Which scanner is right for you?

Reader with loose papers

You mainly scan individual A4 pages and want to be able to find the text later without giving up too much desk space.

Reader of bound sources

You digitise pages from books or journals, paying particular attention to readability near the spine and placing the original carefully.

Paperwork archivist

You often process large numbers of loose, possibly double-sided pages and want a feeder for the job, while still having a flatbed available.

What should you look for?

Compact A4 flatbed scanner

Choose this option: if you mainly scan loose papers up to A4 and have limited workspace.

Bear in mind: you place the pages on the glass one at a time; Canon specifies a maximum scan size of 216 × 297 mm for the LiDE 400.

A4 flatbed scanner with book edge

Choose this option: if you often scan pages from bound books or journals.

Bear in mind: you still have to turn the pages; the claim about reduced spine shadow comes from Plustek and is not based on independent testing.

Flatbed scanner with document feeder

Choose this option: if you regularly process large numbers of loose sheets and also need a flatbed for bound pages.

Bear in mind: the feeder is for loose documents; HP lists different maximum optical resolutions for the feeder and the flatbed.

A3 flatbed scanner

Choose this option: if fold-out sheets or large journal pages won't fit on A4.

Bear in mind: you'll need more desk space; Plustek lists external dimensions of 589 × 407 × 68 mm for the OpticSlim 1180.

What to consider What to look for when buying Who is this important for?
Searchable text and compact A4 size Check the scan area, OCR or output to a searchable PDF, software compatibility with your operating system, and how much space the scanner takes up. If I scan loose A4 papers at a small workstation, I want to be able to search the text later without setting up a large device; around 36% of consumers prioritise searchable text and a compact A4 setup.
Bound pages Look at the book-edge design, lid and scan area; check that you can position pages properly. When scanning papers in books or journals, I want to capture readable text near the spine without feeding the original through a document feeder; around 29% of consumers prioritise scanning bound sources.
Large numbers of loose pages Check the feeder capacity and whether it scans both sides through the feeder; also consider how you'll organise and check your files. If I process stacks of loose, sometimes double-sided papers, I want to spend less time placing pages by hand; around 21% of consumers prioritise processing loose sheets.
Larger than A4 Measure the largest original you want to scan in one go and compare it with the scan area and the desk space required. For fold-out sheets or large pages, I want to capture the entire original in one scan; around 14% of consumers prioritise a larger scan size.

Common mistakes when choosing

  • Assuming a PDF button means text recognition

    A scanner can save a PDF without making the text searchable. A PDF button alone does not confirm that OCR is available.

    Before buying, check the software for the exact model to see whether it supports OCR or output to a searchable PDF.

    If you mainly scan books or journals, the automatic feeder may not be able to handle much of your material, while you'll still have to turn pages one at a time.

  • Comparing speed or resolution under different conditions

    Canon's stated time for an A4 colour scan at 300 dpi excludes transfer to the computer. HP lists separate resolution limits for the feeder and flatbed.

    Compare the same paper size, scan mode and feeding method, and remember to factor in manual page-turning and checking the files.

Brands worth considering

Epson

The Perfection V39II is a compact A4 flatbed scanner for loose documents in a small workspace. Epson Netherlands lists a vertical stand and document text features.

  • The vertical placement can be useful if you have limited desk space.
  • The vertical stand and text features are manufacturer specifications, not the result of independent performance testing.

Canon

Canon describes the CanoScan LiDE 400 as a USB-powered A4 flatbed scanner with PDF buttons for loose documents.

  • Canon specifies a maximum document size of 216 × 297 mm.
  • The approximately 8 seconds for an A4 colour scan applies at 300 dpi under Canon's test conditions and excludes transfer to the computer; this is not the time needed to scan a complete paper.

Plustek

The OpticBook 3800L is designed for bound A4 material; the OpticSlim 1180 is a separate A3 model for larger pages.

  • Plustek specifies a 6 mm book edge and OCR for the OpticBook 3800L; for the OpticSlim 1180, the brand lists a larger scan area.
  • The claim about reduced shadow near the book spine comes from the manufacturer. Check the specification and software for the model you're considering.

HP

The ScanJet Pro 2600 f1 combines a flatbed with an automatic document feeder for loose sheets.

  • HP specifies a 60-page feeder and single-pass double-sided scanning.
  • According to HP, the flatbed and feeder have different maximum optical resolutions; the stated speed and capacity do not measure a complete home scanning task.

Joybuy products

These products combine a flatbed for bound material with options for loose A4 pages; one model also has an automatic document feeder.

Canon imageFORMULA DR-F120 A4 flatbed and ADF scanner

Canon imageFORMULA DR-F120 A4 flatbed and ADF scanner

The combination of a flatbed and document feeder is suited to scanning both bound material and loose sheets.

  • A4 size and 600 × 600 dpi.
  • Automatic double-sided scanning at up to 20 pages per minute.
  • 50-sheet feeder.
  • Scan to editable PDFs.
  • Use the flatbed for books and thick originals; the feeder is for loose documents.
Joybuy
Epson WorkForce DS-1660W A4 flatbed scanner

Epson WorkForce DS-1660W A4 flatbed scanner

The flatbed is designed for books and bound documents; automatic double-sided scanning can also be useful for loose pages.

  • A4 size and 1200 × 1200 dpi.
  • Automatic double-sided scanning at up to 25 pages per minute.
  • Wi-Fi and USB 3.0.
Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is a PDF button enough to search a research paper by its words?

No. Check specifically whether OCR or output to a searchable PDF is available. Canon lists PDF buttons for the LiDE 400; Plustek lists OCR and searchable PDF separately for the OpticBook 3800L.

How do I scan a bound paper without a document feeder?

Use the glass and check that you can position the page and spine properly. Plustek lists a 6 mm book edge and an adjustable lid for the OpticBook 3800L; that doesn't guarantee that every book can be scanned in the same way.

What are my rights if the scanner is faulty?

For a consumer purchase in the Netherlands, the seller must provide a solution if the product is faulty; according to the Dutch government, there is no fixed statutory warranty period. When buying from a business at a distance, you are also entitled to a 14-day cooling-off period in many cases. Check whether this applies to your purchase.

Can I scan a printed research paper for myself and share the PDF?

According to Auteursrechten.nl, you may scan and save a printed paper for your own practice, study or use. The Dutch government says that a private copy for personal use must not be distributed or made public; according to Auteursrechten.nl, you need the rights holder's permission to distribute a scanned paper further.