Keeper of handwritten notes
Wants to keep loose or bound notes legible, and understands the difference between a good scan and automatically recognised text. The KB identifies image quality as a factor in OCR.
For loose A4 notes that you scan one at a time, a compact flatbed scanner is a sensible starting point. If you regularly scan batches, a model with an automatic document feeder can cut down on manual loading. For bound notes or larger sheets, the book edge and scanning area are key. A high dpi rating doesn’t guarantee that handwriting will be searchable automatically, so test a scan using your own minutes.
Wants to keep loose or bound notes legible, and understands the difference between a good scan and automatically recognised text. The KB identifies image quality as a factor in OCR.
Regularly processes loose sheets and wants to work out whether placing each sheet on the glass by hand is practical.
Has bound or larger documents as well as A4 sheets, so pays attention to the book edge and the size of the scanning area.
Choose this when: the minutes are mostly loose sheets that fit within A4 and you can scan them one at a time.
Bear in mind: you’ll need to load each sheet individually; also check that the software is compatible with your group’s computer.
Choose this when: you regularly process batches of loose sheets, as well as individual originals that you want to place on the glass.
Bear in mind: the stated feed speed doesn’t automatically apply to scans made on the glass; HP specifies a 60-page feeder for the ScanJet Pro 2600 f1.
Choose this when: notes are often in a bound book and you need to capture text close to the spine.
Bear in mind: you’ll still need to turn the pages; Plustek specifies a 6 mm book edge for the OpticBook 3800L, but this doesn’t guarantee good results with every binding.
Choose this when: a sheet or spread won’t fit within A4 but can lie fully on the scanning area.
Bear in mind: measure the space on your desk too: Plustek specifies a scanning area of 297 × 431,8 mm and a body measuring 589 × 407 mm for the OpticSlim 1180.
| What to consider | What to look for | Who should pay particular attention? |
|---|---|---|
| Legible handwriting | Make a test scan using light pen, pencil or paper written on both sides; check the legibility and cropping. | If I’m archiving handwritten minutes, I want to check first that my own handwriting remains legible; around 31% of consumers put the legibility of handwriting first. |
| Batches of loose sheets | Consider how often you scan batches and check that the feeder is suitable for the documents and double-sided pages you use. | If I regularly scan batches, I want to spend less time loading sheets by hand; around 25% of consumers give processing loose batches top priority. |
| Bound notes | Check how the book sits on the glass and whether text near the spine falls within the scanning area. | If my minutes are in bound books, I want to capture text near the spine too; around 19% of consumers prioritise bound originals. |
| Finding text later | Check whether the software creates searchable files and separately test how it handles handwriting. | If I want to search for words in a digital archive later, I want to know what the software can recognise in my notes; around 13% of consumers give finding text top priority. |
| Large sheets or spreads | Measure the largest original in two directions and check the available desk space. | If an original is larger than A4, I want to capture its full size in a single scan; around 12% of consumers prioritise large originals. |
A scan creates an image file; OCR and handwriting recognition are software processes. The KB explains OCR, while the National Archives treats handwriting recognition as a specialist application.
Make a test scan of your own minutes and check whether you can find words that actually appear on the page.
Allow time for checking or manual transcription if recognition isn’t accurate enough.
The speed HP quotes for the ScanJet Pro 2600 f1 applies to the automatic document feeder at 300 dpi, not to manual scanning on the glass.
When choosing a scanner, distinguish between batches of suitable loose sheets and books, delicate documents and originals that need to be scanned on the glass.
An original will fit completely in one scan only if it falls within both dimensions of the scanning area. The scanner body will also take up space on your desk.
Measure both the largest original and the available desk space in two directions.
A storage feature doesn’t determine who can access the files or how long minutes are kept. The Dutch Data Protection Authority outlines requirements for securing, retaining and sharing personal data.
Decide who needs access and assess the storage and sharing settings in light of the contents and purpose of the minutes.
The CanoScan LiDE 400 is a compact A4 flatbed scanner for individual originals.
The Perfection V39II is an A4 model with a stand, designed for a compact workspace.
The ScanJet Pro 2600 f1 combines a flatbed with an automatic document feeder.
The OpticBook 3800L is designed for bound A4 material, while the OpticSlim 1180 has a larger scanning area.
These product choices are suited to A4 flatbed scanning and to combining a flatbed with an automatic document feeder.
Image unavailable
Suited to groups that process batches of loose sheets as well as individual originals; the product name specifies both a flatbed and an automatic document feeder.
A4; 600 × 600 dpi; black.
Image unavailable
Suited to individual A4 notes and bound originals; the product information describes a flatbed for books and bound documents.
A4; 1200 × 1200 dpi; black and white. Epson Netherlands lists the WorkForce DS-1660W as discontinued and no longer available; check the support and model specifications for your needs.
No, don’t assume it will. The KB describes OCR as converting a scan into computer-readable text and notes that image quality is a factor. The National Archives describes handwriting recognition as a specialist application, so test your own notes and allow for checking or transcription.
Check the drivers and manuals for the exact model and operating system. Canon provides model-specific downloads for the CanoScan LiDE 400; a listed set of operating systems doesn’t guarantee that every future version will work.
If the minutes contain personal data, the organisation must protect it appropriately and keep it only for as long as necessary for the purpose, according to the Dutch Data Protection Authority. There are conditions on sharing it with others; the appropriate measures and retention period depend on the contents and purpose.