Who are these scanners for?

If you scan bound recipes

You want to capture recipes clearly right up to the spine without removing pages. Check the book edge, lid and scanning area; specifications alone don’t show how your recipe book will sit on the glass. Plustek lists a 6 mm book edge and an A4 scanning area for the OpticBook 3800L.

If you share a desk

You scan loose pages and want to connect the scanner easily and put it away again afterwards. Compare the dimensions, connection and space required. Epson lists a built-in stand for the Perfection V39II; Canon gives the dimensions of the CanoScan LiDE 400 as 250 × 367 × 42 mm.

If you’re creating a recipe archive

You scan regularly and want to find your files again later. Compare the PDF and software features, and test OCR separately if you want to make handwritten recipes searchable. A PDF feature alone says nothing about how well your handwriting will be recognised.

What should you look for when choosing?

Compact A4 flatbed

Choose this option if: you scan individual pages and want to put the scanner away after use.

Bear in mind: A4 glass isn’t large enough for every double-page spread, and a Z-lid doesn’t guarantee that every book spine will scan flat.

A4 book scanner with a book edge

Choose this option if: you often scan bound pages with text close to the spine.

Bear in mind: the scanner takes up space, and the book edge doesn’t guarantee that every binding will be captured without shadows.

Larger flatbed

Choose this option if: the full page or spread you want to scan won’t fit on A4 but will fit within the larger scanning area.

Bear in mind: measure the available desk and storage space too; a larger glass area won’t automatically capture text that disappears into the spine.

Flatbed with document feeder

Choose this option if: as well as recipe books, you regularly scan lots of loose recipe pages.

Bear in mind: a bound recipe book still needs to go on the glass; the feeder won’t turn the pages for you.

What to considerWhat should you check?Who should pay attention to this?
Book spine and binding Check the book edge and lid, and see how much of the page can lie on the glass without forcing the book flat. Measure the page; according to Plustek, the OpticBook 3800L has an A4 scanning area of 216 × 297 mm. If I want to capture text close to the spine without removing pages, I’ll focus on how the book sits. Around 36% of consumers say the book spine is their main concern when buying.
Space and connection Compare the dimensions, cable and connection with the available workspace and your computer. A built-in stand doesn’t change the amount of space needed to place a book on the glass. At a shared desk, I want to be able to connect and use the scanner, then put it away again. Around 29% of consumers cite limited desk space and connection as their main concern when buying.
Saving and finding scans Check which PDF and software features come with the model. Test OCR with a handwritten page of your own before relying on text recognition. If I want to find recipes again later, I need a suitable way to save and organise scans. Around 21% of consumers give archiving and finding files again their highest priority.
Page or spread size Measure the width and height. According to Canon, the CanoScan LiDE 400 has an A4 scanning area of 216 × 297 mm; the European specifications for the OpticSlim 1180 list a maximum of 297 × 431.8 mm. Check the model and dimensions when buying. If I want to save a larger spread in a single scan, it needs to fit entirely on the glass. Around 14% of consumers say scanning size is their main concern when buying.

Common buying pitfalls

  • Comparing only the highest dpi

    A resolution figure doesn’t tell you how a bound page will sit on the glass. Measure the page and check the book edge and lid before comparing resolutions. Canon and Plustek publish specifications for their models; you’ll need to check separately whether your recipe book will fit.

    If text falls outside the scanning area or doesn’t sit properly near the spine, you may need to scan it again.

  • Taking the quoted scan speed as the time needed for a complete recipe

    Scan speeds apply under specified conditions and don’t include positioning, turning the pages or organising a recipe book. Think about how you’ll keep track of page order and file names; an automatic feeder is most useful if you also scan loose sheets.

    Positioning pages, turning them and checking files by hand all take extra time.

  • Choosing an A3 scanner without measuring the spread

    A larger scanning area only helps if the image you want won’t fit on A4 but will fit within the larger format. Compare the width and height of the image with the scanning area, and measure the space available on your desk.

    A larger device may take up more desk and storage space than you need.

  • Assuming PDF or OCR means handwriting will be recognised perfectly

    A PDF button or OCR feature doesn’t prove that handwritten recipes will be accurately recognised and searchable. If you like, save the scan as an image and check a test scan before relying on recognised text.

    Checking and correcting recognised text may involve extra work by hand.

Brands to compare

Canon

The CanoScan LiDE 300 and LiDE 400 are A4 flatbeds for individual pages. For the LiDE 400, Canon lists features including USB-C power, PDF buttons and a Z-lid.

  • Canon specifies a maximum scanning area of 216 × 297 mm and dimensions of 250 × 367 × 42 mm for the LiDE 400.
  • A Z-lid doesn’t guarantee that every book spine will scan flat or without shadows. Also check that the software is compatible with your computer.

Epson

Epson offers compact flatbeds such as the Perfection V39II, as well as models that combine a glass scanning bed with an automatic document feeder, such as the WorkForce DS-1730.

  • According to Epson, the V39II has a built-in stand and is powered by USB. Epson lists 1200 dpi via the glass scanning bed and 600 dpi via the feeder for the DS-1730.
  • The feeder is designed for loose sheets, not bound recipe books. Consider how it scans a thick binding separately from whether the scanner can be stored upright.

Plustek

The OpticBook 3800L is designed for bound A4 pages; the OpticSlim 1180 has a larger scanning area.

  • For the OpticBook 3800L in the Netherlands, Plustek lists a 6 mm book edge and a scanning area of 216 × 297 mm.
  • The European specifications for the OpticSlim 1180 list a maximum of 297 × 431.8 mm. Check the dimensions and model offered by the Dutch retailer; neither size guarantees a good result with every book spine.

HP

According to HP, the ScanJet Pro 2600 f1 combines a glass scanning bed with an automatic document feeder. It may be worth considering if you scan loose recipes as well as recipe books.

  • HP lists a 60-page automatic document feeder alongside the glass scanning bed.
  • You’ll still need the glass scanning bed for a bound recipe book, and you’ll have to turn the pages by hand. If you scan almost exclusively from recipe books, the feeder may be less relevant to your choice.

Joybuy products for bound recipes

These Joybuy products combine a flatbed for bound material with the option to scan loose pages. Focus on comparing the space available and the features for saving scans.

Canon imageFORMULA DR-F120 A4 flatbed scanner with ADF

Canon imageFORMULA DR-F120 A4 flatbed scanner with ADF

The glass scanning bed is designed for bound material; the automatic document feeder also gives you an option for loose sheets.

A4. Stated resolution: 600 × 600 dpi. Dimensions: 469 × 335 × 120 mm. USB 2.0 connection.

The ADF is designed for loose documents; use the flatbed for bound recipe books.

View at Joybuy
Epson WorkForce DS-1660W A4 flatbed scanner

Epson WorkForce DS-1660W A4 flatbed scanner

The flatbed is described as suitable for books and bound documents. The listed software and file formats may be useful if you want to save your scans.

A4. Stated resolution: 1200 × 1200 dpi. The description lists PDF, JPG and TIFF output, Epson Document Capture Pro, Wi-Fi and USB 3.2 Gen 1. Dimensions: 451 × 315 × 120 mm.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I put a bound recipe book through the automatic document feeder?

Use the glass scanning bed for a bound recipe book; the feeder is designed for loose sheets. According to HP, the ScanJet Pro 2600 f1 combines a glass scanning bed with a document feeder, but the feeder won’t turn the pages for you.

How do I clean the glass if a recipe book leaves marks on it?

For the CanoScan LiDE 400, Canon recommends using a soft, dry cloth on the glass and the inside of the lid. For other models, follow the cleaning instructions in their own manuals.

Should I buy extra warranty cover when ordering a scanner online?

You don’t need to buy it to get your statutory rights: these already apply in the Netherlands. The Dutch Government says there is no fixed statutory warranty period; the expected lifespan and circumstances are taken into account. Compare any extra cover by checking the additional rights and terms it offers. For online consumer purchases, you generally have a 14-day cooling-off period.

Can I share scans from a copyrighted recipe book with other people?

The Dutch Government says you may make a private copy for your own use, but you may not distribute it or make it available to the public. A handwritten recipe of your own is a different situation; when sharing scans, consider their contents and any rights belonging to others.

What should I consider if several people save scans on a shared desk?

Check who has access to the computer or storage folder before sharing scans. The Dutch Data Protection Authority advises organisations to check documents for personal data before publishing or sharing them; this guidance for organisations is not a general ban on scanning recipes.