Which scanner is right for you?

Studio using both 35mm and 120 film

Check that both formats are supported by the scanning area and the supplied or compatible holders. Plustek states that the OpticFilm 120 supports 35mm and 120/220 film, from 6 × 4.5 to 6 × 12 cm.

Studio with lots of 35mm strips

If you’re processing a series of frames, compare automatic feeding with scanning by hand. reflecta states that the RPS 10S offers automatic feeding for 3 to 40 frames on 35mm film strips.

Studio that retouches black-and-white files

If you want to assess tone and dust correction yourself, take the film emulsion and the chosen correction method into account. LaserSoft Imaging describes infrared correction as unsuitable for traditional silver-based black-and-white film.

What should you look for when buying?

First, list all the film formats used in the studio. Then work out how many consecutive scans you need, before choosing the level of software-based retouching you want.

What to consider What should you look for when buying? Who should prioritise this?
Supported film formats List your 35mm, 120 and any 110 or 126 film. Check both the holders and the scanning area for the exact model. If we use both 35mm and 120 film in the studio, I want to make sure neither format is left out of the workflow. Around 31% of consumers prioritise support for multiple film formats.
Feeding when scanning lots of frames Check which strip lengths and holders are compatible, and what steps are needed between consecutive scans. When scanning lots of 35mm strips, I want to reduce the manual work per frame and make it easy for users to hand over to each other. Around 31% of consumers give top priority to feeding when scanning repeatedly.
Black-and-white retouching Check which dust correction method is suitable for your film emulsion, and review a test scan for detail before processing a whole batch. If I want to check tone and dust correction carefully, the chosen method needs to suit traditional black-and-white film. Around 23% of consumers prioritise retouching black-and-white files.
Operation and storage Check the screen and file output, the storage media required, and whether the chosen workflow needs scanner software on a computer. If different studio members want to scan without having to install software each time, ease of use is important. Around 15% of consumers say independent, accessible scanning is their main consideration.

Things to consider when buying

  • Assuming infrared correction works for every type of black-and-white film

    Infrared correction doesn’t work in the same way with traditional silver-based black-and-white emulsion as it does with compatible film.

    Check which emulsion the studio uses, and compare suitable software correction with an unedited scan.

    Allow time to clean negatives and carry out any separate retouching that may be needed.

  • Choosing a scanner based only on the term ‘film scanner’

    A model with a scanning area for 35mm film won’t replace a scanner that can handle 120 film as a full frame.

    Compare the studio’s film formats with the scanning area and holders for the exact model.

  • Confusing megapixel output with captured detail

    A higher output resolution doesn’t automatically mean that more detail has been captured from the negative. For the 7-inch KODAK Slide N SCAN Max, the retailer distinguishes between a 13 MP sensor and an option for 22 MP output.

    Compare test files and workflows for your intended use, and don’t treat output resolution as proof of increased optical detail.

  • Overlooking the accessories and software needed for a shared workflow

    The standalone KODAK model mentioned requires an SD card, which the retailer says isn’t included. For computer-connected models, you’ll also need to consider software and computer compatibility.

    Check what’s in the box, storage requirements, licence terms and compatibility with the computer used by the studio.

    Depending on the model you choose, the studio may also need a suitable SD card or software licence.

Brands to compare

Plustek

A useful option to compare for studios looking for a dedicated film-scanning setup, with models designed for different formats.

  • Plustek states that the OpticFilm 120 supports 35mm and 120/220 film, with a motorised holder feed.
  • The OpticFilm 8200i SE is a 35mm option. The specifications consulted are from Plustek’s US product page, so check the UK model, software and what’s included. Infrared correction isn’t an advantage for traditional silver-based black-and-white film.

reflecta

The RPS 10S is a computer-connected option to compare for studios processing lots of 35mm film strips.

  • reflecta states that it offers automatic feeding for 3 to 40 frames and DNG output.
  • The stated scanning area is up to 24,3 × 36,5 mm and doesn’t cover 120 frames. The listed infrared correction isn’t suitable for traditional silver-based black-and-white film.

KODAK Photo Plus

The European 7-inch Slide N SCAN Max is a standalone option for 135, 110 and 126 negatives, among others.

  • According to the retailer, you can operate the device without installing scanner software.
  • An SD card is required but not included. The stated 22 MP output isn’t the same as confirmation of the sensor’s detail, and don’t confuse this model with the separate 5-inch version.

Epson

The Perfection V600 Photo and V850 Pro are examples of flatbed scanners with holders for 35mm and 120 film.

  • Epson Netherlands lists film formats and TIFF output for both models.
  • Epson Netherlands marks both models as discontinued and no longer available from Epson; this doesn’t confirm current new stock.

Joybuy products for this topic

Related products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can I rely on infrared dust removal for traditional black-and-white negatives?

No, not as a general solution: the emulsion in traditional silver-based black-and-white film interferes with the infrared method. Consider cleaning and any software-based correction separately, and check that the correction preserves detail in the image.

What should you record when setting up a shared studio?

For each user, note which film holder, computer, software licence and output settings are part of the workflow, and where scans are stored. Check the requirements for the exact device and studio computer; reflecta, for example, publishes separate Windows and macOS requirements for the RPS 10S.

What maintenance routine helps with dust on black-and-white scans?

Keep negatives and holders clean, and review a test scan before processing a whole batch. For traditional black-and-white film, infrared correction is no substitute for checking for dust.

Who can help if a device is faulty, and does consumer law apply if the studio buys it for business use?

For a consumer purchase, ACM ConsuWijzer says the seller is responsible for resolving the issue if the product doesn’t perform as you could reasonably expect under normal use. Don’t assume this automatically applies to a business purchase on behalf of the studio: decide in advance who the contracting party is and read the terms that apply to that purchase.

Can studio members share or publish scans of other people’s photos online?

According to the Dutch government, making a copy for personal use doesn’t automatically give you permission to distribute or publish copyright-protected photos. Privacy rules may also apply if people can be recognised; the Dutch Data Protection Authority points out that personal data can’t simply be published online without permission. Consider the rights and intended use of each photo.