Who is each scanner suited to?

Scanning bound magazines

If you want to keep magazines intact, look for easy access to text near the spine and check the size of the scanning area. Plustek describes these features for the OpticBook 3800L.

Processing stacks of loose articles

If you scan both loose sheets and bound material, consider whether a model with a flatbed and a document feeder suits the way you work. HP describes both scanning options for the ScanJet Pro 2600 f1.

Creating a searchable archive

If you want to search your files by text, check that the software for your chosen model supports OCR and the file format you need. Plustek and HP list OCR capabilities for specific models.

What should you consider when choosing?

First, decide whether you’ll mainly scan bound material, loose sheets or originals larger than A4. Then consider whether you need to be able to search the digital files.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Text near the book spine Check whether you can access the text on your own bound material and whether the scanning area is large enough. If I want to capture articles from bound magazines, I focus on the text along the spine. Around 36% of consumers say this is their main need.
Feeding loose sheets Check whether the model has a document feeder and whether it supports the double-sided scanning you need. If I regularly process stacks of loose articles as well as bound material, I want to know whether both scanning options are available. Around 29% of consumers prioritise processing loose sheets.
Searchable files Check that OCR, the output format you need and the software are available on the group’s computer. If I want to search for words in scans later, the chosen OCR output needs to support this. Searchability is the main need for around 21% of consumers.
Large originals Compare the width and length of the scanning area with the largest page you want to scan. If you want to capture a large magazine page or a double-page spread in one go, the size of the scanning area matters. Around 14% of consumers prioritise being able to scan large originals.

Pitfalls to avoid

  • Confusing a book scanner with a model for large spreads

    Plustek lists a 6 mm book edge for the OpticBook 3800L, but its scanning area is A4. So a scanner designed for books won’t automatically meet your needs for a larger format.

    Measure your largest original and check that text near the spine is easy to access on your own material.

  • Assuming scan speed means the time it takes to scan an entire magazine

    A stated scan time for a single page doesn’t include placing and turning each page. Canon lists the CanoScan LiDE 400’s scan speed under specific test conditions.

    Assess the whole process using the type of material your group actually wants to scan.

  • Assuming OCR delivers flawless searchable text

    OCR makes text recognition possible, but how useful it is for your articles depends on the scan and the output.

    Make a test scan and check names, footnotes and columns before building a large archive.

  • Assuming private use means you can share scans with a group

    The Dutch Government distinguishes between a private copy for personal use and digitally sharing protected publications. You need permission to share them; an applicable scheme doesn’t automatically cover every group or method of distribution.

    Before sharing, check which permission or scheme applies to your specific use.

Relevant brands

Plustek

The OpticBook 3800L is designed for scanning bound material, while the OpticSlim 1180 has a larger scanning area.

  • Plustek lists a 6 mm book edge and included OCR for the OpticBook 3800L. Its scanning area is A4.
  • Plustek lists a maximum scanning area of 297 × 431,8 mm for the OpticSlim 1180.
  • The OpticSlim 1180 is 589 mm wide, so measure your available workspace too.

HP

According to HP, the ScanJet Pro 2600 f1 combines a flatbed with a feeder for loose pages.

  • HP lists a 60-page automatic document feeder, double-sided scanning and OCR output, including searchable PDF.
  • HP lists the flatbed’s maximum size as 216 × 297 mm. Check whether that’s large enough for your originals.

Canon

The CanoScan LiDE 400 is a compact A4 flatbed scanner for pages placed individually on the glass.

  • Canon lists USB power, a Z-lid and a scanning area of 216 × 297 mm.
  • A stated scan time for a single page doesn’t tell you how long it takes to process a whole stack by hand.

Epson

The Perfection V39II is a compact A4 option, while the WorkForce DS-1730 is designed for business flatbed scanning with a document feeder.

  • Epson lists a built-in stand and USB power for the V39II.
  • For the DS-1730, Epson lists 1200 dpi via the flatbed and 600 dpi via the document feeder.
  • These resolutions apply to different scanning options, so they aren’t directly comparable measures of quality.

Joybuy product picks

These models are suited to scanning tasks involving both bound documents and loose sheets.

Canon imageFORMULA DR-F120 flatbed and ADF scanner, 600x600DPI, A4, black

Canon imageFORMULA DR-F120 Flatbed & ADF Scanner

The combination of a flatbed and automatic document feeder suits groups that scan both bound material and loose sheets.

600 × 600 DPI; A4; black.

Joybuy
Epson WorkForce DS-1660W flatbed scanner, 1200 x 1200DPI, A4, black and white

Epson WorkForce DS-1660W

This A4 flatbed model is worth considering when comparing scanners for bound documents and loose sheets.

1200 × 1200 DPI; A4; black and white.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How do I choose between an A4 and an A3 scanning area?

Measure the width and length of the largest page or spread you want to capture in one scan. Canon lists a maximum of 216 × 297 mm for the CanoScan LiDE 400; Plustek lists a maximum of 297 × 431,8 mm for the OpticSlim 1180.

Is a PDF from a scanner automatically searchable?

No. Check whether the software supports OCR and output as a searchable PDF. Plustek lists these capabilities for the OpticBook 3800L, and HP for the ScanJet Pro 2600 f1. Try the output with one of your own articles before creating a large archive.

What should I check before installation and after a test scan?

Check that the software and drivers work with the computer your group uses, and test the scanning options you need. Plustek publishes operating system requirements for the OpticBook 3800L. If necessary, make test scans of both bound pages and loose sheets.

Can our group share scans of academic publications with one another?

Don’t assume that a private copy for personal use also allows you to share it with a group. The Dutch Government says permission is needed to digitally copy and share protected publications. An applicable reprographic rights scheme may cover use within a business or institution, but check that it also covers your group and the intended distribution.

What if scanned documents contain personal data?

If you process personal data, GDPR principles apply. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, an organisation must decide which security measures are needed based on the risks of the processing.