Who is this buying guide for?

Teachers with individual clippings

You want to place individual pieces on the glass and save them. Measure your largest clipping to see whether A4 is big enough; Canon and Plustek specify different maximum scanning areas for the models mentioned here.

Teachers with limited workspace

You want to know in advance how much space the scanner will take up and what type of power connection it needs. The stated dimensions and power supplies differ between Canon and Epson’s A4 models and Plustek’s A3 scanner.

Creating searchable teaching materials

You want to find articles by searching for text later, so you need to consider the PDF and OCR process as well as the scanning area. Epson describes the Perfection V39II as having a searchable PDF function.

What should you look for when choosing?

First, measure the largest clipping you want to scan in one go. Then consider whether you need a compact scanner for a small workspace, a larger scanning area or searchable text.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Placing individual clippings Check that the model has a glass platen and that you can position the clipping on it. If I want to place loose, potentially delicate clippings carefully, the glass platen matters to me. Around 36% of consumers prioritise being able to position items carefully.
Workspace and power Measure the available space and check the external dimensions and power supply. If space is limited, I want to know in advance whether the scanner will fit on my desk and what connection it needs. Around 29% of consumers give limited workspace top priority.
Scanning area size Measure both sides of your largest clipping and compare them with the maximum scanning area. If I want to capture larger pieces in a single scan, the scanning area needs to be large enough. Around 21% of consumers prioritise a larger scanning area.
Finding text later Check whether the software can create a searchable PDF and works with the school computer. If I want to find articles by searching for words later, I need a suitable OCR process as well as a scan. Around 14% of consumers make searchable text their top priority.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming A4 will scan any clipping in one go

    A piece that’s larger than the scanning area won’t fit in one go. You’ll need to scan it in sections or choose a different approach.

    Measure your largest clipping and compare both sides with the stated scanning area.

    Scanning in sections takes extra time and effort.

  • Confusing a high dpi rating with searchable text

    Resolution and OCR are different features. An image scan doesn’t automatically become a PDF that you can search for words in.

    Check the OCR feature on the exact model and test it with a scan of the newspaper material you plan to use.

    If the OCR doesn’t suit your workflow, you may need to use extra software or spend time correcting the results.

  • Measuring only the scanning area

    The casing and the power supply required also determine whether a scanner is practical in a small workspace. The Plustek A3 scanner mentioned here has a separate mains power supply.

    As well as the paper size, check the external dimensions, operating position and connections.

  • Assuming that scanning automatically gives you permission to share clippings

    Auteursrechtnl explains the conditions for using protected material in education. Internal use and sharing outside the institution aren’t necessarily covered by the same rules.

    Before sharing, check which educational or licensing rules apply to your institution and intended use. Stichting Reprorecht’s guidance on the scheme for AOC's and mbo applies specifically to those institutions.

Brands to compare

Canon

Canon describes the CanoScan LiDE 300 and LiDE 400 as A4 flatbed scanners for individual documents and clippings measuring up to 216 × 297 mm.

  • Canon states that both models are USB-powered. The LiDE 400 has five scan buttons, while the LiDE 300 has four.
  • Canon’s stated A4 colour scan times at 300 dpi are around 8 seconds for the LiDE 400 and around 10 seconds for the LiDE 300 under Canon’s test conditions. These figures aren’t from an independent speed test, and neither model has an A3 scanning area.

Epson

Epson describes the Perfection V39II as a compact A4 flatbed scanner with a searchable PDF function. The WorkForce DS-1730 combines a glass platen with a document feeder.

  • Epson states that the V39II is USB-powered and has an integrated stand. For the DS-1730, Epson specifies 1200 dpi from the glass platen and 600 dpi via the feeder.
  • The document feeder is only relevant for documents you want to feed through it. The stated features alone don’t tell you anything about OCR accuracy.

Plustek

Plustek describes the OpticSlim 1180 as an A3 flatbed scanner for pieces that won’t fit within an A4 scanning area.

  • Plustek specifies a maximum scanning area of 297 × 431,8 mm and states that OCR software for Windows and Mac is included.
  • The stated dimensions are 589 × 407 × 68 mm and the weight is 4,32 kg. The scanner uses a separate mains power supply, so make sure you have enough workspace and a nearby socket.

Joybuy products

This selection focuses on A4 flatbed scanning for individual clippings that fit on the glass platen.

Epson WorkForce DS-1660W A4 flatbed scanner

Epson WorkForce DS-1660W A4 flatbed scanner

Suitable for scanning individual clippings that fit on an A4 glass platen.

The product name specifies A4, 1200 × 1200 DPI and black and white.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How can I tell whether A4 is large enough?

Measure both sides of the largest piece you want to save in a single scan. According to Canon, the CanoScan LiDE 400 has a maximum scanning area of 216 × 297 mm; according to Plustek, the OpticSlim 1180 has a maximum area of 297 × 431,8 mm. If a piece doesn’t fit, you’ll need to scan it in sections or choose a different approach.

Does a higher dpi rating make a scan searchable?

No. Resolution and OCR are different features. Check whether the exact model can create a searchable PDF on the school computer, then test text recognition using a scan of your own newspaper material.

What should I check before connecting it to the school computer?

Check the ports, cables and power supply you’ll need, along with support for the school computer’s operating system. According to Canon, the LiDE 400 is USB-powered; according to Plustek, the OpticSlim 1180 has a separate mains power supply.

Can I share a scanned newspaper clipping with pupils?

Not automatically: Auteursrechtnl describes an educational exception that applies under certain conditions, including using material to explain or supplement something rather than replace it; a fair fee may be payable for reproductions. The applicable rules depend on the institution and how you share the material. Stichting Reprorecht’s guidance on internal use specifically concerns AOC's and mbo.

What should I check before putting the original clipping away?

Check that the text and edges have been captured in full. If you’ve created a searchable PDF, test a few words from the clipping. The function described by Epson doesn’t guarantee that every word in a newspaper will be recognised correctly.