Which scanner is right for you?

Scanning on a small desk

If you mainly have 35mm negatives and don’t want a computer next to your scanner, a standalone scanner with SD storage is one option. reflecta describes the x33-Scan as a standalone device.

Digitising portraits with care

A computer-connected 35mm film scanner could suit you if you want more control over your scans and don’t mind using software. Infrared dust removal isn’t necessarily suitable for traditional black-and-white film, as LaserSoft Imaging explains.

Preserving different film formats

If you have other originals as well as 35mm film, start by identifying their formats. reflecta lists a separate adapter set for 110/126 film; Epson specifies support for 120/220 film for the V600.

What should you look for when choosing?

First, identify whether you have negatives, slides or prints, and check the film format. Then choose a standalone scanner, a computer-connected model or a flatbed, depending on the space you have and how much control you want over your scans.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this for?
Desk space and standalone scanning Check the scanner’s dimensions, the space needed around the film holder, the storage medium and the included power supply. If I have little desk space and want to scan without a computer, a standalone workflow matters most to me. Around 31% of consumers prioritise desk space and standalone scanning.
Detail and adjustments Compare the sensor or optical specifications with the output resolution; also check the film type and software compatibility. If I want to edit portraits carefully, control matters more to me than a simple workflow. Around 31% of consumers prioritise scan detail and editing control.
Original format Check whether you have 35mm, 110, 126 or 120/220 film, and make sure the holder for that format is included with the model. If I have different film formats, I want to know before buying whether the holders will fit my originals. Around 23% of consumers prioritise format compatibility.
Scanning time and effort Count the images, decide which file format you need and compare the steps involved in scanning them yourself with what a digitisation service offers. If I have a lot of images, I want to consider how much time cleaning, adjusting and organising the files will take. Around 15% of consumers prioritise time and effort.

How to avoid common buying mistakes

  • Mistaking a high interpolated resolution for extra captured detail

    For the Slide N Scan, KODAK lists a 14 MP sensor and 22 MP output with interpolation. These figures describe different things.

    Compare the sensor, optical and output specifications separately, and choose based on what you want to do with your scans.

  • Assuming a 35mm holder supports every film format

    The holders supplied with the reflecta x33-Scan are for 35mm film; reflecta lists a separate adapter set for 110/126. A holder for 35mm film doesn’t automatically mean that medium-format film will fit too.

    Check an original to identify its format, then confirm the matching holder and what’s included in the box before choosing.

  • Assuming infrared dust removal works on every black-and-white negative

    According to LaserSoft Imaging, infrared light does not pass through the silver-based emulsion of traditional black-and-white film in the way required.

    Check what type of film you have. For traditional black-and-white film, be prepared to use a different method for removing imperfections.

  • Assuming an older flatbed model is readily available new

    Epson Netherlands lists the Perfection V600 Photo as discontinued.

    If you’re considering old stock or a second-hand model, check its condition, film holders, software support and how much space it takes up.

Brands and models to consider

reflecta

The x33-Scan is a standalone option for 35mm negatives and slides if you don’t want a computer on your desk while you scan.

  • According to reflecta, the x33-Scan saves JPEG files directly to an SD card and comes with 35mm holders.
  • reflecta lists a separate adapter set for 110/126 film. Check that it’s compatible with the model you’re considering.

Plustek

The OpticFilm 8200i SE is designed for scanning 35mm film and slides using a computer and software.

  • Plustek lists an infrared channel and SilverFast software for this model.
  • LaserSoft Imaging says the infrared method is not suitable for traditional black-and-white film with a silver-based emulsion. Also check that the software is compatible with your computer.

Kodak Photo Plus

The Slide N Scan with its 5-inch screen is a standalone option for collections containing different small film formats.

  • The manufacturer lists adapters for 135, 110 and 126 film, as well as a 14 MP sensor.
  • The stated 22 MP output is interpolated. Cameranu says an SD card is required; check which accessories are included with the specific model.

Epson

The Perfection V600 Photo shows when a flatbed with a transparency unit could be useful, for example for 35mm and 120/220 film.

  • Epson lists film holders and dimensions of 280 × 485 × 118 mm.
  • Epson Netherlands lists the V600 as discontinued. Consider how much desk space it needs, and check the holders and software if you’re buying one.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can I use any negative scanner to scan old printed portraits too?

No. Film holders are designed for transparent film or slides. If you only have prints, look for a suitable photo scanner or flatbed, and decide whether you want to scan negatives, slides or printed photos before buying.

Do I need a computer or an SD card to scan?

It depends on the scanner. According to reflecta, the x33-Scan saves JPEG files directly to an SD card; Cameranu says an SD card is required for the Kodak Slide N Scan. For a computer-connected model, check that the software works with your computer.

How should I deal with dust on black-and-white portrait negatives?

Don’t assume that automatic infrared dust removal will work on traditional black-and-white film. According to LaserSoft Imaging, infrared light does not pass through the silver-based emulsion in the way required. Carefully remove dust from the originals and assess a test scan.

Can one scanner handle several old film formats?

Some models include holders for several formats, but that isn’t true of every scanner. The manufacturer lists adapters for 135, 110 and 126 film for the Kodak Slide N Scan; check that these holders are included with the model on offer and compare them with your originals.

Is scanning images yourself always faster than having them digitised?

No. The time required depends on factors such as how many images you have and how much editing you want to do. The Consumers’ Association points out that scanning images yourself also takes time for cleaning, colour correction and file management. Compare these steps with what a digitisation service offers for your collection.