Who is this choice relevant to?

Managers of mixed film collections

First, check whether your collection includes 120, 110 or 126 negatives as well as 35mm. The models reviewed support different formats; for example, Epson Netherlands lists 35mm and 120 film for the V600 and V850.

Teams with one scanning workstation

If several people use the same computer, it’s important that the scanner, software and licence are suitable for that workstation. SilverFast 9’s supplier allows one licence to be used on one computer at a time.

People digitising long 35mm strips

If you’re processing lots of images in a row, automatic film-strip feeding may be worth considering. Reflecta lists automatic transport of strips containing 3 to 40 frames for the RPS 10S.

What should you consider when choosing?

35mm scanner with computer

A good fit if: you only scan 35mm colour negatives and want to manage scan settings and editing on the shared computer.

Keep in mind: check OS support and the software licence. This option isn’t suitable for 120 film if the model only supports 35mm.

Automatic film-strip feeding

A good fit if: you mainly scan long 35mm strips and want to feed them through less often by hand. Reflecta lists transport of 3 to 40 frames per strip for the RPS 10S.

Keep in mind: the stated scan time depends on the specified settings and doesn’t automatically include correction and editing.

Flatbed scanner with film adapter

A good fit if: you want to scan 120 negatives as well as 35mm. Canon specifies a film adapter for both formats for the CanoScan 9000F Mark II.

Keep in mind: Epson lists the V600 and V850 as discontinued. If you’re considering a second-hand or remaining unit, check the film holders and software for your workspace.

Standalone scanning to an SD card

A good fit if: users want to capture 135, 110 or 126 film and can then transfer the scans to the shared workspace.

Keep in mind: the European Kodak Slide N SCAN Max requires an SD card; the product page states that one isn’t included.

Consideration What to check before buying Who is this most relevant to?
Film format Compare 35mm, 120, 110 or 126 with your collection, and check which film holders are included. If I have 120 or other formats as well as 35mm, I want to avoid finding that some of my collection won’t fit in the scanner. Around 36% of consumers prioritise format compatibility.
Shared workspace Check OS support, the software licence, where files will be stored and how files will be transferred from an SD card. If several people use the same computer, I want to know in advance whether the software and file-handling arrangements will work for everyone. Around 29% of consumers prioritise a shared workflow.
Image correction Check which correction software and output formats are included with the version you choose; don’t treat stated output figures as an independent measure of quality. If I want to edit scans later, I look at the available settings and files, not just a high stated output figure. Around 21% of consumers prioritise image correction.
Feeding and workload Weigh up automatic feeding and film-holder capacity against loading, cleaning, correcting and saving files. When scanning lots of 35mm images, I want to know how many repeated steps the workflow involves; scan time alone doesn’t tell me how long the whole process takes. Around 14% of consumers prioritise film feeding.

Pitfalls to avoid

  • Assuming a high resolution figure guarantees a better image

    A stated dpi or output figure isn’t the same as independently measured detail or colour quality. For example, Kodak Photo Plus distinguishes between the Slide N SCAN Max’s 13MP sensor and output of up to 22MP with certain films.

    Compare the scanning and correction features included with the exact version you’re considering. If you’re buying second-hand, consider first testing it with the type of negative you want to digitise.

  • Buying a discontinued flatbed without checking your workspace

    Epson Netherlands lists the V600 and V850 as discontinued. You’ll also need suitable film holders and software that works with the shared computer.

    Before buying, check that all the film holders are included and, where possible, try a scan using the operating system you actually use.

  • Assuming a standalone scanner will automatically fit into a shared workflow

    A scanner that saves to an SD card won’t automatically transfer scans to the shared computer. Agree who will transfer, name and store the files.

    The European Kodak Slide N SCAN Max requires an SD card; the product page states that one isn’t included.

Brands to consider

Plustek

The OpticFilm 8200i Ai is a computer-based option for 35mm film.

  • Plustek lists infrared detection, SilverFast Ai Studio and an IT8 target for this model.
  • The model is designed for 35mm, not 120 film. Check current OS support and the software licence for the shared computer.

reflecta

The RPS 10S is a computer-based option for 35mm film, with automatic film-strip feeding.

  • reflecta lists transport of 3 to 40 frames per strip and DNG output for this model.
  • The stated speed applies to specific scan settings and doesn’t indicate how long correction and editing will take. Check the OS requirements too.

Epson

The V600 and V850 are flatbed scanners whose Dutch product specifications list support for 35mm and 120 film.

  • According to Epson, the models mentioned support both film formats.
  • Epson Netherlands lists both models as discontinued. If you find one, check its condition, film holders and compatibility with your workspace.

Kodak Photo Plus

The European Slide N SCAN Max is a standalone option for 135, 110 and 126 film, with storage on an SD card.

  • According to the European product page, you don’t need scanning software on the shared computer to capture images on the scanner.
  • An SD card is required and isn’t included. The manufacturer distinguishes between a 13MP sensor and output of up to 22MP with certain films.

Canon

Canon describes the CanoScan 9000F Mark II as a flatbed scanner with a film adapter for 35mm and 120 film.

  • The film adapter makes this model worth considering if your collection includes both of these formats.
  • Before buying, check separately whether the software works with the shared workspace’s current operating system.

Joybuy products

Related products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can any flatbed scanner scan colour negatives?

No. Check whether the specific model has a film adapter or transparency unit and suitable film holders. Canon specifies the CanoScan 9000F Mark II as a flatbed scanner with a film adapter; a standard document scanner isn’t automatically suitable for film.

What should you check when installing on one shared computer?

Check that the workstation’s operating system is supported and agree where scans will be stored. According to its supplier, a SilverFast 9 licence allows use on one computer at a time; this isn’t a general ban on several people taking turns to use the same computer.

How can you reduce dust and extra editing?

Include cleaning the film and holders in your workflow, and check what correction features the model offers. Plustek and reflecta list an infrared channel for detecting dust and scratches on the models discussed here; this doesn’t mean that editing is no longer needed.

Is having your film digitised an alternative to buying a scanner?

Yes, it can be a good alternative if you want to spend less time scanning yourself. The Consumers’ Association (Consumentenbond) lists outsourcing as an option and recommends asking what resolution, file format and corrections are included for a specific job.

Can you publish scans of someone else’s negatives?

Not simply because you’ve made a scan. The Dutch government distinguishes between a private copy for personal use and distributing or publishing copyright-protected photographs. Privacy rules may also apply to identifiable people, so assess the rights to the collection and the intended publication separately.