Start by checking the negative formats and agreeing on the file type for delivery. If you only have compatible 35mm negatives and need editable scans, a computer-connected film scanner is likely to be the better choice. A standalone scanner may be more practical if it supports the formats you have and the output you need. The Consumentenbond emphasises that the amount of material, the quality you want and the time available all matter. Count the images and test the entire workflow, including checks and backups, before agreeing a handover date.
Who is this advice for?
Manager of mixed-format negatives
You want to find out first whether your collection includes 120, 110 or 126 film as well as 35mm. Check both the formats the scanner supports and the holders supplied with that version. Plustek and reflecta specify different format ranges.
Creator of editable archive scans
You want to be able to adjust details and tones later, and keep the agreed file type. The Library of Congress describes TIFF as a lossless format for later editing, so check that the scanner and software can actually produce the output you need.
Digitiser working to a handover date
You need to deliver a set number of images on time and want to know how much work automatic feeding saves compared with checking each frame individually. The Consumentenbond points out that the amount of material, the quality required and the time available all influence your choice.
What should you consider when choosing?
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Film formats and holders |
Take stock of the originals and check which formats and holders are supported and supplied with the exact model. |
If I have different formats, I want to be sure I can feed them into the scanner I choose. Around 31% of consumers give format compatibility top priority. |
| Editable archive file |
Agree the required delivery format and check that the scanner and software can save it. Also check whether a higher output resolution is interpolated. |
If you want to correct scans later, you’ll benefit from a suitable file format and checking workflow. Around 25% of consumers put an editable archive file first. |
| Turnaround time, including checks |
Count the strips and frames, make test scans, and allow time for corrections, file checks and a second copy. |
If I have a deadline to meet, I want to allow for preparation and checks as well as scanning time. Around 25% of consumers cite timely processing as their top priority. |
| Total project requirements |
Check whether you need extra holders, software, a computer or storage media, and compare those requirements with the agreed delivery. |
If you’re doing a one-off project, you’ll want to know in advance what equipment, time and storage your chosen approach will require. Around 19% of consumers put the overall project requirements first. |
Common mistakes
-
Choosing a scanner before checking your film formats
A 35mm model won’t automatically handle other formats. With a mixed collection, a missing or optional holder may mean that some originals need to be scanned another way.
Compare a few representative strips with the format list for the exact model and check which holders are included in the box.
If a holder you need isn’t included with the scanner, you may have to arrange a second scanning method for some of the material.
-
Treating a quick JPEG scan as your archive master
A file that’s suitable for viewing or sharing won’t necessarily meet the requirements for an editable archive file later on. The Library of Congress describes TIFF as lossless for later editing.
Agree the required file format in advance and test with a sample scan that the complete workflow produces it.
If the agreed output isn’t created, you may need to scan again. Make sure you also allow enough storage space for the files.
-
Expecting infrared correction to work on traditional black-and-white negatives
LaserSoft Imaging warns that infrared-based dust and scratch correction can cause artefacts with silver-based black-and-white film.
Check what type of film you have and test the correction on a sample image. Don’t rely on infrared as your only approach for this type of negative.
Allow for the possibility that you may need to remove dirt manually or correct it using software.
-
Forgetting a required memory card or a second copy
Kodak Photo Plus states that the Kodak Slide N Scan Max RODFS70 requires an SD card, which isn’t included. One card also doesn’t count as a separate backup.
Check what’s included, create test files and keep verified copies on separate storage media. The Library of Congress recommends using multiple storage media in different locations.
Allow for suitable storage media for both the scan and a separate backup.
Relevant brands for reference
Plustek
The OpticFilm 8200i SE is a computer-connected scanner for 35mm negatives and mounted slides, suited to anyone who wants to adjust their scans.
- Plustek specifies 7,200 dpi and an infrared channel. These are manufacturer specifications, not an independent measurement of usable image detail.
- The model is designed for 35mm and doesn’t support 120 film. LaserSoft Imaging warns that infrared correction isn’t suitable for traditional silver-based black-and-white negatives.
reflecta
The RPS 10S is designed for automatic processing of 35mm strips, while the x66-Scan offers a standalone option for, among others, the 35mm and 120 formats listed by reflecta.
- reflecta specifies automatic feeding of strips containing 3 to 40 frames for the RPS 10S. The x66-Scan saves JPEG files to SD.
- According to reflecta, the x66-Scan has a 14MP sensor; its 22MP output is interpolated. reflecta lists an optional holder for 126 film.
Kodak Photo Plus
The European Slide N Scan Max RODFS70 is a standalone option for the 135, 110 and 126 negatives listed on the product page.
- Kodak Photo Plus lists a 7-inch screen and SD storage.
- According to Kodak Photo Plus, an SD card is required but isn’t included. Check the specifications for the exact version.
Rollei
The DF-S 310 SE is a standalone scanner for selecting slides and negative strips. Rollei also lists a 110 insert as included.
- Rollei specifies SD and SDHC storage up to 32 GB and a capture resolution of 14 MP.
- The listed 24MP mode is interpolated. The slide-scanning speed quoted by Rollei isn’t the processing time for a complete collection of negatives.
Epson
The Perfection V600 Photo is a flatbed scanner that Epson specifies for 35mm and 120/220 film, among other formats. It may be worth considering if you’re assessing existing or second-hand equipment.
- Epson lists support for a range of film formats, including 35mm and 120/220.
- Epson states that the V600 Photo has been discontinued in the Netherlands and is no longer available through its product page. If buying second-hand, check the holders and software.
Joybuy products for this project
Related products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
Does a higher megapixel count automatically mean more detail from the original?
No. A higher output count alone doesn’t prove that more detail has been captured from the original. reflecta specifies a 14MP sensor for the x66-Scan and an interpolated output of 22 MP. So assess test scans and the scanner’s native capture capability, not just its highest output figure.
Is one SD card enough to store my scans?
Don’t store your files on just one SD card. The Library of Congress recommends keeping copies on at least two different storage media and in separate locations. Open and check the files before handing them over, too.
How should I handle family negatives before scanning?
Work with clean hands or gloves, on a clean surface. The US National Archives gives this as a preservation guideline because fingerprints can cause permanent marks; it isn’t a legal requirement in the Netherlands.
What warranty applies to a scanner I buy in the Netherlands?
If you buy as a consumer, the seller must provide a product that meets reasonable expectations, according to ACM ConsuWijzer. This doesn’t automatically mean a fixed two-year warranty. For a business purchase, check the applicable terms and conditions separately.
Can I hand over recognisable family portraits to a client without further consideration?
Buying a scanner doesn’t give you that right. The Dutch Data Protection Authority distinguishes between strictly personal or household use and business use of identifiable images; the household exemption doesn’t apply to business use. For the specific project, establish the roles, legal basis and permitted transfer. If one party processes personal data solely on behalf of a controller, the Dutch Data Protection Authority sets out the matters that must be covered in a data processing agreement.