Which option is right for you?

Team processing lots of 35mm strips

If you often process several frames one after another, automatic feeding can reduce the number of manual steps. Plustek says the OpticFilm 135i can process six frames from one strip per batch; reflecta describes the RPS 10S as offering automatic transport for strips of 3 to 40 frames.

Manager of a mixed-format film archive

If you have 120 film as well as 35mm, check the formats and film holders supported by each model. Epson lists holders for formats including 35mm and 120/220 film for the Perfection V850 Pro.

Editor of individual colour frames

If you want to check colour negatives frame by frame, look at the scanning software included and the options for editing your scans. Plustek lists an infrared channel and SilverFast SE Plus as included with the OpticFilm 8200i SE.

What should you look for when choosing?

Automatic feed for 35mm

A good fit if: you repeatedly process several frames from 35mm strips on a shared workstation.

Consider: automatic feeding alone tells you nothing about total scanning time or image quality; check the holder and output options too.

Manual film scanner for 35mm

A good fit if: you want to adjust and edit individual 35mm colour negatives; Plustek supplies the OpticFilm 8200i SE with SilverFast SE Plus.

Consider: check software compatibility and, if you plan to use it on several computers, the licence terms.

Flatbed scanner with film holder

A good fit if: you want to process 120/220 film or prints as well as 35mm; Epson lists holders for this purpose with the Perfection V850 Pro.

Consider: Epson lists the V850 Pro and V600 Photo as discontinued on its Dutch product pages, so don’t treat them as confirmed new purchases.

Standalone device with SD card

A good fit if: you prefer to save scans to a memory card first; reflecta lists JPEG output to SD for the x66-Scan.

Consider: files will then need to be transferred to the shared archive; this is a different workflow from scanning directly to a computer.

Consideration What should you check? Who is this important for?
Throughput for shared use Check that the holder fits your 35mm strips, how many frames are processed per feed and how files are named. If we process lots of 35mm frames one after another at a single workstation, we want fewer manual feeding steps; around 36% of consumers prioritise throughput.
Colour and editing Check the output format, suitable scanning software and whether the shared system supports that software. If I want to check and edit colour negatives frame by frame, I look at the scanning and software options; around 29% of consumers prioritise control over editing.
Film formats and holders Take stock of the negatives you have and check the formats supported by each model and which holders you need. If my archive contains different film formats, I want to know in advance what will actually fit in the scanner; around 21% of consumers prioritise format compatibility.
File transfer Agree where scans will be saved and check computer compatibility and licence terms for simultaneous use. If several people manage scans in one place, I want to know how files will get from the scanner into the shared archive; around 14% of consumers prioritise easy transfer.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming a high stated dpi means a better scan

    Manufacturers’ specifications for different models are not an independent comparison of the detail captured.

    Start by comparing film formats, holders, workflows and the output you need. Don’t rank image quality based on a dpi figure alone.

    A higher dpi figure can mean larger files and more processing; it doesn’t automatically mean better results for your negatives.

  • Assuming every film scanner supports 120 film

    The Plustek film scanners in this comparison are designed for 35mm; the reflecta x66-Scan also lists specific 120 formats.

    Check which film formats you have and, for the exact model, confirm both the supported dimensions and the holders required.

  • Overlooking software and file management for shared use

    A scanner that saves JPEG files to SD doesn’t save them directly to the shared computer. LaserSoft Imaging says that one SilverFast 9 licence allows use on only one computer at a time.

    Agree how files will be transferred and stored, and check the licence and operating system before choosing a model.

    When scans are saved to SD, someone will need to transfer and name the files, then store them in the shared archive.

  • Mistaking an old product page for confirmation that a product is currently available new

    Epson lists the V600 Photo and V850 Pro as discontinued on its Dutch product pages. The European product page for the KODAK SCANZA says the model is currently unavailable.

    If you find a specific offer, check that the device, film holders and usable software are actually included.

Brands and models to consider

Plustek

The OpticFilm 135i and 8200i SE offer two options for 35mm: batch processing of strips, or a dedicated film scanner supplied with software.

  • Plustek says the 135i can process six frames per 35mm strip in a batch.
  • The models mentioned are designed for 35mm; batch specifications are not an independent comparison of scanning time or quality.

reflecta

The RPS 10S is a computer-connected scanner with automatic strip transport; the x66-Scan is a standalone option for formats including 35mm and certain 120 formats.

  • According to reflecta, the RPS 10S processes strips of 3 to 40 frames; the x66-Scan saves JPEG files to SD.
  • The SD option doesn’t save scans directly to the shared workstation.

Epson

The Perfection V850 Pro and V600 Photo are flatbed scanners with film-scanning features.

  • Epson lists holders for formats including 35mm and 120/220 film, as well as TIFF output, for the V850 Pro.
  • Epson lists the V850 Pro and V600 Photo as discontinued on its Dutch product pages.

KODAK Photo Plus

The SCANZA is a standalone scanning option with JPEG output for a range of smaller film formats.

  • The European product page lists formats including 35mm, 126 and 110 film.
  • The same page says the model is currently unavailable and that it doesn’t support other film formats.

Related products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Does a scanner need to be connected to the shared computer?

Not always. According to reflecta, the x66-Scan saves JPEG files to an SD card, while the RPS 10S is a computer-connected scanner. Decide in advance where files will be transferred to and managed.

Can one SilverFast 9 licence be used on several workstations at the same time?

No. Software maker LaserSoft Imaging says one licence allows use on only one computer at a time. You can install the software on several workstations, but simultaneous use on different computers requires additional licences. Several users sharing the same workstation is not the same as using the software on several computers at once.

Does infrared dust correction work on colour negatives?

LaserSoft Imaging describes its iSRD infrared feature for colour negatives, provided the scanner has a suitable infrared channel. The company says the technology doesn’t work with conventional silver-based black-and-white film, so check the film type and whether the software you choose supports the feature.

What costs and rights should I consider when buying?

Check whether the film holders you need and usable software are included; additional licences may be required to use SilverFast on several computers at the same time. If your purchase qualifies as a Dutch consumer purchase, your statutory guarantee applies alongside any manufacturer’s warranty. According to ACM ConsuWijzer, the length of the guarantee depends on what you can reasonably expect from the product. For online purchases, you generally have 14 days from delivery to change your mind, subject to statutory exceptions.

Can a shared workstation store and share scans of identifiable people?

This depends, among other things, on who manages the scans and how they are used. The Dutch Data Protection Authority distinguishes between strictly personal or household use and wider distribution or business use; the household exemption does not automatically apply to an organisation or public publication.