Who is this buying guide for?

A group with mixed film formats

You have more than one negative format and want to avoid finding that some of your collection won’t fit in the scanner holders.

Volunteers creating archival copies

You want to be able to correct images later and keep them as a managed collection, even if scanning involves more steps.

A group with lots of 35mm negatives

You want to minimise the handling required for each image and check the results as you work.

What should you look for when buying?

First, take stock of your film formats. Then decide whether straightforward output, control and editing, or organising archival copies is most important.

What to consider What should you look for? Who is this most important for?
Film formats Check which formats and holders are included with the exact model, and which you’ll need to buy separately. reflecta and KODAK Photo Plus list different supported formats and adapters. If our collection includes both 35mm and 120 film, for example, I want to know in advance whether both formats will fit in the holders. Around 33% of consumers put film-format compatibility first.
Editability Check the output options, software and correction features available with the model, and assess a representative test scan for your intended use. Plustek lists 48-bit colour output and an infrared channel for the OpticFilm 8300i SE. If we want to correct scans later and manage them as archival copies, I want control over the scan and the file. Around 25% of consumers make editability their top priority.
Workflow speed Compare stated scan times with the entire workflow: loading the film, naming the files and checking the results. Before you begin, try a test batch using the same settings and division of tasks as you plan to use for the project. With a large pile of negatives, I want to know how long volunteers will spend on the full process for each image. Around 25% of consumers put workflow speed first.
File management Agree who will check and name the files, and where copies will be stored. The Library of Congress recommends keeping copies on at least two different storage media. If we want to keep the scans as a group collection, I want to agree in advance how they’ll be checked, accessed and copied. Around 17% of consumers make collection management their top priority.

Common pitfalls

  • Confusing a document scanner with a film scanner

    A scanner needs to be able to shine light through negative film and have a suitable film holder. The word ‘scanner’ alone doesn’t tell you whether it can do this.

    Check the product page for the exact model to see which film formats and holders it supports.

  • Comparing interpolated megapixels with the sensor specification

    For the reflecta x66-Scan, reflecta distinguishes between a 14MP sensor and an interpolated 22MP output mode. These are different specifications and, on their own, don’t tell you what a scan will look like for your intended use.

    Compare the native sensor specification and view a test scan for your intended use, rather than choosing based only on the highest megapixel count.

  • Mistaking a quick JPEG scan for a complete archival copy

    A scan doesn’t automatically create an organised collection. You’ll need separate arrangements and storage media for file names, checks and backup copies.

    Before scanning, agree who will check the files, how they’ll be named and where copies will be stored. The Library of Congress recommends keeping copies on different storage media.

    Allow extra time for file management and for the storage media the group plans to use for copies.

Brands to compare

reflecta

The x44-Scan and x66-Scan are standalone options. Compare them based on the film format you need and the specific holders available.

  • According to reflecta, both models save JPEGs directly to an SD card. The x66-Scan is designed for formats including 35mm, 120 and 127 film.
  • For the x44-Scan, holders for 110 and 126 film are optional. According to reflecta, the x66-Scan has a 14MP sensor and an interpolated 22MP output mode; this isn’t an independent comparison of scan results.

Plustek

The OpticFilm 8300i SE is a computer-connected film scanner for 35mm negatives, with software and infrared support according to Plustek.

  • Plustek lists 48-bit colour output and an infrared channel as part of the scanning workflow.
  • It scans 35mm film only. Plustek notes that infrared scanning takes extra time; also check that the software will work on the group’s computer.

KODAK Photo Plus

The SLIDE N SCAN Max is a standalone option if the supplied adapters fit the formats you have.

  • According to the EU product page, adapters for 110, 126 and 135 film are included, along with JPEG storage.
  • The retailer says an SD card isn’t included. The product information doesn’t provide a basis for ranking its image quality against other models.

Epson

The Perfection V600 Photo and V850 Pro are transparency flatbeds worth considering if the group already has one or is looking at a used model.

  • Epson lists film holders and support for 35mm and 120/220 film for both models.
  • Epson Netherlands marks both models as discontinued on its product pages. If the group already has one or is considering a used scanner, check its condition, holders and software.

Joybuy products

Related products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

How should volunteers prepare negatives for scanning?

Work on a clean surface and handle the film as little as possible. The Library of Congress recommends well-fitting, clean, lint-free cotton or nitrile gloves. If an original is fragile or badly damaged, consider having it assessed first.

Is an SD card enough for archiving?

No. An SD card for the scanner isn’t a complete archiving solution on its own. Organise the files and keep checked copies on at least two different storage media, as recommended by the Library of Congress.

What other items should the group check?

For each model you’re considering, check whether the holders and storage media you need are included. According to the EU retailer, the KODAK SLIDE N SCAN Max requires an SD card, which isn’t supplied. The Plustek OpticFilm 8300i SE requires a computer and software with their own system requirements.

Can the group publish scans featuring identifiable people online?

First, check the relevant privacy and copyright requirements for your intended use. The Dutch Data Protection Authority considers identifiable people in photographs to be personal data and says that publication beyond personal or household use requires a legal basis. Permission from the photographer to use a copyright-protected image is a separate matter. Assess both issues for each photograph and intended use.