Managing a mixed film collection
You have old portraits on more than one physical film format and want to make sure the holders and scanning range are suitable. Plustek and reflecta models show why it’s important to check support for each format.
Choose a film scanner based first on the physical film formats in your collection, then on the files you want to keep. Support for 35 mm does not automatically mean support for 120 film, and a JPEG-only model won’t suit you if you want a TIFF archive. Next, decide whether you want to scan without a computer or use a computer-connected model. Check the holders, output formats and software for the exact model.
You have old portraits on more than one physical film format and want to make sure the holders and scanning range are suitable. Plustek and reflecta models show why it’s important to check support for each format.
You want to be able to retouch portraits later, so as well as shareable files, you’re looking for an archive format such as TIFF that the model supports. Plustek lists TIFF and PSD for the OpticFilm 120 Pro.
You want to select and save images without a computer, and JPEG is an acceptable output format for you. reflecta and KODAK Photo Plus describe standalone models with JPEG output.
Start with the physical film formats in your collection. Then decide whether saving JPEGs without a computer is enough, or whether you also need editable output files.
| What to consider | What should you check? | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Film formats and holders | Compare each film format you own with the scanning range and compatible holder. Check whether the holder is included or available separately. | If I have portraits on different types of film, I want to know in advance whether they will all fit in the scanner. Around 33% of consumers prioritise compatibility with their film formats. |
| Output files | Check which file formats the exact model and its software support. | I want to be able to edit scans later, so I check whether TIFF or another format I need is available. Around 25% of consumers prioritise editable output files. |
| Scanning without a computer | Check whether you need a computer, which output format is saved, and which memory card and power supply are required. | If I want to scan without a computer and JPEG is good enough, a standalone workflow matters most to me. Around 25% of consumers prioritise this convenience. |
| Time needed for the whole collection | Count the images and make a test scan. If you’re using a scanning service, ask which film formats and files it provides. | I want to estimate in advance how long it will take to sort, scan and save my entire collection. Around 17% of consumers base their choice mainly on the time required to process their images. |
A scanner that offers several digital output formats won’t necessarily handle several physical film formats. Without a suitable holder and scanning range, some of your collection may not be usable with that model.
Check physical film types and digital output separately in the information for the exact model.
reflecta lists a 14MP sensor and a 22MP interpolated mode for the x66-Scan. These figures don’t describe the same thing.
Compare the stated sensor resolution with the interpolated output mode, and assess a test scan. Don’t base your choice on the highest figure alone.
Epson Netherlands lists the Perfection V600 Photo as discontinued. The specifications given therefore don’t confirm that you can buy the model new.
If you’re considering a used one, check the exact model, the film holders you need, and whether it works with your computer and software.
The OpticFilm 8200i SE is designed for 35 mm film, while Plustek says the OpticFilm 120 Pro is intended for 35 mm and 120 film.
The standalone x66-Scan and computer-connected RPS 10S offer different options: the first saves JPEGs, while reflecta lists DNG output for the RPS 10S.
According to the manufacturer, the SCANZA is a standalone scanner with JPEG output for certain film formats.
Epson says the Perfection V600 Photo can scan both paper originals and film.
It depends on the model and your computer. reflecta says the standalone x66-Scan saves JPEGs to an SD card without a computer. For a computer-connected scanner, check that the software supports your operating system, especially if you’re buying used equipment.
Start with a clean original and holder, then check a test scan. Plustek says the OpticFilm 8200i SE has an infrared channel that can detect dust and scratches on the original. Check the results with your own film, and don’t assume that correction will remove all damage.
It depends, among other things, on the size of your collection and the work involved in handling the scans. The Consumers’ Association points out that cleaning, correcting and saving images also take time. Make a test scan and factor in these steps when estimating how long you want to spend on your whole collection.
Not necessarily. Scanning for personal use and publishing images publicly are two different things. The Government of the Netherlands says you may make a private copy of someone else’s copyright-protected photographs for your own use, but you may not simply distribute or publish them. The Dutch Data Protection Authority considers identifiable people to be personal data; the exception for personal or household use does not automatically apply when sharing images publicly. So check copyright and privacy before publishing.