Who is this relevant to?

Keeper of bound journals

Your main concern is capturing text close to the spine without forcing the journal open. Canon states that the LiDE 400 has a Z-lid for material up to 21 mm thick; for certain OpticBook models, Plustek specifies a book-edge clearance. These details don’t, on their own, tell you how your binding will scan.

Collector of photos and travel documents

You also scan pasted-in photos, maps or larger spreads. Compare the scan area with your largest original, and check which photo and text features the manufacturer lists. Epson describes photo and text enhancement features, but the results depend on the material and settings.

Hobbyist with limited workspace

You want to scan pages regularly, but also use your hobby table for other projects. Compare the scanner’s external dimensions, power supply and how it creates multi-page files. Canon and Epson, for example, describe USB-powered models.

What should you look for?

First decide whether the book spine or the size of your originals is the priority. Then check the file workflow and how much space the scanner will take up on your hobby table.

What to consider What should you check? Who should prioritise this?
Book spine and binding Compare the design with your book. Plustek specifies a 6 mm book-edge clearance for the OpticBook 3800L and 2 mm for the 4800; for the LiDE 400, Canon states that the Z-lid accommodates material up to 21 mm thick. These are manufacturer specifications, not a guarantee for every binding. If I want to scan close to the spine without pressing my journal fully open, I’ll pay particular attention to the book-edge clearance and how my own page lies on the glass. Around 36% of consumers prioritise protecting the binding.
Photos and scan size Canon lists a maximum document size of 216 × 297 mm for the LiDE 400; Plustek lists a scan area of up to 297 × 431,8 mm for the OpticSlim 1180. Measure your largest original and compare it with the glass area. If I want to capture pasted-in photos or larger maps, I need to know whether the whole original will fit on the glass and which image features are available. Around 29% of consumers prioritise photos and size.
Finding files later Check whether the software on your computer supports multi-page files or searchable PDFs. Canon lists a feature for multi-page PDFs; Plustek and HP list searchable PDFs. This doesn’t tell you how well handwriting will be recognised. If I’m archiving lots of pages, I want to keep them in order and find them later without relying on handwriting recognition. Around 21% of consumers prioritise organising and finding files.
Workspace and connection Compare the scanner’s dimensions, available connections and power supply with your workspace. Canon gives the LiDE 400’s dimensions as 250 × 367 × 42 mm; Plustek lists the OpticSlim 1180 at 589 × 407 × 68 mm, with a separate AC power supply. If I also need my hobby table for other tasks, I want to know in advance how much space the scanner takes up and how to connect it. Around 14% of consumers prioritise workspace and connection.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming a lid designed for a certain material thickness will work for every book spine

    Canon states that its Z-lid can accommodate material up to 21 mm thick. That’s not the same as a guarantee that text close to the spine will be captured without shadows.

    Check where the text sits in your journal and whether the binding opens without pressure before choosing a scanner with a particular lid or book-edge design.

  • Choosing an A3 scan area without measuring the scanner itself

    Plustek specifies external dimensions of 589 × 407 × 68 mm for the OpticSlim 1180. A larger scan area also means you’ll need enough space on your hobby table.

    Measure both your largest open original and the available space on your table.

    A larger scanner could take up space you need to lay out and turn the pages of your journal.

  • Assuming an automatic document feeder’s speed applies to scanning a journal

    HP describes the ScanJet Pro 2600 f1’s speed when using its automatic document feeder. Bound pages are scanned on the flatbed, not through the feeder.

    When choosing a scanner for journals, consider how you’ll use the flatbed and manually turn and position the pages, rather than looking only at feeder speed.

    With bound material, manually positioning and turning every page takes time.

Brands to consider

Canon

The CanoScan LiDE 400 is a compact A4 flatbed scanner for pages that fit within its scan area.

  • Canon Netherlands lists USB power, a scan area of 216 × 297 mm and a Z-lid for material up to 21 mm thick.
  • The thickness of material that fits under the lid doesn’t determine how text beside a stiff book spine will be captured.

Epson

The Perfection V39II is an A4 photo and document scanner with a built-in stand.

  • Epson Netherlands lists USB power, a built-in stand and photo and text enhancement features.
  • These features don’t determine the results you’ll get with your photos or whether the scanner is suitable for a particular book binding.

Plustek

Plustek offers both OpticBook models with a book-edge design and the larger OpticSlim 1180.

  • Plustek Europe specifies a 6 mm book-edge clearance for the OpticBook 3800L and 2 mm for the 4800. For the OpticSlim 1180, the brand lists a scan area of up to 297 × 431,8 mm.
  • Book-edge clearance varies by model; with stated external dimensions of 589 × 407 mm, the OpticSlim 1180 needs more table space. These are manufacturer specifications, not an independent comparison.

HP

The ScanJet Pro 2600 f1 combines a flatbed with an automatic document feeder for loose documents.

  • HP lists a 60-sheet feeder and a maximum optical resolution of 1200 dpi on the flatbed.
  • HP lists a maximum resolution of 600 dpi for the feeder. Its capacity and speed don’t describe how it scans bound journal pages.

Joybuy products

These models combine a flatbed for bound pages with options for loose travel documents.

Canon imageFORMULA DR-F120 A4 flatbed scanner with ADF, 600 × 600 dpi, black

Canon imageFORMULA DR-F120 A4 flatbed scanner with ADF, 600 × 600 dpi, black

The combination of a flatbed and an automatic document feeder could suit journals scanned on the glass and loose travel documents scanned through the feeder.

The product name lists A4 and 600 × 600 dpi. Use the flatbed for bound pages; the document feeder is for loose documents.

View at Joybuy
Epson WorkForce DS-1660W A4 flatbed scanner, 1200 × 1200 dpi, black and white

Epson WorkForce DS-1660W A4 flatbed scanner, 1200 × 1200 dpi, black and white

The flatbed could be useful for bound documents and the automatic feeder for loose sheets. Check in advance that your journal’s binding will lie properly on the glass.

The product name lists A4 and 1200 × 1200 dpi. The stated feeder is designed for loose documents, not bound pages.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can you put a bound journal through an automatic document feeder?

Use the flatbed for bound pages. A feeder for loose sheets can be useful for individual travel documents, but HP’s stated capacity and speed don’t apply to scanning a book.

Will a searchable PDF also be searchable if your journal is handwritten?

Not automatically. Manufacturers list text recognition and searchable PDF features, but that doesn’t guarantee your handwriting will be recognised. Make a test scan and check the recognised text before relying on it.

What are your rights if a scanner bought online isn’t right for your needs or develops a fault?

If a scanner isn’t right for your needs, ACM ConsuWijzer states that online purchases have a 14-day cooling-off period, which ends 14 days after the product is delivered. Check whether an exception applies to your purchase. A faulty product is also covered by the statutory guarantee: the retailer is your point of contact.

Can you share other people’s photos or text from your travel journal online after scanning them?

Not just because you scanned them for your own use. The Dutch government states that you can make a private copy of copyright-protected work for personal use, but you can’t distribute or publish it without permission. So distinguish between your own material and other people’s work.