the standard you could reasonably expect; there isn't simply a fixed two-year period that applies to every stick.