First, measure the largest page or open spread and check how close the text comes to the book’s spine. A compact flatbed scanner may be enough for loose A4 pages. If the text sits close to the spine, look for a book-edge design; a larger scanning area is only useful if the section you want to capture fits on it. With bound books, you’ll need to turn the pages by hand and check the scans before sharing them.
Who is this choice relevant to?
Keeper of bound recipe books
You want to capture recipes close to the spine without taking the book apart. Canon lists a Z-lid for the LiDE 400, while Plustek specifies a 2 mm book edge for the OpticBook 4800. Try a test scan to see whether the text in your book comes out legibly.
Creator of a searchable recipe archive
You want to organise recipes so they’re easy to read and find later. Epson lists text enhancement features for the V39II, while Plustek offers software for searchable PDFs with the OpticBook 4800. Test it with the handwriting you’ll be scanning to check that text searches work as you need them to.
Volunteer with lots of pages or large spreads
You’re processing several recipe books, loose sheets or large spreads. Measure the area you want to scan and allow for the need to turn and check the pages of bound books by hand.
What should you look for when scanning recipe books?
Compact A4 flatbed scanner
Choose this option: if you mainly scan loose pages that fit within 216 × 297 mm. Canon lists this scanning area for the LiDE 400.
Bear in mind: a larger spread won’t fit entirely on the scanning area, and a special lid doesn’t guarantee a flat inner edge.
Book-edge flatbed scanner
Choose this option: if you want to capture text close to the binding while keeping the book intact. Plustek lists a 2 mm book edge for the OpticBook 4800.
Bear in mind: the manufacturer’s claim about the book edge hasn’t been independently tested with your book, so try a test scan.
Flatbed scanner with a larger scanning area
Choose this option: if the section you want to capture is larger than A4 but fits within a scanning area of up to 297 × 431,8 mm, as Plustek specifies for the OpticSlim 1180.
Bear in mind: Plustek lists the dimensions of the unit as 589 × 407 × 68 mm; a larger scanning area won’t automatically solve the problem of a stiff binding or deep crease.
Flatbed scanner with automatic document feeder
Choose this option: if you regularly scan suitable loose sheets as well as bound books. According to Epson, the WorkForce DS-1730 combines a flatbed with an automatic document feeder.
Bear in mind: use the flatbed for bound pages; the feeder won’t turn the pages of a book for you.
| What to consider |
What should you look for? |
Which consumers? |
| Text close to the spine |
Check the binding, how the book sits on the glass and the book edge of the exact model; assess a test scan. |
If I want to capture text close to the spine without taking the book apart, I’ll pay particular attention to the inner edge. Around 36% of consumers put the book’s spine at the top of their list of purchasing concerns. |
| Legibility and finding recipes later |
Test typical handwriting, faint ink and margin notes; check both the image and whether you can search the saved PDF. |
If I want to find and read recipes easily later, I’ll check whether the scan and any text recognition work with our handwriting. Around 29% of consumers make legibility and searchability their top priority. |
| Processing time |
Count bound pages and loose sheets separately, and compare the whole process rather than just the stated scan time. |
If I have lots of pages or loose sheets to process too, I want to know how many steps the whole process involves. Around 21% of consumers name processing time as their main purchasing concern. |
| Size of the area to be captured |
Measure the width and height of the largest page or spread and compare them with the actual scanning area. |
If I want to save a large open page in a single scan, I’ll first check whether it fits on the glass. Around 14% of consumers prioritise the size of the page or spread. |
Common pitfalls when choosing and using a scanner
-
Measuring just one page
An open spread may be larger than an A4 scanning area, even if a single page fits.
Measure the area you want to capture in both directions and compare it with the scanning area before choosing a size.
Otherwise, you may need more than one scan to capture a spread, plus extra work to save the images together.
-
Assuming the stated scan time is the time needed per finished recipe
With bound books, positioning, turning pages, checking and organising all add to the scanning time.
Test the whole process with several consecutive pages. Use a document feeder only for suitable loose sheets.
Volunteers will need to spend time handling the pages by hand.
-
Assuming a searchable PDF will recognise handwriting perfectly
Software for searchable PDFs doesn’t prove that names, quantities and ingredients in your handwriting will be recognised correctly.
Check difficult words in test scans and compare the search results with the original page image.
Incorrectly recognised text may need extra time to correct.
-
Sharing a digital archive widely straight away
Copyright-protected text and personal information that could identify someone may need special consideration before scans are shared.
Review the content and how you plan to share it. Where necessary, arrange permission, an appropriate legal basis and restricted access.
Brands to compare
Canon
The CanoScan LiDE 300 and LiDE 400 are compact A4 flatbed scanners for individual pages.
- Canon lists a scanning area of 216 × 297 mm and a Z-lid for the LiDE 400.
- A larger spread won’t fit entirely on the stated scanning area, and the lid doesn’t guarantee a flat inner edge.
Epson
The Perfection V39II is designed for compact photo and document scans; the WorkForce DS-1730 combines a flatbed with a document feeder.
- Epson lists text enhancement features for the V39II and a stand for this model.
- The DS-1730’s feeder doesn’t replace the flatbed for bound books. The older Perfection V39 is a different model from the V39II.
Plustek
The OpticBook 4800 is designed for bound material; the OpticSlim 1180 is suited to larger pages and spreads.
- Plustek lists a 2 mm book edge and software for searchable PDFs for the OpticBook 4800.
- The manufacturer’s claims aren’t based on independent testing with your recipe books; a larger scanning area isn’t the same as a book edge.
HP
The ScanJet Pro 2600 f1 combines a flatbed with a document feeder for groups that also scan loose documents.
- HP lists a 60-page feeder and a stated feed speed of up to 25 pages per minute.
- The feeder specifications don’t apply to scanning bound recipes by hand.
Joybuy product selection
This Joybuy selection is a flatbed scanner with an automatic document feeder, for groups that scan bound books on the glass and also process loose sheets.
No image available
Epson WorkForce DS-1660W A4 flatbed scanner
A flatbed scanner with an automatic document feeder suits a group that processes loose sheets as well as bound books.
The product name specifies A4 size and a scan resolution of 1200 × 1200 dpi.
Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Can I put a bound book through an automatic document feeder?
Use the flatbed for a bound book. An automatic document feeder is useful for suitable loose sheets; on a scanner with both options, they’re separate ways of scanning.
Will handwritten recipes automatically become searchable?
That isn’t guaranteed with your books. Plustek lists software for searchable PDFs with the OpticBook 4800, but try a test page to see whether names, quantities and handwriting can be found accurately. Keep the original page images too.
How can I keep a digital recipe archive useful?
Agree on a consistent page order and file-naming system in advance. Scan a few representative pages and check the inner edge and small quantities before processing whole books. Follow the instructions for your chosen model when cleaning the flatbed glass.
Should I buy an extended warranty for a scanner?
Not automatically. According to the Dutch government, when you buy as a consumer in the Netherlands you’re entitled to a product that works as it should, but there’s no fixed statutory warranty period. Compare the cost of an extended warranty with your existing rights and the seller’s terms and conditions.
Can we share all the scanned recipes with the group?
Not without first considering the content and how you plan to share it. According to the Dutch government, a private copy of copyright-protected text for personal use must not be distributed or made public; sharing it with a group doesn’t automatically count as private use. For protected text, photos or illustrations, check whether you have permission or an applicable exception. If the books contain personal information that could identify someone, also consider the GDPR and the appropriate legal basis for processing it.