Which scanner is right for you?

Archivist with mixed film formats

If you want to preserve old portraits and your collection includes 120 negatives as well as 35mm, check which holders the scanner supports for each format. Epson lists holders for 35mm and 120/220 film with the Perfection V600 Photo; a dedicated 35mm scanner won’t automatically support those formats.

Careful portrait scanner

If you want to review and edit important 35mm portraits, taking extra time over each image may suit the way you work. Check what type of film you have: according to LaserSoft Imaging, infrared correction does not work in the same way with traditional silver-based black-and-white film as it does with colour film.

Practical family archivist

If your collection is growing and you mainly want to view, share and preserve images, compare a standalone scanner with a computer-based workflow. The Consumers’ Association points out that the size of your collection, the quality you want and the time you have available all matter. Also check how your chosen model saves files.

What should you look for when choosing?

First, take stock of your film formats, then decide how much control you need over the finished portraits and processing time. This will help you compare the right type of scanner and the key checks to make before buying.

What to consider What should you check? Who should pay particular attention?
Film format and holders List the formats you have and check which holders are compatible with the exact model. If I want to scan both 35mm and 120 film, I need to know that there’s a suitable holder for each format. Around 33% of consumers prioritise format compatibility.
Detail, colour and restoration Check the output formats and correction options offered by the model, and bear the film type in mind. For important portraits, I want to be able to review the files and edit them if needed, without assuming that one correction feature works with every film type. Around 27% of consumers prioritise image quality and restoration.
Workflow speed Check how you load and save negatives, and whether the quoted scan times include the other steps involved. If I want to process lots of images one after another, the whole workflow matters to me: loading the holders, scanning and organising the files. Around 20% of consumers prioritise a manageable workflow speed.
Requirements and workflow Check software compatibility, included accessories and whether a memory card is required; compare scanning at home with a detailed quote for a professional service. If I’m weighing up the purchase, extra requirements and professional scanning, I want to know what I’ll need to keep my chosen workflow going. Around 20% of consumers put total requirements and costs first.

Common pitfalls

  • Focusing only on a high dpi or megapixel figure

    The stated output resolution alone doesn’t tell you how much detail you’ll see in a scan. reflecta says that the x33-Scan’s higher output resolution of 5760 × 3840 pixels is interpolated.

    Compare the stated scan or sensor resolution, the output files and the editing you’ll need. Don’t focus only on the biggest figure on the box.

  • Assuming a 35mm holder can handle other film formats

    The models reviewed support different film formats. For 110 and 126 film, reflecta lists a separate adapter set for the x33-Scan.

    Match your negatives to the list of holders included with the exact model. If a format isn’t supported, you may need a separate adapter, a second device or a professional service.

  • Treating a discontinued flatbed model as readily available new

    Epson Netherlands lists the Perfection V600 Photo as discontinued. If you find one for sale, as remaining stock or second-hand, pay extra attention to its condition and the parts included.

    Before buying, check that all the film holders are included and that the software works with your computer. Checking these details may take extra research for a discontinued model.

  • Counting only the scan time per image as the total project time

    Quoted scan times aren’t the same as the total time needed for a collection. Loading negatives, removing dust, correcting images and organising files all take time too.

    Plan a trial run with your own collection and compare the full workflow with a detailed quote for a professional service.

Brands to consider

Plustek

The OpticFilm 8200i SE is a dedicated option for compatible 35mm negatives and slides if you want to scan using a computer.

  • Plustek says the model has an infrared channel, a USB connection and SilverFast SE Plus software included.
  • The stated 7200 dpi is a manufacturer’s specification, not an independent measurement. It scans 35mm film, so also check that the software is compatible with your computer.

Epson

The Perfection V600 Photo is a flatbed option if you want to scan 35mm and 120 negatives or printed photos.

  • Epson lists holders for two strips of six 35mm frames and for 120/220 film, as well as JPEG and TIFF output.
  • Epson Netherlands lists this model as discontinued. If you find one for sale, check its condition, holders and software compatibility.

reflecta

The standalone x33-Scan is designed for 35mm strips and mounted slides, with no computer needed while you scan.

  • reflecta says the model saves JPEG files to an SD card and includes holders for 35mm strips with up to six frames.
  • For 110 and 126 film, reflecta lists a separate adapter set. According to the manufacturer, the higher output resolution of 5760 × 3840 pixels is interpolated.

KODAK Photo Plus

The EU version of the Slide N Scan with a 5-inch screen is a standalone option for 135, 110 and 126 negatives.

  • The EU product page lists a 14MP sensor, a screen and film adapters included.
  • The same product page says an SD card is required; it isn’t included. The description of image quality comes from the manufacturer.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can I scan 120 negatives with a 35mm film scanner?

Don’t assume you can: the Plustek OpticFilm 8200i SE is designed for 35mm, while Epson lists support for 120/220 film separately for the Perfection V600 Photo. Check the format and the suitable holder for the exact model.

Will infrared correction automatically remove scratches from old black-and-white portraits?

Not necessarily with traditional silver-based black-and-white film. According to LaserSoft Imaging, infrared light can’t be used in the same way as it can with colour film. Check your film type and be prepared to use other software-based or manual correction.

What do I need to scan without a computer?

It depends on the model. reflecta says the x33-Scan saves JPEG files to an SD card; according to the EU product page, the KODAK Slide N Scan reviewed requires an SD card, which isn’t included.

Who should I contact if a scanner I bought from a shop in the Netherlands is faulty?

If the product is faulty, contact the retailer: according to the Dutch government, they can’t simply send you to the manufacturer. For eligible online purchases, you’re also often entitled to a 14-day cooling-off period. This is separate from the remedy for a faulty product.

Where can I take an old electric scanner?

According to the Dutch government, you can return an old, similar device to a shop when you buy a new one. Ask the shop whether you can return your scanner there.