Who is this choice relevant to?

Preserving fragile clippings

You want to place thin or damaged pieces individually on a flatbed, without feeding them through a document feeder. Canon and HP describe their flatbed scanners as suitable for scanning pieces like these one at a time.

Building a searchable clipping archive

You want to be able to find scanned text later, and are considering the software and the manual work involved. Epson lists a searchable PDF feature for the Perfection V39II.

A studio with different formats and users

You need to check whether any clippings are larger than A4 and agree clear rules for accessing stored files. Epson also describes flatbeds with an A3 scanning area; the Dutch Data Protection Authority provides guidance on access to personal data.

What should you look for when buying?

Measure your largest clipping before choosing a model. Then consider text recognition and how the scanner and files will be used in the studio.

Consideration What should you check? Who is this important to?
Fragile paper Check that the device has a flatbed and that you can place clippings individually on the glass. If I’m preserving thin or damaged clippings, I want to place them on the glass one at a time rather than feed them through a feeder. Around 40% of consumers prioritise preserving paper.
Searchable text Check whether the software creates searchable PDF files and test text recognition with one of your own clippings. I want to find articles by text later, so I first check how my own newspaper material is recognised. Around 30% of consumers prioritise searchability.
Full scanning area Measure the length and width of your largest clipping and compare both measurements with the scanning area of the exact model. If a clipping is larger than A4, I want to capture it in full without scanning it in sections. Around 20% of consumers prioritise a full-size scanning area.
Shared workflow Check the connections and software for the computers you use, and agree where files will be stored and who can access them. In a shared studio, I want to know which computer can scan and who is allowed to open stored files. Around 10% of consumers prioritise a shared workflow.

Points to consider when choosing

  • The scanner’s external dimensions don’t tell you the size of its scanning area

    Canon specifies a maximum scanning size of 216 × 297 mm for the CanoScan LiDE 400. This means a larger clipping won’t fit in a single full A4 scan.

    Measure your largest clipping and compare both its length and width with the model’s scanning area.

    A larger clipping may mean extra work if you need to scan it in sections and join the scans afterwards.

  • The document feeder’s speed doesn’t apply to flatbed scans

    The speed quoted by HP applies to the ScanJet Pro 2600 f1’s automatic document feeder, not to placing fragile clippings on the flatbed one at a time.

    Consider the flatbed and automatic feeder as two different ways of working. Don’t use the feeder for fragile clippings just because of its quoted speed.

  • A searchable PDF doesn’t mean every word has been recognised correctly

    Epson lists a searchable PDF feature for the Perfection V39II, but that doesn’t guarantee it will recognise small or damaged newspaper lettering.

    Test text recognition with representative clippings and check the results before processing a large quantity of material.

    Allow time to review and correct recognised text if necessary.

  • A shared folder doesn’t automatically give you permission to reuse files

    The Dutch Government distinguishes between copies for personal use and distribution. Businesses and institutions must meet reprographic rights requirements for internal copying; a shared folder doesn’t cover those rights.

    Check what permission applies to your intended use and make separate arrangements for internal access and public distribution.

Relevant scanner brands

Canon

With the CanoScan LiDE 300 and LiDE 400, Canon offers compact A4 flatbeds for loose clippings.

  • Canon specifies a maximum glass size of 216 × 297 mm for the LiDE 400 and quotes around 8 seconds for an A4 colour scan at 300 dpi under its own test conditions.
  • Neither model has an A3 scanning area. The quoted scan time doesn’t include placing and changing clippings.

Epson

The Perfection V39II is an A4 flatbed option with text-file features, while the Expression range also includes a larger A3 option.

  • Epson lists standard USB power, text enhancement and a searchable PDF feature for the V39II.
  • These features aren’t an independent test of text recognition on old newspaper clippings. Epson lists the Expression 13000XL, with a scanning area of 310 × 437 mm, as discontinued.

HP

The ScanJet Pro 2600 f1 combines a flatbed for individual pieces with an automatic document feeder for suitable documents.

  • HP specifies a flatbed resolution of up to 1200 dpi and an automatic feeder that holds 60 pages.
  • HP’s quoted speed of 25 pages per minute applies to the automatic feeder, not to fragile clippings on the glass.

Related products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

How do you get started scanning old clippings?

Carefully place a clipping on the glass and check the first scan for legibility and cropping. For photographs, the Library of Congress recommends using a slightly damp, lint-free cloth for cleaning and warns against spraying water directly onto the scanner. For fragile newspaper clippings, also follow the scanner manufacturer’s instructions.

How long does it take to scan a pile of clippings?

The total time is more than the quoted scan time, as you also need to place and process each clipping. Canon quotes around 8 seconds for an A4 colour scan at 300 dpi with the LiDE 400 under specific test conditions; this isn’t an estimate for scanning a whole pile.

Can you share scans of newspaper clippings inside or outside the studio?

Not automatically. The Dutch Government distinguishes between copies for personal use and distribution or making material available to the public. For businesses and institutions, it describes a reprographic rights scheme for internal copying under applicable conditions; this isn’t general permission to publish scans publicly. Check what permission applies to your intended use.

What if scans contain personal data?

If an organisation processes personal data, the Dutch Data Protection Authority says it must prevent unauthorised access and must not keep personal data for longer than necessary. Decide who can open the files and how long they need to be kept, taking the content and use of the scans into account.