Who is this guide for?

Groups with mixed film formats

You may have portraits in different film formats and want to avoid choosing a 35mm holder that won’t accommodate larger negatives.

Volunteers with lots of images to scan

You want to sort through images together and keep an eye on the work involved and the time needed for each scan.

Those managing an editable archive

You want to be able to edit files later and handle originals with care, including when other volunteers take over the work.

What should you look for when choosing?

First, identify the formats in your collection. Then choose between standalone JPEG scanning and a computer-based workflow that gives you files for further editing.

What to consider What to look for Who should pay particular attention?
Film format and holder Check which film formats are supported and the exact image sizes that fit in the holder supplied. If our collection might include larger negatives, I want to know which holders will actually fit them. Around 29% of consumers put format compatibility first.
Workflow and operation Look at the whole process, from loading and checking images to naming and saving files. A short scan time isn’t the same as a short overall processing time. When volunteers are handling lots of images together, an easy workflow makes a big difference. Around 24% of consumers prioritise throughput and ease of use.
Files and post-processing Check whether the scanner outputs JPEG or TIFF, and only compare resolutions when they’re measured on the same basis. If we want to correct or reuse scans later, the output file matters more than simply being able to sort through images quickly. Around 23% of consumers put editable archive files first.
Project costs and support Check computer and software requirements, the holders and storage media supplied, and compare scanning yourself with getting a quote for the collection. When we’re weighing up equipment and volunteer time against outsourcing, I want to know the full workflow and what we’ll need. Around 12% of consumers put project costs first.
Preservation and portrait management Assess the condition of fragile originals before loading them, and agree where scans will be stored and who will have access. If we’re handling fragile film and identifiable portraits, I want to make sure they’re handled carefully and access is managed properly. Around 12% of consumers put preservation and management first.

Common buying pitfalls

  • Assuming every medium-format scanner can handle all 120 film

    Supported image sizes vary by model: the reflecta x66-Scan lists support up to 6 × 9 cm, while the Plustek OpticFilm 120 Pro lists support up to 6 × 12 cm.

    Measure the largest images in your collection and check that the exact scanner and holder can handle them before you buy.

    An unsuitable model could mean your group needs a second scanning workflow for larger negatives.

  • Comparing interpolated megapixels with sensor measurements

    reflecta lists 14 MP and 22 MP as interpolated output for the reflecta x66-Scan; these aren’t equivalent measurements.

    Compare resolutions on the same basis and assess a test scan for your intended use.

  • Treating a discontinued flatbed model as a readily available new product

    Epson lists the Perfection V600 Photo as discontinued. If you buy one second-hand, the holders, software and connection can all affect how useful it is.

    Check the condition and everything included with the specific unit, and make sure its software works with the group’s computer.

    A second-hand unit may be missing film holders or compatible software.

  • Assuming that digitising portraits means you have permission to publish them

    Scanning and sharing images publicly are two different things. Identifiable portraits can raise questions about personal data, copyright and portrait rights.

    Keep internal digitisation separate from publication, and check the rights and legal basis for the specific images before making them public.

Relevant brands to consider

reflecta

The x44-Scan is designed for 35mm film; according to reflecta, the x66-Scan supports 35mm and 120 film within the specified image sizes.

  • reflecta lists JPEG storage on an SD card for both models.
  • For the x66-Scan, reflecta lists 120 formats from 6 × 4.5 to 6 × 9 cm.
  • The x66-Scan’s stated 22 MP is interpolated; reflecta also lists a 14 MP sensor. The x44-Scan is designed for 35mm film.

Plustek

The OpticFilm 8300i SE is designed for 35mm scanning with a computer-based workflow; according to Plustek, the OpticFilm 120 Pro supports 35mm and 120 film up to 6 × 12 cm.

  • Plustek lists TIFF output for the OpticFilm 120 Pro.
  • The OpticFilm 120 Pro requires a computer; check the system requirements for the computer your group plans to use.
  • An infrared channel won’t help with dust removal on traditional silver-based black-and-white film.

Epson

The Perfection V600 Photo is an example of a flatbed scanner that can handle prints, 35mm film and supported 120/220 film.

  • Epson lists film holders and TIFF output for the V600 Photo.
  • Epson marks this model as discontinued. If you’re considering a second-hand unit, check the holders, software and connection.

KODAK Photo Plus

According to the product information, the Slide N Scan is designed for viewing and scanning 135, 110 and 126 film without a computer.

  • The product information lists a 5-inch screen and JPEG storage on an SD card.
  • The stated 22 MP is interpolated; the product information also lists a 14 MP sensor.

Joybuy products

Related products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

Where should you start if you don’t know the film format?

First, sort a small sample by the physical size of the film, then check the formats and holders supported by each scanner. A scanner for 35mm film isn’t automatically suitable for 120 film.

Does every volunteer need to scan images using a computer?

No, it depends on the scanner. reflecta says the x44-Scan and x66-Scan can save JPEG files to an SD card without a computer; the manufacturer lists computer requirements for the Plustek OpticFilm 120 Pro. Agree in advance who will transfer and name the files.

Does infrared correction remove dust from old black-and-white portraits?

Not from traditional silver-based black-and-white film: according to SilverFast, infrared correction doesn’t work on it in the same way as it does on colour film. Check the film type and allow for careful cleaning and any manual or software-based post-processing that may be needed.

What should the group compare with outsourcing?

Ask for a quote that clearly sets out the film format, resolution, file type, processing and any corrections included. Compare that workflow with the time and equipment the group would need to scan and manage the files itself.

Can the group simply put identifiable old portraits online?

No, the age of a photo doesn’t by itself give you permission to publish it. The Dutch Data Protection Authority points out that identifiable living people are personal data, and publication may require an appropriate legal basis under the GDPR. Copyright and portrait rights may also apply, so assess the photographer, the person pictured and the intended use for each image.